Judge Kristina Karle Admonished for a Bail Request Text
On October 13, 2026, the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct determined that Judge Kristina Karle should be publicly admonished, with all eleven members concurring. On January 24, 2025, Karle worked out where the daughter of her sister’s friend would be arraigned on an arrest warrant, called that court and left her name and judicial title with the clerk, then texted the presiding judge, identified herself as an Ontario County judge, and wrote: My request if legally permissible please set bail and hold her. She explained that the young woman was in severe addiction and living on the street and that her family believed custody was the last chance to get her into treatment. The judge who received the text sought guidance from the Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics, told Karle they were uncomfortable, and recused. Karle apologized immediately and reported herself to the Commission. She stipulated to the facts and to admonition in an Agreed Statement of Facts. The determination is not final until a 30-day window for Court of Appeals review runs out.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Kristina Karle |
| Court | County and Family Courts, Ontario County, New York, since 2019; Acting Justice of the Supreme Court, Ontario County, since 2021 |
| Admitted | New York, 1998. Her term expires December 31, 2028 |
| Conduct | January 24, 2025 |
| Complaint | Formal Written Complaint dated April 23, 2026, containing one charge |
| Agreed Statement | Entered July 29, 2026; accepted by the Commission September 24, 2026; further submissions and oral argument waived |
| Determination | October 13, 2026. Sanction: admonition, the lowest public sanction New York imposes. All eleven members concurred |
| Rules Violated | Sections 100.1, 100.2(A), 100.2(B), 100.2(C), 100.3(B)(6) and 100.4(A)(1), (2) and (3) of the Rules Governing Judicial Conduct |
| Status | Not final. She has 30 days from receipt of the determination to request review by the Court of Appeals |
What She Did on January 24
The young woman, a non-party to anything in Karle’s court and referred to here only by role, was scheduled to be arraigned on an arrest warrant somewhere in the court system that morning. Karle did not know where.
So she called another County Court judge to find out where the arraignment would happen. Then she called that court and asked the clerk to have the judge return her call, giving the clerk her name, her judicial title and her cell phone number. Then she texted the judge directly, I am a county court judge in Ontario county, and asked the judge to call her about a case on the morning calendar. When the judge called back she introduced herself again as the Ontario County Court judge and asked whether the arraignment was on that court’s calendar. The answer was no. Hours later the judge texted that word had come in of a warrant return that afternoon.
The Commission’s charge described all of this as a favor to her sister, for purposes unrelated to her official duties, in which she repeatedly invoked her judicial title. Nothing she did would have worked the same way if she had been a private citizen. The clerk took the message, the judge returned the call, and the judge answered the text, because a judge was asking.
The Request
Her reply opened with the operative sentence: My request if legally permissible please set bail and hold her. What followed was a description of a young woman in severe addiction, homeless, whom the family believed would die without intervention, with the explanation that they hoped detention would get her into treatment. She closed by offering to step out of a trial she was conducting if the judge wanted to speak with her.
If legally permissible sounds like deference to the other judge’s authority but it changed nothing. The problem was never that she told a judge to do something unlawful. The problem was that a judge, invoking her office, communicated with the judge handling a pending matter, about that matter, on behalf of someone she knew, outside the presence of the parties.
| WHY THE REASON DOES NOT RESCUE IT
The Commission has heard this argument before and has a line of its own precedent rejecting it, which it cited here. In Matter of Ramirez, reported in the Commission’s 2018 Annual Report, a judge’s judgment was clouded by what the Commission called a sincere, albeit misguided, desire to help her son and a friend, and that did not justify a departure from the standards expected of the judiciary, because her communications could be perceived as backed by her judicial power and prestige. In Matter of Edwards, 67 NY2d 153 (1986), the Court of Appeals held that a petitioner’s paternal instincts do not justify such a departure either. The governing statement is older still. In Matter of Lonschein, 50 NY2d 569 (1980), also cited in Case File No. 57, the Court of Appeals wrote that no judge should ever allow personal relationships to color his conduct or lend the prestige of his office to advance the private interests of others, and that judges must assiduously avoid contacts that might create even the appearance of impropriety. A rule that bent for sympathetic motives would be no rule, because the judge who intervenes always has a reason that satisfies her. |
The Other Judge Did It Right
The judge who received the texts sought advice from counsel to the Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics, told Karle plainly that they were uncomfortable with the communication, and recused from the matter. The Commission went out of its way to commend that judge for taking the appropriate steps in a difficult situation.
