Who Polices the Bench? Inside the Texas SCJC
The State Commission on Judicial Conduct is the independent Texas agency that investigates complaints of judicial misconduct and judicial disability. Texas voters wrote it into the Constitution in 1965. Its thirteen members can discipline judges privately or publicly, suspend a judge who has been indicted, and refer a judge to a review tribunal for removal. What it cannot do is reverse a ruling or remove a judge on its own. Proposition 12, approved November 4, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, rebuilt both the membership and the authority. Three changes matter most and two of them have been widely misreported: the Commission can now issue a private sanction only to a judge who has never had one and only where no criminal conduct is alleged, outside that narrow lane its non-formal sanctions are public only; the review tribunal must now bar a removed judge from future judicial office rather than merely being allowed to; and the tribunal is no longer drawn by lot.

The foundational explainer for the series: who the Commission is, what it can and cannot do, who sits on it now, what each rung of discipline means, and what Proposition 12 actually changed when it took effect in 2026.
Welcome to the Gavel of Shame
Texas voters elect their judges. But once a judge puts on the robe, who holds them accountable when they cross the line, when they berate the people in front of them, ignore the law, or behave badly off the bench?
In this series we read the public discipline files so you do not have to. We break down real public sanctions: what the judge did, which rule they broke, and what happened next. Some of these stories are infuriating. All of them are public record.
What the Commission Is
The State Commission on Judicial Conduct is an independent Texas state agency headquartered in Austin. It is not a creation of the Legislature or of the courts. It sits directly in Article V, Section 1-a of the Texas Constitution, where voters put it in 1965. Government Code section 33.002 adds a line worth remembering: the Commission is an agency of the judicial branch and does not have the power or authority of a court in this state.
Its mission is to protect the public, promote confidence in the integrity, independence, competence and impartiality of the judiciary, and encourage judges to maintain high standards on and off the bench. It does that by investigating allegations of misconduct and incapacity.
What it is not is a court of appeals. It cannot reverse a ruling, release anyone from jail, take a judge off your case, or award you money. It reviews the judge’s conduct, not the outcome of any case.
Which Judges It Covers, and Which It Does Not
The Commission’s reach extends to municipal judges and magistrates, justices of the peace, constitutional county judges and county court at law judges, statutory probate judges, district and appellate judges, associate judges and masters, and retired and former judges sitting by assignment. Since a 2021 amendment, subsection (13-a) also lets the Commission act on complaints about candidates for judicial office the same way it acts on officeholders, which is why judicial candidates appear in this series by name.
Just as important is who it cannot touch. It has no authority over attorneys, including elected and assistant district attorneys, whose complaints go to the State Bar of Texas. It has none over federal judges and magistrates, whose complaints go through the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. And none over administrative hearing officers, private mediators and arbitrators, county and district clerks, law enforcement, jail conditions or prison officials. Each has its own channel, and the Commission’s FAQ lists where to send each one.
That distinction matters in criminal defense. If a prosecutor crosses an ethical line, the venue is the State Bar. The Commission is strictly about judges, and that is the lane this series stays in.
Who Sits on the Commission
Thirteen members, six-year terms, no compensation. Under Proposition 12 the split is six judges or justices appointed by the Supreme Court of Texas with Senate consent, at least two of whom must be trial court judges and no two of whom may sit on the same type of court, and seven citizens appointed by the Governor with Senate consent, each at least 35 years old. The two State Bar attorney seats that existed before 2026 are gone. The practical effect is that the Governor now appoints a majority, seven of thirteen, of the body that disciplines Texas judges. Supporters called it modernizing oversight; critics, including some former commissioners, warned it concentrates control in the Governor’s office.
