Gavel of Shame

Judge Frank Mora Ordered Removed for Suing Complainant

Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist
Updated
Read time 19 min
The Short Answer

On August 21, 2026, the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct determined that Frank M. Mora, a judge of the Poughkeepsie City Court in Dutchess County since 2011, should be removed from the bench. All eleven participating members agreed on removal. The Commission found he retaliated against an ophthalmology office manager who had filed a confidential complaint about him, by suing her for defamation over the very statements in that complaint, and separately that he refused to leave her workplace after repeated requests until police were called twice. Three things most coverage has missed. The Commission overrode its own hearing referee, who had found that charge unproven. The Court of Appeals suspended him on its own motion, not at anyone’s request. And while all of this was pending, Mora filed a petition for certiorari in the United States Supreme Court, which is still live.

Judge Frank Mora Ordered Removed for Suing Complainant
CASE FILE AT A GLANCE
Judge Frank M. Mora
Court Poughkeepsie City Court
County Dutchess County, New York
Admitted / On the Bench Admitted in New York 1997; judge since 2011
Current Term Expires December 31, 2030
Formal Complaint Dated January 14, 2025, three charges
Referee Peter Bienstock, Esq.; hearing October 15 to 17, 2025; report April 9, 2026
Oral Argument June 18, 2026, before the Commission
Determination August 21, 2026, removal; eleven members concurring
Dissent Stefano Cambareri, as to Charge I only
Status Suspended with pay by the Court of Appeals, September 17, 2026, No. 115

A Mask Dispute That Would Not End

On December 28, 2021, Mora brought one of his children to an ophthalmology practice in Poughkeepsie for an eye examination. The practice required masks: signs on the front door, a line in the appointment confirmation texts, and, by the office manager’s testimony, roughly half the patient base elderly and the protocols taken seriously. Mora wore a clear plastic face shield, open at the bottom and sides, which did not comply. About 15 to 20 patients filled the waiting room.

A receptionist asked him to mask. He refused, citing a medical condition he did not identify or document. She asked him to wait outside; he refused that too. A supervisor called the office manager, who asked him to mask, then asked for documentation, then asked him to mask or step outside, and told him she would call the police if he did not. He refused each time. She repeated the request to leave more than once, in front of the waiting patients, and then had the police called. They were called twice. He stayed, by her estimate, 30 to 40 minutes after first being asked to leave, and walked out as an officer was being dispatched.

He had done this before. In a footnote the Commission records that about eleven months earlier, in January 2021, Mora came to the same practice with an older child, again in a face shield, and again refused requests to put on a mask. That time he waited outside while his child, masked, had the appointment. He knew the policy, and he knew the workaround.

The medical explanation arrived afterward, and kept changing. He had no diagnosis on the day. Shortly after leaving he asked his chiropractor for a letter, and emailed the office manager a letter dated that same afternoon saying he was medically unable to wear a mask. She then arranged for a doctor to examine his child that day, with the two of them escorted in through a side door. In late April 2022, after the Commission wrote asking him to respond to the complaint, he consulted a licensed clinical social worker who diagnosed a form of object phobia. At the hearing in 2025 he said he had not left because he was having a panic attack, and acknowledged he never told the office manager that. A June 13, 2022 letter that Mora wrote and a practice employee signed described him as calm throughout.

He also went back. On May 20, 2022, after he knew about the complaint, he returned for his own eye examination and spoke there with the employee who had witnessed the incident. The letter that employee signed is dated three weeks later.

Suing the Woman Who Complained About Him

She filed her complaint on December 29, 2021, the day after the incident, using the form on the Commission’s website. On April 12, 2022, the Commission wrote asking Mora to answer questions about his conduct, and under section 2.6(D) of the Commission’s Policy Manual the letter enclosed a copy of her complaint. That is how he learned who had complained and what she had said.

One year to the day after she filed, on December 29, 2022, Mora sued her for defamation in Dutchess County Supreme Court, seeking $425,000, consisting of $250,000 compensatory and $175,000 punitive. His verified complaint identified five statements from her Commission complaint as false and libelous, and pleaded that her conduct had required him to answer her false claims before a state commission designed and empowered to investigate judicial misconduct. She was served at her workplace on January 3, 2023.

