Judge Jon Ickes Removed Over Hidden Stepson Conflict
On August 19, 2026, the Supreme Court of Ohio removed Sandusky County Common Pleas Judge Jon Ickes from the bench and suspended his law license for two years, with nothing stayed. He had presided over two criminal cases in which his stepson, a Fremont police officer, was the arresting officer or a key witness, and never disclosed the relationship. Both convictions were later reversed because of it. The Court also found he cultivated an abusive, sexualized workplace, used a vulgar nickname for a child rape case, and texted from the bench mocking a prospective juror during a live trial. The Board of Professional Conduct had recommended a fully stayed one-year suspension; the Court rejected that as too lenient, 5 to 2. And then the strangest part: he had already won an uncontested Republican primary, and on September 14 the Court held that Ohio law gave nobody the power to take him off the November 3 ballot. So the question went to the voters, and on November 3 they answered it. Kimberly Ontko, the magistrate who had tried to have him struck from the ballot, took 13,729 votes to his 6,177, a margin of nearly thirty eight points. Below: the conflict that undid two felony convictions, why the ballot could not be fixed, and the Texas statute that would have fixed it.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Jon Marshal Ickes, Sandusky County Court of Common Pleas, General and Domestic Relations Division, Ohio |
| Disciplinary case | Disciplinary Counsel v. Ickes, No. 2025-1323, Slip Op. No. 2026-Ohio-3173 (Ohio, August 19, 2026) |
| Violations found | Ten of seventeen charged violations of the Ohio Code of Judicial Conduct |
| Sanction | Two-year suspension from the practice of law, nothing stayed; removed from judicial office without pay for the duration, effective immediately; taxed with costs |
| Vote | 5 to 2. Chief Justice Kennedy wrote for the majority; Justices DeWine and Deters would each have imposed less |
| Board recommendation | One-year suspension, fully stayed, which would have let him keep the seat |
| Ballot case | State ex rel. Ontko v. Sandusky Cty. Bd. of Elections, No. 2026-1133 (Ohio, September 14, 2026): the Court cannot order him off the ballot |
| On the ballot | November 3, 2026, for a full term beginning January 1, 2027, after an uncontested Republican primary. His opponent ran as an independent; no Democrat filed |
| Election result | Kimberly Ontko 13,729 votes, 68.97 percent; Jon M. Ickes 6,177 votes, 31.03 percent. Unofficial results; the official canvass follows |
| Suspension runs to | August 2028, roughly the first nineteen months of the term he sought |
| Status | Off the bench, unable to practice law until August 2028, and defeated at the polls |
| THE APPEARANCE OF IMPARTIALITY STANDARD
Judges do not have to be proven biased to be disqualified. Ohio’s Code of Judicial Conduct, like the ABA Model Code most states follow, disqualifies a judge whenever impartiality might reasonably be questioned, which is a far lower bar than proving actual bias. A close family relationship to a testifying officer is a textbook example. The rule also requires the judge to put the basis for disqualification on the record, so the parties can decide with full information whether to waive it. A judge does not get to make that call alone and quietly. |
The Conflict He Didn’t Put on the Record
His stepson, a Fremont police officer, was the arresting officer in a 2022 drive-by shooting case and a key law enforcement witness in a separate assault case against the same defendant. Ickes presided over pretrial proceedings in both and over the full trial in the assault case.
Ohio’s code required him to disqualify and to state the basis on the record. He did neither. He sentenced the defendant to six to nine years without ever telling him, his attorney, or the prosecution that the state’s witness was the judge’s stepson.
The pattern repeated a year later. A defendant was indicted after livestreaming himself sexually assaulting an 18 month old child, and the same officer was again the arresting officer. That defendant’s attorney asked Ickes to recuse once he learned of the relationship. Ickes refused, telling the defense the officer’s role did not warrant it. The defendant was convicted and sentenced to life without parole.
How a Hidden Relationship Undid Two Convictions
In the drive-by case the defendant himself flagged the relationship and asked Ickes to step aside. Ickes did, and prosecutors later dropped that case after an eyewitness left the state. But the assault case had already gone to trial and sentencing with the conflict undisclosed. On appeal the Sixth District Court of Appeals reversed that conviction, finding an unconstitutional potential for bias because nothing in the record showed the defendant or his lawyer knew the officer was the judge’s stepson.
