Gavel of Shame

Judge Franco GoBourne Jailed a Public Defender

Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist
Updated
Read time 9 min
The Short Answer

On March 25, 2025, in Fall River District Court, Judge Franco J. GoBourne found a public defender in criminal contempt after a three minute exchange that began with an instruction to stop pacing and face the bench. The lawyer was handcuffed, put in leg restraints and held in a cell for about five hours. The Massachusetts Commission on Judicial Conduct filed formal charges with the Supreme Judicial Court on October 22, 2026, alleging willful judicial misconduct, conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice and conduct unbecoming a judicial officer. He retired in September 2025. The charges are allegations; nothing has been adjudicated.

Judge Franco GoBourne Jailed a Public Defender
CASE FILE AT A GLANCE
Judge Hon. Franco J. GoBourne, retired; former Circuit Justice of the District Court Department
Appointed 2010; retired September 2025
Court Fall River District Court, Massachusetts
Complaint Number 2025-21
Conduct March 25, 2025, at a pretrial appearance in a criminal case
Complainant The Committee for Public Counsel Services, the state public defender agency, June 6, 2025
Statement of Allegations Issued July 16, 2026 and received by him July 27, 2026; no written response was filed
Formal Charges Dated September 9, 2026; filed with the Supreme Judicial Court October 22, 2026
Grounds Willful judicial misconduct bringing the office into disrepute; conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice; conduct unbecoming a judicial officer
Status Pending. The Commission has asked for a hearing officer; a public hearing follows within 30 to 60 days of that appointment

Three Minutes

A public defender was in Fall River District Court on March 25, 2025, on a pretrial matter for a client. To answer a question from the bench he turned away to look at his file, which was on a desk behind him.

What followed, as the charges set it out, took about three minutes. The judge told him to stop pacing and face the bench. The lawyer said, twice, excuse me, Your Honor. The judge told him he had better be careful what he said. They began talking over each other. The charges state that the lawyer’s tone stayed polite and professional throughout.

Then: “I’m asking you to be quiet. And I’m asking you to face the court. Take him into custody. Take him into custody. I find you in contempt of court, Counsel.”

Court officers handcuffed him, took his personal belongings, put him in leg restraints and placed him in a holding cell. It was about 9:30 in the morning.

Five Hours

Around noon, another lawyer from the same public defender office asked the judge to consider releasing him. The judge declined to hear the argument then, although he had no other cases on his docket, said he would take it up at 2:00, and recessed. He came back at 2:42.

At that brief hearing he explained himself:

“[Y]ou may not have heard it on the tape but his attitude, his facial expressions, and his body expressions, and his recalcitrance is contemptuous. I asked him to stop speaking. Everyone’s telling me, and I’ll be honest with you, I got a call from the Chief Justice, and he was telling me you don’t have it. But when I read the rules and what could be considered contempt, I feel that his actions did fall as contemptuous.”

He then ordered the lawyer released and withdrew the contempt finding. By then the attorney had been in restraints and in a cell for roughly five hours.

Two things in that statement do the damage. The first is the grounds he gave: attitude, facial expressions, body expressions. None of those is disorder, and a judge cannot jail a lawyer for a face. The second is that he had already been told. The chief justice of his own court called him and said he did not have it, and the lawyer stayed in the cell for another several hours anyway.

WHAT SUMMARY CONTEMPT IS FOR

Summary, or direct, contempt is the power to punish on the spot with no hearing, no notice and no separate judge. It exists for one reason: a judge must be able to stop a proceeding from collapsing into disorder right now, when there is no time for process. It is not a tool for enforcing courtesy, and it is not a response to a tone. Where the court can give notice and a hearing without the proceeding falling apart, due process requires exactly that.

What the Commission Charged

The state public defender agency filed its complaint on June 6, 2025. The Commission issued a statement of allegations on July 16, 2026, and he received it July 27. No written response was filed, and formal charges followed.

The charges allege that he summarily ordered the lawyer into custody for criminal contempt with no factual basis to support a finding that summary punishment was necessary to maintain order in the courtroom. The grounds tracked in the charges are the statutory ones under Massachusetts General Laws chapter 211C, section 2(5): willful misconduct in office, conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice, and conduct unbecoming a judicial officer, each of which brings the judicial office into disrepute. The charges also cite provisions of the Massachusetts Code of Judicial Conduct on promoting public confidence in the judiciary, upholding and applying the law fairly and impartially, avoiding the appearance of bias, and being patient, dignified and courteous to litigants and lawyers: Rules 1.1, 1.2, 2.2, 2.3 and 2.8(B).

The Commission has asked the Supreme Judicial Court to appoint a hearing officer. Once that happens a public hearing is to be scheduled within thirty to sixty days. He has ten days from service to answer. The electronic docket lists him as representing himself. None of this has been decided, and this file uses allegation voice throughout.

He Retired. The Case Did Not End.

He was appointed in 2010 and retired in September 2025, about three months after the complaint was filed and a year before the charges issued. In most of the files in this series that is the end of the matter, because the sanction a conduct body has is the job.