Under the amendment’s temporary provision, every commissioner serving before January 1, 2026, saw their term expire July 1, 2026, and the Supreme Court and Governor appointed replacements to staggered two, four and six-year terms. This is the roster as the Commission currently posts it.
| Commissioner | Seat and Term |
| Hon. Wayne Money | Judge member, Greenville, Supreme Court appointee, term ends 12/31/2029 |
| Hon. Sid L. Harle | Judge member, San Antonio, Supreme Court appointee, term ends 12/31/2029 |
| Hon. Kevin Yeary | Judge member, Austin, Supreme Court appointee, term ends 12/31/2027 |
| Hon. Ana E. Estevez | Judge member, Amarillo, Supreme Court appointee, term ends 12/31/2027 |
| Hon. Grant Dorfman | Judge member, Houston, Supreme Court appointee, term ends 12/31/2031 |
| Hon. April I. Aguirre | Public member, Pasadena, Governor’s appointee, term ends 12/31/2029 |
| Hon. Yinon Weiss | Public member, Austin, Governor’s appointee, term ends 12/31/2031 |
| Hon. Tracy L. Harrison | Public member, Friendswood, Governor’s appointee, term ends 12/31/2031 |
| Hon. JJ Isbell | Public member, Houston, Governor’s appointee, term ends 12/31/2027 |
| Hon. Martin Deleon Jr. | Public member, Corpus Christi, Governor’s appointee, term ends 12/31/2027 |
Two things about that list. It shows ten of thirteen seats, so one judge seat and two public seats appear unfilled. And it names no officers, even though the Constitution requires the Commission to select one of its members as chair annually. The orders answer that question even though the roster does not: Justice Ken Wise of the Fourteenth Court of Appeals signed the August 2026 public sanctions as Interim Chair and signed the October 22, 2026 suspension order as Chair. He does not appear on the posted roster. If you are citing the membership for anything that matters, check the page the day you cite it.
One more transitional rule is worth knowing, because it explains some of the odd dates in this series. A complaint filed before January 1, 2026, was to be decided by the old commissioners unless it was still unresolved on July 1, 2026, in which case it passed to the new ones. That is why a 2021 complaint number can carry an August 2026 order signed by a commission seated weeks earlier.
What Proposition 12 Actually Changed
This section works from the enrolled text of Senate Joint Resolution 27 rather than from summaries. The Senate adopted it 27 to 4 on April 14, 2025, the House 119 to 17 on May 26, the Senate concurred 27 to 4 on May 30, and voters approved it on November 4, 2025.
Private discipline became a narrow exception, not a default
Before Prop 12, subsection (8) let the Commission issue a private or public admonition, warning, reprimand or education order, across the board, at its discretion. The amendment split that in two. New subsection (8)(i) allows a private order of admonition, warning, reprimand, censure or additional training only where the judge has never been issued an order under that subparagraph and only in response to a complaint that does not allege conduct constituting a criminal offense. New subsection (8)(ii) is the general power, and the words private or were struck from it.
The private lane is the whole ladder, including censure, but it is a one-time lane available only to a judge with no prior private order of that kind and only where no criminal conduct is alleged. Outside it, a non-formal sanction is public. The eligibility test is about prior private orders, not about a clean record generally.
After a formal hearing, a public sanction is mandatory
New subsection (8-a) handles what happens after formal proceedings or a Master’s report. If the Commission finds the judge engaged in willful or persistent conduct clearly inconsistent with the proper performance of a judge’s duties, or other good cause, it shall issue a public admonition, warning, reprimand, censure or education order, and it may recommend removal or retirement to a review tribunal. Note the pairing: the public sanction is mandatory and the removal referral is discretionary. The old text made the referral mandatory instead. Note also that this applies at the post-formal-hearing stage, not to every finding of willful or persistent conduct.
The tribunal got teeth, and lost the lottery
Subsection (9) changed in four ways. The review tribunal may now order suspension without pay for a specified period as a disposition, alongside public censure, retirement and removal. On removal or involuntary retirement for disability it shall prohibit the person from holding judicial office in the future, where the old text said may. It is composed of seven justices of the courts of appeals, as before, and must still act within 90 days of the record being filed, with an appeal to the Supreme Court under the substantial evidence rule.
