Judge James Oakley Reprimanded for Harassing a Judge
On December 11, 2024, the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly reprimanded Burnet County Judge James Oakley. A justice of the peace had asked to lock her courtroom door when court was not in session. He had the lock removed, and when she kept closing the door, he had a hole drilled through the floor and the door and bolted it open with a padlock whose combination he gave to no one. The Commission also found that he sexually harassed her, created a hostile work environment, and engaged in a pattern of harassment toward other women in the county. He resigned a week later.

How a Burnet County judge stripped the lock from a fellow judge’s courtroom, drilled her door open, and drew a public reprimand that covered far more than the door
| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Hon. James Oakley, former County Judge |
| Court | County Judge, Burnet County, Texas |
| CJC Number | 23-0518 |
| Reviewed | Commission meeting of October 3, 2024; he appeared and testified December 3, 2024 |
| Date Issued | December 11, 2024 |
| Sanction | Public reprimand |
| Provisions Violated | Canons 2A, 3B(2), 3B(4), 3B(5) and 3B(6); Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 1-a(6)A |
| Signed By | Gary Steel, Chairman, State Commission on Judicial Conduct |
| Resigned | December 18, 2024, effective January 2, 2025 |
| Criminal Case | Three remaining charges dismissed in the interest of justice, May 20, 2026 |
| Since | Filed a federal malicious prosecution suit against the former district attorney, the sheriff and the county, October 26, 2026 |
A Texas county judge is not a courtroom judge in the usual sense. The job is largely administrative: running the commissioners court, managing the county’s business, and, as local administrative judge, overseeing courthouse security. Think of it as mayor of the county. It was that last duty Burnet County Judge James Oakley turned on its head.
It was not his first trip through the discipline system, and the reprimand was nearly his last act in office.
The Door She Wanted to Lock
On November 3, 2022, Justice of the Peace Lisa Whitehead asked to speak with Judge Oakley about keeping her courtroom door closed, and locked as needed, when court was not in session. Her courtroom sits close to a public outside entrance of the historic courthouse, in a spot not screened at any manned security barrier, and she had concrete concerns after an incident the previous month in which a particular individual had come into the building. His answer was flat: the door would not be locked and would not be closed. She told him she would keep shutting it anyway, for her safety and her staff’s.
What followed was not a compromise. The next day, November 4, he had courthouse maintenance remove or deactivate the lock. She kept closing the door. She raised her concerns with the Office of Court Administration’s court security division, which agreed to send someone to assess the building. On November 9, before that assessment happened and because she was still shutting the door, he had county maintenance drill a hole through the courthouse floor and through the courtroom door and install an eyebolt, so the door was held open indefinitely with a combination padlock.
He did not give the combination to Judge Whitehead, the sheriff or the constable. He did not consult or get approval from the sheriff, the constables or any court security committee. He taped a printed sign to the outside of the door announcing that it was to remain open when the room was not in use, signed with his name. The padlock came off only after the sheriff spoke with him about it.
The state’s assessment, completed on November 18, 2022, found the opposite of everything he had done. The courtroom should be kept secured when not in use. The door should be closed and locked at all times unless a bailiff is present. The eyebolt should be removed. And the door should never be fixed in a single position that court security staff cannot control, including open.
In his response to the Commission he defended all of it, saying no such measures were required in a courthouse built in 1936 and that her concerns did not make sense. Testifying in December 2024 he allowed that in retrospect he might have handled it differently, but said he considered the room a public room rather than a courtroom. The building’s own blueprints designate it a courtroom.
| WHO CONTROLS COURTHOUSE SECURITY
Courthouse security is not a county judge’s personal call. Local Government Code section 291.003 puts the county sheriff in charge and control of the courthouse, subject to the regulations of the commissioners court. Government Code section 74.092(a)(13) requires the local administrative judge to establish a court security committee to adopt security policies for the courts served. A judge who strips a lock and bolts a courtroom open without the sheriff, the constables or that committee is not exercising authority. He is going around the people the law puts in charge of it. |
More Than a Door
The fight over the door brought the rest to the surface. Judge Whitehead alleged, and the Commission found, that he had bullied and sexually harassed her over a period of years.
On January 6, 2023, she was working in her office with the door into her courtroom open and the courtroom door closed and locked, when she discovered that Judge Oakley was sitting in the courtroom with the overhead lights off, having never announced himself. How long he had been there was unclear. The order says his presence startled and frightened her.