The advice the judge received was not optional. The Advisory Committee’s Opinion 25-28, issued February 6, 2025, on these very facts, states that a judge with first-hand knowledge that another judge improperly attempted to influence the outcome of a case before him or her must report the other judge to the Commission. The Commission also recognized the challenging position judges are placed in when a fellow judge engages in misconduct. The system only works if the judge on the receiving end is willing to make an enemy.
The Same Conduct, Two Very Different Endings
Case File No. 54 is the other judge-to-judge influence case in this series, and it is the same wrong handled the opposite way at every turn. A Philadelphia judge is alleged to have had his assistant summon a colleague to his robing room, held out a paper with a defendant’s name and the colleague’s courtroom number and sentencing date, asked OK, and destroyed the paper. He has called it a misunderstanding, contested the charges, and the case is before the Court of Judicial Discipline with removal on the table.
Karle apologized to the judge immediately, by text. She self-reported to the Commission. She acknowledged in the stipulated record that her intervention was improper notwithstanding her concern for the young woman, and that she regretted putting a fellow judge in the position of having to recuse. She agreed to the facts and to the sanction. She got an admonition, the lowest public sanction New York has.
The gap between a removal proceeding and an admonition, on conduct in the same category, is almost entirely about what the judge did in the hour after the contact.
The Rules She Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Section 100.1 | A judge shall uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary and observe high standards of conduct so that its integrity and independence are preserved. |
| Section 100.2(A) | A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary. |
| Section 100.2(B) | A judge shall not allow family, social, political or other relationships to influence the judge’s judicial conduct or judgment. |
| Section 100.2(C) | A judge shall not lend the prestige of judicial office to advance the private interests of the judge or others. |
| Section 100.3(B)(6) | A judge shall not initiate, permit or consider ex parte communications concerning a pending or impending proceeding, subject to limited exceptions that did not apply. |
| Section 100.4(A)(1), (2) and (3) | A judge shall conduct extra-judicial activities so that they do not cast reasonable doubt on the judge’s capacity to act impartially, do not detract from the dignity of judicial office, and do not interfere with the proper performance of judicial duties. |
How It Works in Texas
Every piece of this maps onto Texas law, and one piece maps onto a duty most Texas lawyers do not know judges have. Texas Canon 2B is the prestige rule and reads almost identically to New York’s: a judge shall not lend the prestige of judicial office to advance the private interests of the judge or others, and shall not allow any relationship to influence judicial conduct or judgment. Texas Canon 3B(8) is the ex parte rule, with its own short list of exceptions, none of which covers a request like this one. For how a complaint moves through the Texas system, see our explainer, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained.
Texas Canon 3D(1) provides that a judge who receives information clearly establishing that another judge has committed a violation should take appropriate action, and that a judge having knowledge of a violation raising a substantial question as to another judge’s fitness for office shall inform the State Commission on Judicial Conduct or take other appropriate action. Canon 3D(2) does the same for lawyers, pointing to the Office of the General Counsel of the State Bar. So a Texas judge who received Karle’s text would face the same choice the New York judge faced, under a canon rather than an advisory opinion.
Article 17.15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets out the rules a Texas court applies in fixing bail and its conditions: bail sufficient to give reasonable assurance the undertaking will be complied with, the nature of the offense, the defendant’s ability to make bail, the safety of the victim, law enforcement and the community, and the defendant’s criminal history, among others. Getting a defendant into drug treatment is not among them. The article also says expressly that the power to require bail is not to be used to make bail an instrument of oppression, which is the provision that most directly answers a request to hold someone for her own good. And Texas treats this seriously enough to put it in the discipline statute: Government Code section 33.001(b)(7) lists persistent or wilful violation of Article 17.15 as grounds for judicial discipline.