The old text said the seven justices were selected by lot by the Chief Justice, and required each court of appeals to designate one of its members for the list from which the selection was made. Proposition 12 struck both. The seven are now selected by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, full stop. Several secondary sources, including widely cited ones, still describe the tribunal as drawn by lot. It is not, and that is a meaningful shift in who shapes the panel that removes a Texas judge.
One safeguard did not change. Subsection (12) provides that no judge covered by the section may sit as a member of the Commission in any proceeding involving that judge’s own suspension, discipline, censure, retirement or removal. The Constitution says nothing comparable about who selects the tribunal when the respondent is the Chief Justice who does the selecting.
A wording quirk worth knowing
Subsection (6)A contains two different standards. The removal standard reads willful or persistent conduct clearly inconsistent with the proper performance of duties. The sworn-complaint standard that supports a recommendation of suspension to the Supreme Court in the same subsection reads willful and persistent. This is why Commission orders quote the phrase inconsistently, and why a judge’s answer sometimes turns on which clause is being invoked. Read the order carefully.
What Counts as Judicial Misconduct
Judicial misconduct is conduct by a judge that brings discredit on the judiciary or the administration of justice. It can violate the Texas Constitution, the Penal Code, the Code of Judicial Conduct, or other Supreme Court rules. The recurring categories in this series are demeaning courtroom behavior, including yelling, profanity, bias or slurs; using the prestige of the office to advance private interests; communicating with only one side of a case; commenting publicly on a pending case; sitting on a case involving a financial interest or a close relative; alcohol, drug or mental health problems affecting the judge’s duties; off-bench conduct such as harassment, official oppression, theft, threats or driving while intoxicated; steering appointments to friends; endorsing a political candidate; and failing to cooperate with the Commission.
What is not misconduct is a wrong ruling. Even if a judge misapplies the law or rules against the weight of the evidence, that is an appeal, not a complaint. The Commission cannot be used as a back door to overturn a decision you disagree with.
The Sanctions Ladder
When an investigation finishes, the Commission votes. A quorum is seven members, and recommendations for retirement, censure, suspension or removal require at least seven affirmative votes rather than a bare majority of those present.
| Commission Action | What It Means |
| Dismissal | Not a sanction. The case is closed for no misconduct or insufficient evidence. A dismissed case can be reconsidered under section 33.035. |
| Order of additional education | Can stand alone or accompany a sanction. Used where a judge was misguided or exceeded authority without bad faith. |
| Admonition | The least severe formal sanction. An official finding of misconduct. Private only in the narrow subsection (8)(i) lane; otherwise public. |
| Warning | A step above admonition. Same private and public rules. |
| Reprimand | The most severe sanction available without formal proceedings. Same private and public rules. |
| Censure | Available privately only in the subsection (8)(i) lane, and publicly after formal proceedings. More serious than a reprimand. |
| Suspension on indictment | Public. On indictment for a felony or a charge of a misdemeanor involving official misconduct, the Commission must act immediately under Rule 10 of the Disciplinary Rules for Judges and Judicial Candidates: suspend with or without pay, file a misconduct complaint, or both. It takes seven votes. |
| Recommendation of removal or retirement | Public, after formal proceedings. The Commission cannot remove a judge. Only the review tribunal can, subject to appeal to the Supreme Court. |
| Voluntary agreement to resign | Public once the Commission accepts it. Twenty-one of the roughly ninety-six published indictment suspensions closed this way, and the agreement can carry a lifetime bar from Texas judicial office. |
| PRIVATE VERSUS PUBLIC, AND WHY IT MATTERS
Private sanction: the judge is disciplined and the complainant learns the outcome, but the judge’s name and the details stay confidential by law. The public never sees it. Public sanction: the order is published, the judge is named, and the conduct is described. This is the record the Gavel of Shame examines. Bottom line: public discipline is the only judicial discipline the public can see, and since January 1, 2026 the private route is a one-time exception rather than an open option. One more wrinkle under section 33.032(d): a judge’s disciplinary record, including private sanctions, is admissible in a later proceeding. A quiet first sanction is invisible to you but not to the Commission. |
How a Judge Fights a Sanction
A sanctioned judge is not stuck with the result. Under Government Code section 33.034, within 30 days of a sanction or censure the judge may ask the Chief Justice of the Texas Supreme Court to appoint a Special Court of Review. Within 10 days the Chief Justice selects three courts of appeals justices by lot, excluding any from the petitioning judge’s own appellate district and any serving on the Commission. The Commission then files a charging document within 15 days, which becomes public on filing. The hearing comes within 30 days of that filing, with continuances capped at 60 days total, and the decision within 60 days of the hearing.
