Gavel of Shame

Judge E. Mason Martin Ruled Before Hearing the Advocate

Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist
Updated
Read time 12 min
The Short Answer

On June 3, 2026, the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly admonished visiting judge E. Mason Martin and ordered additional education. Across three related child welfare cases involving the same child, a Court Appointed Special Advocate had been appointed as the child’s guardian ad litem. At hearing after hearing, that guardian was heard late or not at all, and only after the child’s attorney ad litem pushed for it. Texas law does not make this optional. The Family Code says the court shall ensure the guardian has an opportunity to testify.

Judge E. Mason Martin Ruled Before Hearing the Advocate

How a Montgomery County visiting judge drew a public admonition and an order of additional education for repeatedly ruling in child welfare cases before the child’s guardian ad litem had been heard

CASE FILE AT A GLANCE
Judge Hon. E. Mason Martin, visiting judge
Court Sitting by assignment, Conroe, Montgomery County
CJC Number 25-0232
Cases Three related Department of Family and Protective Services cases involving the same child, Cause Nos. 22-21330, 24-22367 and 24-22445
Conduct Hearings on May 24, July 19, September 6 and December 20, 2024
Reviewed Commission meeting of May 13, 2026
Date Issued June 3, 2026
Sanction Public admonition and order of additional education
Provisions Violated Canons 2A and 3B(2) of the Texas Code of Judicial Conduct
Education Two hours with a mentor on guardians ad litem, within 60 days of notice, on top of required FY 2026 judicial education
Signed By Gary Steel, Chair, State Commission on Judicial Conduct
Prior Discipline Public admonition and public warning, both December 2004

In a child welfare case the child at the center usually cannot speak for themselves. That is why Texas law provides for a guardian ad litem, often a trained volunteer through a Court Appointed Special Advocate program, to tell the court what is in the child’s best interest. The law does not leave it to chance. It requires the judge to make sure that voice is heard.

This is a quieter entry than most in this series. No lawsuit, no outburst, no headline conduct. It is a competence problem. In this kind of case, getting the procedure right is not a technicality. It is how the system keeps a child’s interests at the center of decisions about that child’s life.

What Happened

Judge Martin presided over three related cases brought by the Department of Family and Protective Services involving the same child. In each, a Court Appointed Special Advocate had been appointed as the child’s guardian ad litem.

On May 24, 2024, at the adversary hearing in the second case, the guardian was present and asked to give a best interest statement. The judge did not allow it. The guardian was finally permitted to testify at the next hearing, on July 19, 2024, but only after the child’s attorney ad litem told the judge about the earlier error, and only after he had already ruled.

The same pattern ran through the third case. On September 6, 2024, at that case’s adversary hearing, the guardian specifically asked to give a best interest statement and report before the judge ruled. At the hearing that followed, the guardian was allowed to present the report only after the attorney ad litem asked for it. On December 20, 2024, at an emergency hearing, the guardian was again allowed to testify only after the attorney ad litem asked once more. At one point the judge said the guardian’s testimony was not necessary, and allowed it only after deciding the guardian might have testimony that was necessary, relevant or appropriate.

What the Law Requires

Section 107.002(e) of the Texas Family Code is not ambiguous. Unless the guardian ad litem is an attorney appointed in the dual role and subject to the rules of evidence, the court shall ensure, in a hearing or in a trial on the merits, that the guardian has an opportunity to testify and is permitted to submit a report about the guardian’s recommendations on the best interests of the child and the bases for them.

The operative word is shall. It is a duty the court owes, not a request the guardian has to win.

The Legislature made it mandatory for the same reason the role exists. A guardian ad litem, and a volunteer advocate in particular, is often the one participant in the room whose only job is the child. Not the State’s case, not a parent’s position. Hearing that before deciding is how a court makes sure a best interest ruling is actually informed by the child’s best interest.