The lawyer Mora retained for that suit testified that Mora was very angry and wanted her to pay, because the Commission’s own process could not award him money damages even if her complaint were dismissed as meritless. That lawyer told him directly that suing a Commission complainant does not look good for a judge. Mora filed anyway. He did not consult the separate ethics counsel already representing him before the Commission, or New York’s Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics, which he testified he otherwise consulted regularly.

She and the Commission, which intervened to protect her, moved to dismiss on absolute privilege and New York’s anti-SLAPP statute. His lawyer advised him again to withdraw before the motion was decided. He refused again. On April 4, 2023, Justice Maria Rosa dismissed the suit and ordered Mora to pay the office manager’s attorney’s fees, writing that letting judges sue Commission complainants would create a very real fear that others may be deterred from bringing legitimate and serious complaints before the Commission. He did not appeal. A month later the parties settled: Mora paid her $20,000, signed a letter of apology saying the suit should not have been brought in the first instance, and agreed to stay away from her and from the practice’s locations.

The Referee Said No, and the Commission Overruled Him

The Formal Written Complaint, dated January 14, 2025, carried three charges, not two. Charge I was the discourteous confrontation and the refusal to leave. Charge II was the retaliatory lawsuit. Charge III alleged that in responding to the Commission’s requests for information, Mora improperly withheld documents or improperly redacted what he did produce.

The referee heard three days of testimony in October 2025 and reported on April 9, 2026 that only Charge II was established, and that Charges I and III were not. Commission counsel sought removal. Mora argued all three charges should be dismissed, including the one the referee had sustained. After oral argument on June 18, 2026, the Commission dismissed Charge III but sustained Charge I in part, rejecting its own referee’s conclusion. It did not find the discourtesy, but it did find that the prolonged refusal to leave after repeated requests was itself misconduct, regardless of his tone.

One member, Stefano Cambareri, dissented as to Charge I and would have dismissed it. So the removal was unanimous among the eleven participating members, while the findings were not. Mora himself admitted he was wrong to refuse to leave and should have gone when asked, and admitted at the hearing that he should not have brought the lawsuit.

THE DISCIPLINE LADDER (NEW YORK)

New York’s Commission determines a sanction itself, up through admonition, censure and removal, rather than recommending one to a court. Under Judiciary Law § 44, a judge who disagrees has thirty days from receipt of the determination to request review by the Court of Appeals, and if no request is made the sanction is carried out. On review the court considers the record and may accept or reject the determined sanction, impose a different one including admonition, censure, removal or retirement, or impose none.

Separately, under section 44(8) the court may suspend a judge while a removal determination is pending. Pay is the default: a suspended judge receives the judicial salary unless the court directs otherwise, and if the court withholds pay and the suspension later ends, it may order back pay.

Why the Commission Treated This as Removal Territory

The Commission wrote that Mora appears to be the first New York judge ever to retaliate against a Commission complainant by suing her, and called doing so for $425,000 aggressive and egregious. In a footnote to its sanction, it said that given the seriousness of retaliating against a complainant it would find removal appropriate on that misconduct alone.

A judicial disciplinary system has no investigators patrolling courtrooms; it runs on members of the public being willing to come forward. If a judge can answer a complaint with a lawsuit, the next person decides it is not worth it. The Commission treated as aggravating that Mora never appeared to accept that his lawsuit could deter future complainants, even after a sitting justice told him so in writing while dismissing it, and that he overrode his own lawyer’s advice twice. He admitted the suit was a mistake; what the Commission found he never grasped was its effect on everyone who was not him.

The Rules He Broke

Rule What It Requires
22 NYCRR 100.1 A judge shall uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary and observe high standards of conduct so that integrity and independence are preserved.
22 NYCRR 100.2(A) A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.
22 NYCRR 100.4(A)(2) A judge shall conduct extra-judicial activities so that they do not detract from the dignity of judicial office.
N.Y. Const. art. VI, § 22(a) The constitutional basis for discipline for cause, cited in the Commission’s conclusion.
Judiciary Law § 44(1) The statutory basis for discipline, also cited in the conclusion. Section 44(4) is the proceeding under which the determination issued.