The standard of review depends on which door the sanction came through. Review of a sanction issued in a formal proceeding is a review of the record, on the law and facts presented, plus any additional evidence the court permits for good cause. Only review of a sanction issued in an informal proceeding is a trial de novo, in the sense that term carries on appeal from justice to county court. There is no jury either way, and under section 33.034(i) the court’s decision is not appealable.
Keep that in mind reading the files: a public sanction on the books is one the judge either accepted or challenged and did not overturn.
Three Rules That Changed in 2025
Senate Bill 293 of the same legislative session added statutory machinery that gets almost no attention and that affects anyone thinking about filing.
Section 33.02111 created a seven-year limitations period. The Commission may not investigate and shall dismiss a complaint filed on or after the seventh anniversary of the misconduct, or of the date the complainant knew or reasonably should have known of it, unless it finds good cause. Note what it does not do: it limits how late a complaint may be filed, and says nothing about how long the Commission may take afterward.
Section 33.02115 created a penalty for a false complaint. A person who knowingly files one faces an administrative penalty of up to $500 for a first, up to $2,500 for a second, and $5,000 to $10,000 for each one after, and the order is a public record published on the Commission’s website. The operative word is knowingly. A complaint that turns out to be unfounded is not a false complaint.
Section 33.0321 lets you ask for confidentiality of your identity. On the request of a complainant the Commission may keep it confidential, and section 33.032(e) says that when a judge asks for the number, nature and disposition of complaints against him, the Commission may refuse to release a complainant’s identity. Both are permissive and the first requires you to ask, so ask in the complaint itself. Section 33.0211(a)(1) requires the file to contain your name either way.
Two older provisions round it out. Section 33.031 says court costs and attorney’s fees may not be awarded in a chapter 33 proceeding, to either side. And section 33.040 requires the Commission to report to the Legislature each year how many complaints it failed to finalize within 270 days of filing, which is the only statutory pressure on its own pace.
How to File a Complaint
You do not need a lawyer and you do not need permission. Anyone can file about any Texas judge, including a defendant who believes the judge in their own case crossed a line. But the Commission is specific about the form, and it is stricter than most people expect.
The complaint must be a completed, signed, sworn complaint form, printed and mailed. You can download the form in English or Spanish in fillable PDF, or request a paper form by phone at (512) 463-5533 or toll free at (877) 228-5750. The mailing address is P.O. Box 12265, Austin, Texas 78711. There is no filing fee.
The Commission does not accept complaints by online form, telephone, email or fax. A phone call will get you a form in the mail and nothing else.
After that: papers and proceedings are confidential before formal charges are filed, under section 33.032(a) and article V, section 1-a(10). Expect status notices at least quarterly under section 33.0211(b), and you may add supporting documentation within 45 days of filing. If a public sanction issues it becomes public; private sanctions and dismissals do not.
If your case is pending, talk to your lawyer first. A complaint does not pause anything, and there may be a recusal motion or an appellate remedy that actually addresses your problem. Those run on separate tracks with their own deadlines, and the Commission cannot reach any of them.
A Note on the National Edition
Most files in this series are Texas Commission files. The National Edition files are the ones from outside Texas, and they are include state judges disciplined by their own states’ bodies: New York’s Commission on Judicial Conduct, which determines sanctions itself subject to review by the Court of Appeals; Maryland’s Commission on Judicial Disabilities, which can only recommend; Wisconsin’s Judicial Commission, which routes cases through a three-judge panel before the Supreme Court finalizes discipline; New Hampshire’s Judicial Conduct Committee; Louisiana’s Judiciary Commission; Michigan’s Judicial Tenure Commission; and others. We run them because the comparison is instructive, and because the Texas answer to the same problem is often different in a way worth knowing.