The second defendant’s appeal was pending when the Sixth District decided the first. Relying on that precedent, the appellate court found the undisclosed relationship violated his due process rights, vacated the life sentence, and sent the case back.
Two serious felony convictions, both obtained after full trials, came undone. Not because of any factual dispute about guilt, but because the judge who presided never told anyone he had a personal stake in believing the arresting officer.
It Was Not Just the Recusals
The disciplinary case went well beyond the two conflicted prosecutions. For eight months, staff said he referred to the child rape case by a lewd nickname that one employee called disgusting. During that trial he exchanged text messages from the bench with courtroom staff mocking a prospective juror. The Board also found he made sexualized comments to a pregnant assignment commissioner, used a racial slur within earshot of a defendant, and disparaged a probation officer who had been injured on the job.
The complaint traces to July 2024, when courthouse employees filed harassment complaints and an outside human resources investigation documented what investigators called a sexualized and unprofessional workplace culture.
Why the Court Went Further Than the Board
The Board of Professional Conduct found ten of the seventeen charged violations but recommended a one-year suspension, fully stayed, which would have let him keep his seat so long as he stayed out of trouble. The Supreme Court rejected that as too soft.
Chief Justice Sharon Kennedy, writing for the majority, said judges are held to a higher standard than other lawyers, and that his failure to resign after the Board’s findings showed the higher standard alone would not deter him. The Court wrote that his silence about the conflict caused incalculable harm to the public confidence in the independence, integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.
The two dissenters would have gone easier. Justice DeWine favored a one-year suspension with six months stayed. Justice Deters favored a two-year suspension, fully stayed, conditioned on anti-harassment training. The majority imposed the full two years with nothing stayed, removed him from office without pay for the duration, effective immediately, and taxed him with the costs.
The Ballot Problem
He had filed for a full term and won an uncontested Republican primary in May 2026, before the removal order came down in August. After it did, the Sandusky County Board of Elections held an emergency meeting and decided his judicial conduct had been an issue for the primary, leaving him on the general election ballot.
His opponent, a magistrate in the same courthouse running as an independent, filed a protest with the board in August and lost, then went to the Supreme Court of Ohio. Her position was simple: a candidate for judicial office who is not eligible to assume the office sought has no right of ballot access. She asked the Court to strike him from the ballot or, failing that, to bar the board from counting votes for him or declaring him the winner.
On September 14, 2026, the Court turned her down on every point, and the reasoning is procedural rather than any judgment about his fitness. Under R.C. 3501.39 and the Court’s 2002 decision in Whitman v. Hamilton County Board of Elections, which also involved removing a judicial candidate after a primary, state law allows candidacy protests only before the primary. R.C. 3513.05 provides for pre-primary protests by members of the candidate’s own party; she did not indicate she was a Republican and she filed after the May primary. R.C. 3501.39(A)(2) cannot be used to get around those time limits. R.C. 3501.39(A)(4) does let a board remove a candidate on its own initiative, but it authorizes no individual protest, and it bars the board from removing a candidate within sixty days of the election. The board had not acted earlier, so there was nothing left for the Court to order. And a writ of prohibition cannot compel a government body to act, which disposed of the request to stop the count.
The per curiam opinion was joined by Justices DeWine, Deters, Hawkins and Shanahan. Chief Justice Kennedy, who had written the removal opinion three weeks earlier, and Justice Fischer concurred in judgment only. Justice Brunner concurred separately to say what the opinion would not: that current law does not let the Court keep voters from being presented with a ballot listing a candidate ineligible to hold the office for which he seeks election.
The sixty day rule is not a window the board declined to use. It is a bar. The board could not have removed him inside sixty days even if it had wanted to, and the time when it could have acted had already run.
What the Voters Did With It
On November 3, 2026, Sandusky County elected Kimberly Ontko, the magistrate who had tried to have him struck from the ballot, by 13,729 votes to 6,177. She took 68.97 percent to his 31.03, a margin of 7,552 votes and nearly thirty eight points. These are the board of elections’ unofficial returns, with all 58 precincts reporting; the official canvass follows within weeks and will not move numbers like these.
6,177 is how many people voted to install, as their common pleas judge for a six year term beginning January 1, a man who had been removed from that bench ten weeks earlier and who cannot lawfully practice law, let alone sit as a judge, until August 2028. The result was never close, but roughly three in ten voters marked the ballot for him anyway.