The Other Mora Case, Still Live at the Supreme Court

Mora sought a religious exemption from New York’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate for court personnel, was denied, was ordered out of his courtroom in January 2022 for being unvaccinated, and sued the state court system in federal court. The district court dismissed in September 2023. The Second Circuit affirmed by summary order on March 30, 2026, with the mandate issuing April 21.

On August 26, 2026, five days after the Commission determined he should be removed, Mora filed a petition for certiorari in the United States Supreme Court, No. 26-261. It presents two questions: whether an appointed municipal judge is categorically excluded from Title VII’s definition of employee as an appointee on the policy making level under 42 U.S.C. section 2000e(f), or whether that exclusion requires a functional inquiry; and whether a state employer violates the Free Exercise Clause by denying a religious vaccine exemption on the ground that the applicant’s sworn beliefs are insufficiently internally consistent. The petition was pending as of publication, and no action on it appears in the Court’s October 2026 order lists.

None of that is part of the charges here, and the Commission did not treat it as misconduct. It is worth noting for two reasons. The first is practical: it is the one proceeding in which Mora is still on offense. The second is a wrinkle. To make the Title VII argument he describes himself as a judge appointed by the city’s mayor, while the Commission’s determination records him as a judge since 2011 with a term running to the end of 2030. Whether a city court judge is an employee or a policy-level appointee is exactly the question the Supreme Court is being asked.

What Would Happen to Her in Texas

The right Texas question is not how to file a complaint. It is whether a Texas complainant could be sued the way she was, and the answer turns on three things New York’s record exposes.

Her name

Mora learned who complained because the Commission’s policy manual told it to enclose her complaint with its inquiry letter. Texas is built differently, though less firmly than it first appears. Government Code § 33.0321 provides that on the request of a complainant, the commission may keep the complainant’s identity confidential. Section 33.032(e) adds that when a judge asks for the number, nature and disposition of complaints against him, the Commission may refuse to release a complainant’s identity. Both are permissive, and the first requires the complainant to ask. Section 33.0211(a)(1) requires the complaint file to contain the name, so the name is always there. A Texas complainant who knows to request confidentiality is in a materially better position than the office manager was. One who does not ask may be in the same one.

His grievance

The Commission could not award him money even if the complaint were meritless. Texas closed that gap in 2025. Section 33.02115, added by Senate Bill 293 and effective September 1, 2025, lets the Commission impose an administrative penalty on a person who knowingly files a false complaint, up to $500 for a first, up to $2,500 for a second, and $5,000 to $10,000 for each one after that, with the order a public record published on the Commission’s website. A Texas judge in Mora’s position now has a remedy inside the system, which is the thing he said he lacked. The same provision is a new exposure for complainants, and the word knowingly is carrying a great deal of weight.

Her lawsuit

If a Texas judge sued anyway, the complainant’s answer is the Texas Citizens Participation Act, Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 27. Section 27.001(4)(A)(ii) defines the exercise of the right to petition to include a communication in or pertaining to an official proceeding, other than a judicial proceeding, to administer the law, which is what a judicial-conduct complaint is. She would move to dismiss within 60 days of service under section 27.003(b), all discovery would be suspended on filing, the hearing would be set within 60 days and the ruling due within 30 days of its close, and the judge would have to establish by clear and specific evidence a prima facie case on every element to survive. On dismissal, section 27.009(a) says the court shall award the complainant court costs and reasonable attorney’s fees, and may add sanctions sufficient to deter similar suits.

That is faster and surer than what she got. She had to litigate for three months, with the Commission intervening on her behalf, before a justice dismissed the case and awarded fees. One limit worth noting: section 33.031 bars any award of costs or attorney’s fees in a Commission proceeding itself, so the fee shifting lives entirely in the civil courts.