WHY THE GUARDIAN AD LITEM MUST BE HEARD

In a child welfare case the guardian ad litem, often a trained volunteer advocate, is frequently the one participant whose only job is the child. Section 107.002(e) of the Texas Family Code requires the court to ensure that voice has an opportunity to testify and submit a report on the child’s best interests. The word is shall. It is a duty the court owes, not a request the guardian has to win.

The Defense He Offered

In his answer to the Commission he denied failing to comply with or maintain competence in the law on the ground that the guardian ad litem was ultimately allowed to testify at the emergency hearing.

That is not what the statute asks. It does not ask whether the guardian eventually spoke. It requires the court to ensure the opportunity exists in the hearing, which in practice means before the court decides the question the guardian was appointed to address. Testimony heard after a ruling is a record, not an input. The Commission concluded he failed to ensure the guardian testified at hearings in the second and third cases, and that is the finding on which the admonition rests.

Why This Matters

The stakes in these cases are about as high as they get in a courtroom that is not a criminal one. Where a child lives, who cares for them, whether a family stays together. A ruling entered before the child’s advocate has been heard is a ruling missing something the law required first, and letting the guardian speak afterward does not put the sequence back in order.

What turned isolated moments into a discipline matter was the repetition. Four hearings, three cases, one child, and every time it took the attorney ad litem stepping in to secure a right the court was supposed to protect on its own.

The Rules He Broke

Rule What It Requires
Canon 2A A judge shall comply with the law.
Canon 3B(2) A judge shall maintain professional competence in the law.
Tex. Fam. Code sec. 107.002(e) The court shall ensure that a guardian ad litem has an opportunity to testify, and is permitted to submit a report, regarding the guardian’s recommendations on the best interests of the child and the bases for them.

The Commission found violations of the two canons. Section 107.002(e) is the statute the canons point at: Canon 2A requires a judge to comply with the law, and this is the law he did not comply with. Notably, the order does not reach for Article V, Section 1-a(6)A, the willful or persistent conduct standard the Commission uses for the more serious cases in this series. This was treated as a competence failure, not as misconduct in the constitutional sense.

The Sanction

The Commission issued a public admonition and ordered two hours of instruction with a mentor, specifically on guardians ad litem, in addition to his required judicial education for fiscal year 2026. The mentor is assigned through the Texas Center for the Judiciary, and he has 60 days from written notice of that assignment to complete the hours.

A public admonition is the bottom of the public ladder, and the education order is aimed squarely at making sure this one does not recur.

How It Played in the Press

It did not. There was no clip and no wave of outrage, and that silence fits the case. Child welfare proceedings are confidential, the failure was procedural rather than dramatic, and the people at the center, a child and the volunteer speaking for that child, are not a story that travels.

That is part of why a case like this matters. The protections that get skipped quietly, in courtrooms the public never watches, are the ones that depend on the discipline system to catch them. Here, what actually caught it was an attorney ad litem who kept raising it in the record.

Not His First Time Before the Commission

The 2026 admonition is not the first entry under his name. At its meeting of December 8 through 10, 2004, the Commission disciplined him twice, in two separate orders, from his years on the elected County Court at Law No. 3 bench. He appeared with counsel and testified before the Commission on December 10 in both matters.

The first, a public admonition, came out of a dispute at the Montgomery County jail on or about December 28, 2003. Jail administrators had put new security measures in place for probable cause hearings, separating male and female inmates and posting a deputy outside the hearing room window, ready to act in an emergency. Frustrated, he started to leave, telling the deputies to go find their own judge for probable cause. When one deputy looked through the window he told him to get away from it and to get his ugly face out of his sight, and he told another deputy that if the jailer could not follow orders he would have him locked up in his own jail. The Commission found a violation of Canon 3B(4) and noted that some of the conduct was observed by prisoners.