On March 13, 2023, after the Commission had already suspended him over a separate matter, he contacted her to “clear the air,” told her he was not sensitive to her sensitivities, and told her he loved her. She reported other incidents: a crude remark in her office accompanied by an elbow, and two occasions when he sat beside her at public events, once at a community event in Burnet and once with the county contingent in the House gallery at the Texas Capitol, and rubbed her leg. The order records that the second time he made a comment showing the contact was intentional rather than inadvertent.
The Commission did not treat this as a personality clash between two officials. In a sworn statement, Judge Whitehead described a pervasive pattern of harassment toward other women across the county, many of them employees who feared retaliation against themselves or their departments, some of them young and dependent on a county salary. The Commission also recorded the structural problem behind that silence: Judge Oakley had installed the wife of a sitting county commissioner, one of his closest political allies, as the county’s human resources director. She resigned in October 2023 after the Texas Attorney General concluded her continued employment was likely contrary to state nepotism laws. The point in the record is the obvious one. Women with a harassment complaint were being asked to take it to an HR office run by the judge’s ally.
He disputed the harassment allegations before the Commission and called them false and politically motivated in the press.
The Rules He Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Canon 2A | A judge shall comply with the law. |
| Canon 3B(2) | A judge shall maintain professional competence in the law. |
| Canon 3B(4) | A judge shall be patient, dignified and courteous to litigants, jurors, witnesses, lawyers and others the judge deals with in an official capacity. |
| Canon 3B(5) | A judge shall perform judicial duties without bias or prejudice. |
| Canon 3B(6) | A judge shall not, in the performance of judicial duties, by words or conduct manifest bias or prejudice, including on the basis of sex. |
| Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 1-a(6)A | A judge shall not engage in willful or persistent conduct clearly inconsistent with the proper performance of judicial duties or that casts public discredit on the judiciary. |
The Commission cited the courthouse security statutes directly, which is unusual in a conduct order, and it cited Burnet County’s own personnel policy, quoting the county handbook’s definition of sexual harassment back at the county’s highest elected official. The second half of the conclusion rests on the harassment of Judge Whitehead and on the pattern toward other women, not on the door.
How It Played in the Press
Central Texas media covered the reprimand closely, including the Austin stations KXAN and KVUE and the Highland Lakes outlets DailyTrib.com and The Highlander. Coverage paired the findings with his separate legal troubles and with Judge Whitehead’s response. She said she appreciated the Commission’s thoroughness and that the findings of fact and the conclusion said it all. He told reporters the findings were false and misleading and politically motivated. The county attorney opened his own inquiry into the harassment complaints, which he said could have led to a petition to remove Oakley from office, and dropped it once Oakley left.
What Happened to the Criminal Case
Running alongside all of this was a criminal prosecution, and this file previously left its status open. It is now closed.
Oakley was indicted in March 2023 over a 2021 vehicle collision and related conduct. The Commission suspended him without pay for six months in 2023 while it was pending. A jury acquitted him on one charge. Three others, abuse of official capacity, tampering with evidence and official oppression, were revived when a state appeals court reinstated them in November 2024, weeks before he resigned.
Those three were dismissed on May 20, 2026. The elected district attorney had recused himself in November 2025 and a district attorney from another district was appointed in December. She moved to dismiss all three in the interest of justice. Oakley said he was pleased at the swift action and that it had been stressful.
On October 26, 2026 he sued the former district attorney, the county sheriff and Burnet County in federal court for malicious prosecution, seeking a declaration that they violated his First and Fourth Amendment rights, at least $218,000 in defense fees, and damages for reputational harm and lost income. The suit alleges the charges were timed to push him out while he was looking into a whistleblower complaint about timesheet entries at the sheriff’s office, and that the state offered him a non-prosecution agreement he refused. The former district attorney said Oakley has no grounds for the suit. The sheriff is the same official who intervened to get the padlock off Judge Whitehead’s door. None of those allegations has been tested, and this file takes no position on them.
Where Things Stand
On December 18, 2024, a week after the reprimand, Oakley submitted his resignation to the county attorney, effective January 2, 2025, ending a decade as county judge and, before that, eight years as a county commissioner. In his letter he cited the extreme lack of civility in public discourse and a desire to protect his and his family’s health and safety, and noted that he was eligible for retirement. The commissioners court appointed a temporary judge to finish the term.