3,025 is the number of voters who turned in a ballot and left this race blank. That sounds like a lot until you set it beside the other judicial races on the same ballot. Two other common pleas seats were uncontested, and they drew 6,637 and 6,185 blanks. The contested race drew 19,906 votes against 16,299 and 16,751 in the uncontested ones, so about three thousand more voters marked this race than marked either of the others. The scandal did not drive voters away from the race. It pulled more of them into it than turned out for a judgeship nobody was fighting over.
Ohio had no mechanism to keep an ineligible candidate off the ballot. What the state had instead was an electorate. It is worth being clear about what that does and does not prove. It worked because the race was contested, because a credible opponent had spent two months in court and in the press making the ineligibility an issue, and because the margin was wide enough that nobody had to litigate the aftermath.
The Rules Ickes Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Jud.Cond.R. 1.2 | A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the independence, integrity and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety. |
| Jud.Cond.R. 2.8(B) | A judge shall be patient, dignified and courteous to litigants, jurors, witnesses, lawyers, court staff, court officials and others, and shall require similar conduct of those subject to the judge’s direction and control. |
| Jud.Cond.R. 2.11(A) | A judge shall disqualify from any proceeding in which the judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including where a family member is likely to be a material witness. |
| Jud.Cond.R. 2.12(A) | A judge shall require court staff, court officials and others subject to the judge’s direction and control to act consistently with the judge’s own obligations under the Code. |
How It Would Work in Texas
THE RECUSAL RULE IS THE SAME
Texas draws the line in the same place. Under Rule 18b a judge related within the third degree to a party or a material witness must recuse, and a judge whose impartiality could reasonably be questioned on any other ground must disclose it or step aside. Rule 18a sets the mechanics: the motion goes to the judge, who either recuses or refers it to the regional presiding judge for another judge to decide. Adverse rulings alone are not evidence of bias, which is exactly why an undisclosed relationship, rather than a run of unfavorable decisions, is what moves an appellate court.
THE PUNISHMENT WOULD BE SPLIT BETWEEN TWO BODIES
What Texas does not have is Ohio’s single-door structure. Ohio disciplines judges through the Board of Professional Conduct with the Supreme Court imposing the sanction, so one order suspended a law license and vacated a seat at the same time. In Texas the State Commission on Judicial Conduct issues sanctions up to censure but cannot remove a judge; removal runs through a separate Review Tribunal of appellate justices. The law license is a different matter entirely, handled by the State Bar, and a felony or serious-crime conviction triggers its own compulsory discipline track. Two bodies, two timelines, two records. For what the Commission can and cannot do, see our explainer, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained.
BUT TEXAS HAS THE BALLOT TOOL OHIO LACKED
A Texas district judge must have been a practicing lawyer or a judge for four years before election, under article V, section 7 of the Texas Constitution, so a suspended license defeats eligibility. And section 145.003 of the Texas Election Code supplies the machinery Ohio did not have. A candidate in the general election for state and county offices may be declared ineligible up to the thirtieth day before election day, by the party officer who certifies a nominee’s name or, for an independent, by the authority with whom the application was filed. More striking still, under subsection (d) the presiding officer of the final canvassing authority may declare a candidate ineligible after the polls close, before a certificate of election is issued.
And the predicate fits this case precisely. Under subsection (f), a candidate may be declared ineligible where facts establishing ineligibility are conclusively established by another public record. An order of a state supreme court suspending a law license is about as conclusive a public record as exists.
So a Texas version of this judge could have been declared ineligible before the election, and if the declaration came too late for that, after the votes were counted and before a certificate issued. Ohio had no equivalent. That is not a knock on Ohio’s judges, who said plainly that the law tied their hands. It is a reminder that ballot access and officeholder eligibility are governed by different statutes, and that a state either builds a bridge between them or it does not. Ohio’s voters built one by hand this time. The statute is still missing.
How It Played in the Press
WTOL’s investigative unit broke the story in July 2024 after obtaining records of harassment complaints filed by three courthouse employees and the outside human resources investigation the judge himself had commissioned. The Office of Disciplinary Counsel’s seventeen count complaint followed in January 2025. Local coverage noted that Sandusky County Republican officials defended him during the disciplinary hearing even as the workplace investigation and the two reversed convictions became public.