The second, a public warning, was a step more serious. On January 12, 2004, during jury selection in a misdemeanor marijuana possession case where the defendant had already pleaded guilty and the jury was to assess punishment, a man on the panel said he thought the punishment for the offense was too harsh. He was brought to the bench so the judge and the lawyers could decide whether to excuse him. The judge instead told him that the next time he came to court looking the way he did, the judge would put him in jail, and that if he jailed him that day for looking contentious he would have him drug tested. When the man said that was fine and that he was tested at his job, the judge answered that he was glad he was not a user and that he “ought to quit looking like one.” As the man tried to step away, the judge stopped him, said he had not been excused, and told him to stand straight, drop his hands to his sides and act like he knew what he was doing there, because he did not look like it. Testifying before the Commission, the judge said he had treated the man this way because he perceived him to be a street person. The Commission found violations of Canons 3B(4) and 3B(6), the second being the rule against manifesting bias or prejudice.

The 2004 matters and the 2026 one are different in character. The earlier ones are about temperament and bias toward people in the room. The recent one is about a procedural duty left undone. Read together they describe a judge whose conduct has drawn the Commission’s attention across more than two decades on and around the bench, and they are the reason the 2026 order is worth more than its sanction level suggests.

Where Things Stand

E. Mason Martin II is a former elected judge of County Court at Law No. 3 in Conroe who has since sat as a visiting judge by assignment in Montgomery County. The Commission’s order describes him as a visiting judge, and the conduct it addresses runs through December 2024, so he was taking assignments at least that recently. The Office of Court Administration’s statewide list of senior and former judges available for assignment, current as of April 2023, carries him as a retired county court at law judge in the Second Administrative Judicial Region. We could not locate a current Second Region list to confirm whether he is on it today.

A public admonition is permanent and public, and this one now sits in a disciplinary record that spans more than twenty years. It would be part of what any court weighs before giving him an assignment. The Gavel of Shame series will follow if his assignment status changes.

The Right to Be Heard Is the Floor

Every kind of courtroom runs on the same foundation. The people the law entitles to be heard have to actually be heard, and in the right order. When that does not happen, the objection has to be on the record before it can be anything else.

Deandra Grant Law defends that principle in criminal courts across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you.

Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com

Sources

Primary sources

  • Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Admonition and Order of Additional Education of the Honorable E. Mason Martin, CJC No. 25-0232, issued June 3, 2026. scjc.texas.gov
  • Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Admonition of the Honorable E. Mason Martin II, CJC No. 04-0427-CC (December 2004). scjc.texas.gov
  • Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Warning of the Honorable E. Mason Martin II, CJC No. 04-0466-CC (December 2004). scjc.texas.gov

Reference

  • Tex. Fam. Code sec. 107.002 (powers and duties of a guardian ad litem). codes.findlaw.com
  • Texas CASA, the role of a Court Appointed Special Advocate serving as guardian ad litem. texascasa.org

This post summarizes the findings of public sanctions issued by the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct. All findings are drawn from those public orders. Judge Martin denied the 2026 violation in his written response. The child welfare cases are identified here by cause number only; the child and the family are not named, and neither the child, the guardian ad litem nor the attorney ad litem is accused of any wrongdoing. The prospective juror and jail staff described in the 2004 orders are referred to by role. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.

Where We Defend
Criminal Defense

Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.

Subscribe via RSSGet new DWI guides in your reader
Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By

Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist

She holds a Master of Science in Pharmaceutical Science and a Graduate Certificate in Forensic Toxicology, both from the University of Florida. She is the author of The Texas DWI Manual and has defended Texas DWI cases since 1994.

Full profile and credentials →

Your Defense Starts Now

Charged With a Crime?

Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.

3300 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75219
(214) 225-7117
4500 Airport Freeway, Suite 101
Fort Worth, TX 76117
(817) 631-6522
605 Austin Avenue, Suite 5
Waco, TX 76701
(254) 735-3588
1333 W. McDermott Drive, Suite 180
Allen, TX 75013
(972) 848-8828
1101 Ridge Road, Suite 201
Rockwall, TX 75087
(469) 253-6999
1317 E. McKinney Street, Suite 101A
Denton, TX 76209
(940) 600-5536
No Cost · No Obligation

Request a Free Case Evaluation

Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.