A few National Edition files do involve the federal system, either because a judge was prosecuted in federal court or because the respondent is a federal judge. For an Article III judge the framework is the Judicial Conduct and Disability Act of 1980, 28 U.S.C. sections 351 through 364. A complaint goes first to the chief judge of the relevant circuit, then in serious cases to a special investigative committee and the circuit’s judicial council, and on review to the Committee on Judicial Conduct and Disability of the Judicial Conference of the United States. Sanctions short of impeachment include private and public reprimand, an order temporarily suspending case assignments, and a request that the judge retire voluntarily. Only Congress can remove an Article III judge, by impeachment, and only fifteen federal judges in the history of the United States have been impeached by the House.
National Edition files use the same format as the Texas entries. The framework above is the one that applies when the respondent is a federal judge, and the state frameworks apply when the respondent is a state judge, which is the usual case.
What Comes Next
Now you have the machinery: the body, its membership, what misconduct is, where each sanction falls, what Proposition 12 actually changed, what the 2025 statutes added, how a judge fights a sanction, and how the out-of-state files work. The rest of the series opens the files: real judges, real public orders, and the conduct that earned them.
| The Judge Assigned to Your Case Matters
At Deandra Grant Law we are in North Texas courtrooms every week. We know these judges, these courts, and how they run. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall or McLennan County, put that experience on your side. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
PRIMARY SOURCES
- Senate Joint Resolution 27, 89th Legislature (2025), enrolled text, amending Tex. Const. art. V, § 1-a subdivisions (2), (3), (8) and (9) and adding (2-a), (2-b) and (8-a). This is the controlling text for every Proposition 12 change described above. capitol.texas.gov
- Senate Research Center, Bill Analysis, S.J.R. 27, enrolled (July 21, 2025). capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Gov’t Code ch. 33 (§§ 33.002, 33.0211, 33.02111, 33.02115, 33.031, 33.032, 33.0321, 33.034, 33.035, 33.037, 33.038, 33.040). Texas Government Code
- Supreme Court of Texas, Disciplinary Rules for Judges and Judicial Candidates (Apr. 1, 2026), Rule 10 (felonies and official-misconduct misdemeanors) and Rule 15 (votes required). txcourts.gov
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 2. law.uh.edu
COMMISSION RECORDS
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct, home. scjc.texas.gov
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Commissioners (roster as posted). scjc.texas.gov
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Complaints, including the form and the list of methods it does not accept. scjc.texas.gov
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct, FAQ. scjc.texas.gov
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Suspensions. scjc.texas.gov
FEDERAL FRAMEWORK
- Judicial Conduct and Disability Act of 1980, 28 U.S.C. §§ 351 to 364. law.cornell.edu
- Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, Judicial Conduct and Disability. uscourts.gov
BACKGROUND
- Ballotpedia, Texas Proposition 12 (2025). Note that its description of the review tribunal as selected by lot reflects the pre-2026 text. ballotpedia.org
- Houston Public Media, Proposition 12 would enhance the governor’s powers over elected judges (Oct. 27, 2025). houstonpublicmedia.org
- This post provides general information about a public agency and public records. It is not legal advice, and the description of the complaint process is not a substitute for advice about your own case. It does not allege wrongdoing by any judge beyond what appears in published public sanctions. The account of what Proposition 12 changed is taken from the enrolled text of Senate Joint Resolution 27 rather than from secondary summaries, several of which describe the review tribunal as selected by lot; that requirement was struck effective January 1, 2026. The roster above reflects the Commission’s posted membership as of October 29, 2026, which shows ten of thirteen seats filled and names no officers; the identification of the chair is drawn from the signature blocks of the Commission’s own 2026 orders. Membership changes, so verify it on the day you rely on it.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.