THE TEXAS SANCTION LADDER

Private admonition, warning or reprimand, which the public never sees; an order of additional education; the same three sanctions issued publicly; and public censure, the most severe sanction the Commission can impose by itself. What it cannot do is remove a judge. Removal runs through a Review Tribunal of appellate justices with an appeal to the Texas Supreme Court, and a judge sanctioned short of removal can instead demand a Special Court of Review and a fresh trial. That is the structural difference from New York, where the Commission determines the sanction and the Court of Appeals reviews it, which is why Mora is suspended today rather than waiting on a recommendation.

What Proposition 12 Changed

Texas voters approved Proposition 12 on November 4, 2025 by 61.9 percent to 38.1 percent, on Senate Joint Resolution 27 of the 89th Legislature, effective January 1, 2026, with its temporary provisions expiring January 1, 2031. The Commission stays at thirteen members but is rebuilt: six judges, at least two of them trial judges, and seven citizens appointed by the governor with Senate confirmation, with the minimum age raised from 30 to 35 and the State Bar’s appointed attorney seats removed. Sitting commissioners’ terms expire July 1, 2026, which is why recent Texas orders in this series are signed by an interim chair.

On authority, the Commission may handle a judge who has never been sanctioned and is not accused of a criminal offense privately, including by requiring training. Where it finds willful or persistent conduct clearly inconsistent with the proper performance of duties, it must sanction publicly unless it issues a private sanction, and it may refer removal or retirement to the Review Tribunal or recommend suspension to the Supreme Court. The Tribunal is seven appellate justices selected by the Chief Justice, and Proposition 12 struck the old requirement that they be drawn by lot from a list each court of appeals contributed to. It must act within 90 days of receiving the record, may order suspension without pay for a set period, and on removal or involuntary retirement for disability must bar the person from future judicial office, where that was previously discretionary.

Senate Bill 293 added the statutory pieces in the same session. Besides the false-complaint penalty, it created a seven-year limitations period in section 33.02111: the Commission may not investigate and shall dismiss a complaint filed on or after the seventh anniversary of the misconduct, or of when the complainant knew or should have known of it, unless it finds good cause. Note what that does and does not do. It limits how late a complaint may be filed. It says nothing about how long the Commission may take once one is filed, which is the delay this series keeps running into.

Texas also had its own judge leave the bench mid-proceeding this year. Judge Rosie Speedlin Gonzalez of Bexar County Court at Law No. 13 was suspended without pay in February 2026 after a defense attorney was handcuffed and placed in the jury box during a probation revocation hearing, and resigned in April 2026 under a voluntary agreement in lieu of discipline carrying a lifetime bar from Texas judicial office. The agreement included no admission of wrongdoing, and the criminal charges filed against her were later dismissed by the special prosecutor. The disciplinary case ended with no finding either way, which is its own lesson: not every matter produces a determination like the one Mora is contesting.

How It Played in the Press

Mid Hudson News followed this from the start, from the January 2023 defamation filing through the removal determination to the September 17 suspension. The Times Union covered the dismissal of the lawsuit in April 2023. The ABA Journal and News 12 Westchester both picked up the determination, including his counsel’s on-the-record statement that he would take it up. One correction worth making to the coverage: the suspension is routinely described as following the Commission’s recommendation, but New York’s Commission does not recommend, it determines, and the Court of Appeals acted on its own motion.

Where Things Stand Now

The Court of Appeals order is one page. On the Court’s own motion, Mora is suspended with pay, effective immediately, under article VI section 22 of the New York Constitution and Judiciary Law section 44(8), pending review of the Commission’s determination. Chief Judge Wilson and Judges Garcia, Singas, Cannataro, Troutman and Halligan concurred. Judge Rivera took no part. The matter is No. 115.

That is the identical posture, and the identical bench, as the other New York removal in this series: the Court suspended Judge Joseph Kasper with pay on August 27, 2026, with Rivera again taking no part (File 38). Two judges the Commission has ordered removed are drawing salaries while the Court of Appeals decides, which is what New York’s statute contemplates.

The thirty-day window to seek review ran from his receipt of the August 21 determination and has long since closed. The Court’s order recites that review is pending, and his counsel said publicly he intended to pursue it. On review the Court may accept the Commission’s findings and impose removal, substitute a lesser sanction, or impose none at all. No argument date has been announced, and nothing further has been posted on the Commission’s news page. His term otherwise runs to December 31, 2030.