The reprimand capped a long record, and the Commission had publicly sanctioned him twice before.
The first was a public reprimand and order of additional education issued on April 5, 2018 in CJC Nos. 17-0320-CO and seventeen companion numbers. On November 21, 2016, the San Antonio Police Department posted to Facebook that it had arrested a man and charged him with capital murder in the killing of one of its detectives. Judge Oakley commented on the post, “Time for a tree and a rope.” He took it down and apologized, calling the remark harsh and off the cuff and denying it had anything to do with race, and told the Commission he had meant it as a comment on the death penalty and as a reference to a 1980s salsa advertisement. Eighteen written complaints followed. The Commission found he had cast reasonable doubt on his capacity to act impartially in violation of Canon 4A(1), and ordered thirty hours of judicial training plus four hours of instruction in racial sensitivity with an assigned mentor.
The second was a public admonition under Canon 2B for lending the prestige of his office to advance someone else’s private interests. He let a social acquaintance use his name, likeness and the title Burnet County Judge in her campaign for a seat on the board of the Pedernales Electric Cooperative, in material mailed to roughly 35,000 members. The seat carried a $36,000 annual stipend. He appealed, and on October 25, 2019 a Special Court of Review of three appellate justices agreed with the Commission on both the violation and the sanction. He had not disputed any of the facts, only the legal conclusion.
Separately, the Commission suspended him without pay in 2023 while the criminal charges were pending.
A public reprimand also carries a consequence that outlasts any resignation. Under Government Code section 74.055(c), a retired or former judge cannot be placed on the list of judges subject to assignment unless he certifies under oath that he has never been publicly reprimanded or censured by the State Commission on Judicial Conduct, and the only escape is a sanction rescinded by a special court of review. A separate provision in the same subsection reaches the exact sequence here: a judge who resigns after the Commission has begun a full investigation and is then publicly reprimanded as a result of it is disqualified too. The statute’s one escape, a sanction rescinded by a special court of review, does not help him either. He took one sanction to a special court of review and it was affirmed, and on the 2018 reprimand alone the bar attached six years before he resigned. Whatever else the dismissal of the criminal charges restored to him, it did not restore that.
The Gavel of Shame series will follow the civil case.
| Did a Judge’s Conduct Affect Your Case?
Judicial bias, procedural shortcuts, and misconduct from the bench can be grounds to challenge a ruling, and most of it has to be preserved in the record while it is happening. Deandra Grant Law handles DWI, criminal defense and appeals across Texas, and holds courts to the standards every person in a courtroom is owed. If you are facing a charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
Primary source
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Reprimand of the Honorable James Oakley, CJC No. 23-0518, issued December 11, 2024. scjc.texas.gov
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Reprimand and Amended Order of Additional Education of the Honorable James Oakley, CJC Nos. 17-0320-CO et al., issued April 5, 2018. scjc.texas.gov
- In re Inquiry Concerning the Honorable James Oakley, Docket No. SCR 19-0002, Special Court of Review opinion and judgment, October 25, 2019. scjc.texas.gov
News coverage
- Oakley reprimanded for unprofessional conduct, sexual harassment, DailyTrib.com (December 16, 2024). dailytrib.com
- Burnet County judge quits amid legal, harassment claims, KXAN Austin (December 2024). kxan.com
- Burnet County judge resigns amid public reprimand over sexual harassment, KVUE (December 2024). kvue.com
- Charges against Oakley dismissed in the interest of justice, DailyTrib.com (May 28, 2026). dailytrib.com
- Former Burnet County judge sues for malicious prosecution (October 27, 2026). yahoo.com
Reference
- Tex. Gov’t Code sec. 74.055 (eligibility for the list of judges subject to assignment). codes.findlaw.com
This post summarizes the findings of a public sanction issued by the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct. All findings are drawn from that public order. Judge Oakley disputed the harassment allegations before the Commission and in the press. Judge Whitehead is named because she is a judge and the complainant whose sworn statement the order relies on; the county officials, employees and members of the public described in the order are referred to here only by role, and none of them is accused of any wrongdoing. The allegations in the civil suit he filed in October 2026 are untested. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.