None of that means the concern was misplaced. It means the concern belonged somewhere else: a treatment court or drug court docket, a court-ordered treatment proceeding under the Health and Safety Code, a motion by counsel for conditions of release built around treatment, or a referral the family could pursue on its own. Every one of those routes goes through the parties and stays on the record. The one route that was not available was the one that went judge to judge.
| IF YOU LEARN OF AN EX PARTE CONTACT IN YOUR CASE
Get it on the record immediately. Ask the court to state on the record what communication occurred, who made it and what was said. New York’s Commission has said a judge who receives such a communication is in a compromising position that requires prompt disclosure and an offer to step aside (Matter of Dixon, 2017). If a Texas court does not put it on the record, ask. Recusal is the usual remedy, and it is not automatic. The judge who received this text recused on their own. If a Texas judge does not, a motion to recuse under Rule 18a is the vehicle, and if the judge declines to recuse, it goes to the regional presiding judge rather than being decided by the judge you are complaining about. A conduct complaint is a separate track that does not fix your case. Filing with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct does not undo a ruling, does not pause anything, and will not be resolved on your timeline. Pursue the recusal in the case and the complaint separately, if the conduct warrants it. Watch for the contact you cannot see. This one surfaced because the receiving judge sought advice and the judge who sent it reported herself. Many never surface. That is an argument for asking, on the record, when a ruling arrives that nothing in the filings explains. |
How It Played in the Press
Rochester and Finger Lakes outlets carried the determination the week it was released. WXXI News noted that admonition is the second-lowest discipline the Commission administers, counting its confidential letters of caution, and Finger Lakes 1 ran it as Karle admitting she tried to influence another judge. The coverage focused on the request itself. Less was said about the judge on the receiving end, whose response is the part of the record other judges can actually use.
Where Things Stand Now
Karle remains on the bench. An admonition is the lowest of New York’s three public sanctions, below censure and removal, and it does not affect her service. She has 30 days from receipt of the determination to ask the Court of Appeals to review it. Because she stipulated to both the facts and the sanction, a request would be surprising; if none comes, the admonition stands and the matter ends. Her term runs through December 31, 2028.
The Commission closed by saying it trusts she has learned from the experience and will act in strict accordance with her obligations in the future. It is also, for this series, the second Ontario County judge before the Commission inside a year. Case File No. 46 covers the other one, Canandaigua Town Justice Walter Jones, whom the Court of Appeals removed on October 27, 2026.
| Facing the System in Texas?
What happens off the record can decide your case. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
PRIMARY SOURCES
- New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Determination, In the Matter of Kristina Karle, a Judge of the County and Family Courts and an Acting Justice of the Supreme Court, Ontario County (Oct. 13, 2026). All facts, quotations and rule citations in this post come from that determination and the Agreed Statement of Facts it adopts. cjc.ny.gov (pdf)
- New York Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics, Opinion 25-28 (Feb. 6, 2025). nycourts.gov
- Matter of Lonschein, 50 NY2d 569 (1980). courtlistener.com
- Matter of Edwards, 67 NY2d 153 (1986). courtlistener.com
- New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, 2018 Annual Report, including Matter of Ramirez. cjc.ny.gov (pdf)
NEWS COVERAGE
- Finger Lakes 1, Ontario County Judge Kristina Karle admits trying to influence another judge (Oct. 26, 2026). fingerlakes1.com
- WXXI News, State judicial commission admonishes Ontario County Judge Karle (Oct. 26, 2026). wxxinews.org
- Finger Lakes 1, on the Court of Appeals’ removal of Canandaigua Town Justice Walter Jones (Oct. 28, 2026). fingerlakes1.com
REFERENCE
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canons 2B, 3B(8) and 3D. txcourts.gov (pdf)
- Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 17.15, rules for fixing the amount of bail. statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Gov’t Code Section 33.001(b)(7). Government Code ch. 33
- Deandra Grant Law, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained. texasdwisite.com
- This post summarizes a publicly filed judicial-conduct determination and news reporting for general informational purposes as of publication. It is not legal advice. The determination is not final: Judge Karle may request review by the New York Court of Appeals within 30 days of receipt. She stipulated to the facts and to the sanction of admonition, which is the lowest public sanction New York imposes. The young woman whose arraignment was at issue is identified in the determination only by initials; she is referred to here by role alone, is accused of no wrongdoing in connection with this matter, and the personal details the determination records about her health and circumstances are deliberately not reproduced. The judge who received the communication, the court clerk and the judge’s family members are likewise referred to by role. The Philadelphia matter described in Case File No. 54 remains a contested allegation.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.