Facing the System in Texas?

Judges answer to rules too, and the systems built to enforce them only work if people are willing to use them. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas.

Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com

Sources

PRIMARY SOURCES

  • New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Determination, In the Matter of Frank M. Mora (Aug. 21, 2026). cjc.ny.gov
  • New York Court of Appeals, No. 115, In the Matter of the Hon. Frank M. Mora, suspension order (Sept. 17, 2026). cjc.ny.gov
  • New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, case page and full record. cjc.ny.gov
  • New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, news page. cjc.ny.gov
  • N.Y. Judiciary Law § 44 (subdivisions 4, 7, 8 and 9). nysenate.gov
  • Petition for a writ of certiorari, Mora v. New York State Unified Court System, No. 26-261 (U.S. filed Aug. 26, 2026). supremecourt.gov

TEXAS AUTHORITY

  • Tex. Gov’t Code ch. 33 (§§ 33.0211, 33.02111, 33.02115, 33.031, 33.032, 33.0321, 33.034, 33.037). Texas Government Code
  • Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 27, Texas Citizens Participation Act (§§ 27.001, 27.003, 27.004, 27.005, 27.009). Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code
  • Texas Proposition 12 (2025), Senate Joint Resolution 27, 89th Legislature. ballotpedia.org

NEWS COVERAGE

  • Mid Hudson News, Judge suing office manager for defamation after argument over mask policy at doctor’s office (Jan. 3, 2023). midhudsonnews.com
  • Times Union, Poughkeepsie judge Frank Mora’s defamation lawsuit dismissed (Apr. 2023). timesunion.com
  • Mid Hudson News, Commission recommends ouster of city judge (Aug. 2026). midhudsonnews.com
  • Mid Hudson News, Poughkeepsie judge suspended (Sept. 17, 2026). midhudsonnews.com
  • ABA Journal, Judge should be benched for suing eye doc employee who filed complaint against him, agency says. abajournal.com
  • News 12 Westchester, Poughkeepsie judge should be removed for retaliating against doctor’s office manager. westchester.news12.com

REFERENCE

  • Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, how to file a complaint. scjc.texas.gov
  • Deandra Grant Law, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained. texasdwisite.com
  • The Commission’s findings, its quotations, and the Court of Appeals order are taken from the public record in the New York proceeding. The complainant is referred to by role and her employer is not named, because identifying either would undercut the confidentiality interest the determination exists to protect; the determination names both. Non-judge participants are referred to by role. The Commission’s determination has not been reviewed on the merits: a suspension pending review is not a finding of guilt, and nothing here implies the removal determination is final. The federal certiorari petition is a pending request for review, not a ruling. The comparison of Texas law, including the readings of Government Code chapter 33 and the Texas Citizens Participation Act, is our own analysis of the statutory text applied to a hypothetical Texas case, not a prediction of any outcome, and no Texas court has addressed these facts. This post summarizes public records and news reporting for general informational purposes as of publication and is not legal advice.
Where We Defend
Criminal Defense

Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.

Subscribe via RSSGet new DWI guides in your reader
Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By

Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist

She holds a Master of Science in Pharmaceutical Science and a Graduate Certificate in Forensic Toxicology, both from the University of Florida. She is the author of The Texas DWI Manual and has defended Texas DWI cases since 1994.

Full profile and credentials →

Your Defense Starts Now

Charged With a Crime?

Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.

3300 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75219
(214) 225-7117
4500 Airport Freeway, Suite 101
Fort Worth, TX 76117
(817) 631-6522
605 Austin Avenue, Suite 5
Waco, TX 76701
(254) 735-3588
1333 W. McDermott Drive, Suite 180
Allen, TX 75013
(972) 848-8828
1101 Ridge Road, Suite 201
Rockwall, TX 75087
(469) 253-6999
1317 E. McKinney Street, Suite 101A
Denton, TX 76209
(940) 600-5536
No Cost · No Obligation

Request a Free Case Evaluation

Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.