The ballot ruling drew a second round of coverage in September, and the board’s own director declined to comment while the litigation was pending. The election drew far less. A race in which a judge removed from the bench ten weeks earlier ran for his own seat and lost two to one produced no national story we could find and little local follow-up, which is the usual shape of these things: the charge is news, the sanction is news, and the ending is a line in a results table.
Where Things Stand
It is over. He is off the bench, cannot practice law until August 2028, and will not take the seat he was running for. Kimberly Ontko takes office January 1, 2027. The question this file posed in October, what happens if a man wins an office he cannot occupy for the first nineteen months of the term, does not need answering. Ohio never had to decide whether a winner who cannot be sworn in creates a vacancy, because there was no winner to swear in.
What survives is the part that was never about him. Two felony convictions, obtained after full trials, came undone on direct appeal. Nothing about the evidence changed. The reversals rested entirely on the fact that the judge who presided kept a relationship to himself, and that is the lasting lesson of this file: a relationship a judge keeps to himself does not stay private. It surfaces on appeal, and it takes the judgment with it.
| IF YOUR CASE WAS BEFORE A JUDGE WITH AN UNDISCLOSED CONFLICT
It usually surfaces sideways: a courthouse rumor, a docket sheet with a familiar last name, a co-defendant’s motion in an unrelated case that mentions the relationship. Raise it the moment you learn of it. Both defendants here moved for recusal as soon as the relationship became known, and that timing is part of what let the appellate courts treat the issue as preserved rather than waived. You do not have to prove the judge was actually biased. Ohio and Texas both disqualify on the appearance standard, so the fight is about disclosure and the reasonable-question test, not about reading the judge’s mind. A conviction can be reversed well after sentencing. Both of these were undone on direct appeal, once the reviewing court had the full record of what had been withheld. |
| Facing the System in Texas?
A judge who hears your case owes you a decision-maker with no undisclosed stake in the outcome. That standard does not stop at the Ohio border, and the remedy for a breach of it is a motion made on the record, early. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
PRIMARY SOURCES
- Supreme Court of Ohio, Disciplinary Counsel v. Ickes, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3173 (August 19, 2026). supremecourt.ohio.gov
- Sandusky County Board of Elections, Election Summary, Group Detail, unofficial results, 2026 general election, November 3, 2026, for the vote totals, percentages and undervote counts in the contested and uncontested common pleas races. sanduskycountyoh.gov (pdf)
- Sandusky County Board of Elections, election results page, where the official canvass will be posted. sanduskycountyoh.gov
- Court News Ohio, Sandusky County judge removed from office for multiple judicial conduct violations (August 19, 2026). courtnewsohio.gov
- Court News Ohio, Court cannot remove suspended judge from ballot, State ex rel. Ontko v. Sandusky Cty. Bd. of Elections (September 14, 2026). courtnewsohio.gov
NEWS COVERAGE
- Investigators recommend Sandusky County judge be suspended for sexual, judicial misconduct, WTOL 11 Investigates. wtol.com
- Ohio Supreme Court removes local judge over conduct violations (August 19, 2026). 13abc.com
- Sandusky County judge Jon Ickes suspended, still on ballot, Signal Ohio. signalohio.org
TEXAS REFERENCE
- Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 18a and 18b, recusal and disqualification of judges. txcourts.gov
- Tex. Elec. Code § 145.003, administrative declaration of ineligibility. law.z6s.net
- What the State Commission on Judicial Conduct can and cannot do. texasdwisite.com
- This post summarizes a published opinion of the Supreme Court of Ohio, a public election case, the Sandusky County Board of Elections’ unofficial returns and news reporting, as of November 2026. The election figures are the board’s unofficial results, reported with all 58 precincts in; the official canvass had not been posted when this file was updated. Nothing here is a comment on the guilt or innocence of any criminal defendant whose conviction was reversed on procedural grounds; both reversals rested on the undisclosed judicial conflict rather than on any question about the evidence. The two defendants, the police officer, the court employees and the other private individuals described in the record are referred to here only by role, and the child victim is not described beyond what the opinion required. The officer is accused of no wrongdoing. The judge’s opponent, now the judge-elect, is named because she is named in the election case caption and stood for public office; she is accused of nothing. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.