Massachusetts wrote around it. Chapter 211C, section 2(2) extends the Commission’s jurisdiction to the conduct of a lawyer who is no longer a judge, where the conduct happened while he held judicial office. The same provision requires the Commission to give substantial weight to decisions of the Supreme Judicial Court and the Board of Bar Overseers on bar discipline.

Texas has no equivalent. When a Texas judge resigns or retires while a complaint is open, the State Commission on Judicial Conduct can still issue a sanction, and it sometimes does years later, but the lever it holds is a public record and a bar on future judicial service. The license belongs to the State Bar, which runs a separate system on its own timetable. In Massachusetts the conduct commission is told to look at the bar’s work and the bar is told to look at the commission’s.

How It Would Work in Texas

A Texas judge has the same summary contempt power and the same limit on it. Our file on the Loving County justice of the peace who jailed four prospective jurors covers the rule: under Ex parte Knable, 818 S.W.2d 811 (Tex. Crim. App. 1991), a finding of direct contempt does not by itself justify punishing on the spot, because that authority flows from observing the conduct and from the exigency of the situation, meaning a genuine need to act at once to quell disruption, violence, disrespect or physical abuse. Where due process can be given without disrupting the proceeding, the Fourteenth Amendment requires it.

Texas then adds something Massachusetts does not appear to have, and it is aimed squarely at this situation. Under Government Code section 21.002(d), an officer of the court held in contempt by a trial court shall, on proper motion in the offended court, be released on his own personal recognizance. And the presiding judge of the administrative judicial region then assigns a different judge, who cannot be the judge of the offended court, to decide guilt or innocence.

A Texas lawyer in the same position does not wait in a cell for the offended judge to come back from recess, because the statute takes the custody decision and the guilt decision away from that judge entirely. The reason is obvious once stated: a judge who has just been personally affronted is the worst available person to decide whether the affront was a crime.

Where Things Stand

The contempt finding was withdrawn the same day and the lawyer was released, so there is no conviction and nothing to appeal. What is left is the conduct case, and it is at its beginning rather than its end. Formal charges have been filed with the Supreme Judicial Court, a hearing officer has been requested, and a public hearing follows.

Nothing has been found. He has not answered the charges in writing, and he is listed as representing himself. The Gavel of Shame series will follow this one to its conclusion.

Jailed or Sanctioned for Doing Your Job?

A contempt finding against a lawyer is reviewable, and in Texas the statute entitles an officer of the court to release on personal recognizance and to a different judge deciding the question. Both of those have to be asked for, in the offended court, on the record.

Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you.

Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com

Sources

Primary sources

  • Massachusetts Commission on Judicial Conduct, Formal Charges against Judge Franco J. GoBourne, Complaint No. 2025-21, dated September 9, 2026. mass.gov
  • Commission on Judicial Conduct files formal charges against retired Judge Franco J. GoBourne, press release (October 22, 2026). mass.gov

News coverage

  • Retired district court judge faces charges for jailing public defender, holding him in contempt, The Boston Globe (October 22, 2026). bostonglobe.com
  • Ethics complaint filed against judge who had attorney jailed, shackled for attitude, ABA Journal. abajournal.com
  • Charges filed against former Fall River judge, Fall River Reporter. fallriverreporter.com

Reference

  • Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 211C, sec. 2 (grounds for discipline; jurisdiction over a lawyer who is no longer a judge). malegislature.gov
  • Tex. Gov’t Code sec. 21.002 (contempt; release of an officer of the court and assignment of a different judge). texas.public.law

This post summarizes formal charges filed by the Massachusetts Commission on Judicial Conduct. The charges are allegations. No hearing has been held, no findings have been made, and Judge GoBourne is entitled to respond and to a public hearing before the matter is decided. Quotations are taken from the charging document’s account of the recorded proceeding. The attorney who was held in contempt, his client, and the other lawyers and court staff present are not named here; none of them is accused of any wrongdoing. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.

Where We Defend
Criminal Defense

Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.

Subscribe via RSSGet new DWI guides in your reader
Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By

Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist

She holds a Master of Science in Pharmaceutical Science and a Graduate Certificate in Forensic Toxicology, both from the University of Florida. She is the author of The Texas DWI Manual and has defended Texas DWI cases since 1994.

Full profile and credentials →

Your Defense Starts Now

Charged With a Crime?

Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.

3300 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75219
(214) 225-7117
4500 Airport Freeway, Suite 101
Fort Worth, TX 76117
(817) 631-6522
605 Austin Avenue, Suite 5
Waco, TX 76701
(254) 735-3588
1333 W. McDermott Drive, Suite 180
Allen, TX 75013
(972) 848-8828
1101 Ridge Road, Suite 201
Rockwall, TX 75087
(469) 253-6999
1317 E. McKinney Street, Suite 101A
Denton, TX 76209
(940) 600-5536
No Cost · No Obligation

Request a Free Case Evaluation

Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.