Judge Marcos Lizarraga and the Secret Murder Trial Talks
On April 11, 2025, the State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly admonished 168th District Court Judge Marcos Lizarraga of El Paso for four private conferences he held during a 2019 murder trial, three with the defense and one with the prosecution, each outside the presence of the other side. The case began with twenty-one complaints filed in the weeks after that trial ended in a mistrial, grew into a formal proceeding that charged him with bias, an improper appointment and failure to cooperate, and could have ended in a recommendation of removal. Six years later it ended in the least severe sanction the Commission can put on the public record.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Hon. Marcos Lizarraga |
| Court | 168th Judicial District Court, El Paso County |
| CJC Numbers | Twenty-two consolidated: twenty-one filed in 2019, beginning 19-1353, plus 21-1723 |
| Conduct | Four ex parte conferences during the May and June 2019 murder trial of Moises Galvan |
| Reviewed | Commission meeting of April 2 and 3, 2025; he appeared and testified April 3 |
| Date Issued | April 11, 2025 |
| Sanction | Public admonition |
| Provision Violated | Canon 3B(8) of the Texas Code of Judicial Conduct |
| Signed By | Ken Wise, Vice-Chair, State Commission on Judicial Conduct |
| Status | Did not seek re-election; term ends December 31, 2026 |
What Happened at Trial
In May 2019, Judge Lizarraga presided over the murder trial of Moises Galvan in El Paso. Galvan had been indicted on March 2, 2017 on two counts, murder and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, over a shooting outside a bar that January. The trial began on May 8, 2019.
Over the next three weeks the judge held four private conferences about the case with lawyers from one side at a time. Three were with defense counsel and one was with the prosecution. The Texas Code of Judicial Conduct calls these ex parte communications, and Canon 3B(8) prohibits a judge from initiating, permitting, or considering them on the merits of a pending case.
The fourth conference produced the exchange that makes this order worth reading. On the record, defense counsel told the judge he had wanted to meet privately so he would not, in his words, get in a fight with these two women, meaning the two prosecutors. The judge answered: “That’s not a reason to ex parte.” He was right, and he held the conference anyway.
Asked about the pattern, he acknowledged the conferences and told the Commission he had adopted what he called effective ex parte conferences based on an opinion of the Fourth Court of Appeals, Ex parte Miguel Martinez, 560 S.W.3d 681 (Tex. App.-San Antonio 2018, pet. ref’d). The Commission was not persuaded. Its conclusion is narrower than the conduct and worth noticing: he was admonished for considering improper ex parte communications from either side concerning the merits, which is the third verb in the canon and the one that does not depend on whose idea the meeting was.
It is worth looking at what that case actually is. Ex parte Miguel Martinez is a double jeopardy decision out of San Antonio, No. 04-17-00280-CR, issued July 31, 2018. The question was whether a retrial was barred after a mistrial that followed the State’s late disclosure that a former second chair prosecutor had a past relationship with a key witness. The court held it was not. The ex parte conference that appears in it belonged to the prosecution, was sought by written motion, was held in chambers with the court reporter present, and ended with the trial judge telling the prosecutor to disclose the information to the defense and not to delay.
That is a different thing from four unrecorded side conferences held during trial, one of them requested to avoid an argument with opposing counsel. A judge looking for authority to hold private conferences will not find a rule in that case, and the Commission did not find one there either.
The Four Private Conversations
| When and With Whom | What Was Discussed |
| May 17, 2019, defense alone | Whether testimony the defense did not want to preview for the State was relevant. After the conference the judge ruled it relevant and let the questioning proceed. |
| May 28, 2019, defense alone | An allegation that a lawyer for one of the complainants had approached the partner of a defense witness. |
| May 28, 2019, two prosecutors alone | The same alleged witness tampering, offered as the reason a witness was reluctant to testify. |
| June 1, 2019, defense alone | Whether a prosecution witness could invoke the Fifth Amendment, and how that would affect his separate federal case. |
| THE DISCIPLINE LADDER (TEXAS)
The State Commission on Judicial Conduct issues sanctions in order of severity as admonitions, warnings, reprimands and censures, either privately or publicly. A public admonition, the sanction here, is the least severe the Commission can issue on the public record. Removal and involuntary suspension are a different track: those require a separate review tribunal or the Texas Supreme Court, not the Commission acting alone. |
From Formal Proceedings to One Admonition
The private conferences were a fraction of what reached the Commission. The trial ended in a mistrial in June 2019 after the judge found that a prosecutor had asked an improper question in front of the jury, a ruling the district attorney’s office publicly disputed. Within weeks, twenty-one complaints were filed against him.
The Commission did not handle it informally. It opened formal proceedings, the trial track that can end in a public censure or a recommendation of removal to a review tribunal, and by February 2022 the notice of formal proceedings had become public through local reporting. It charged four things: bias against the prosecution, which the notice tied to the prosecutors being women; an improper relationship with and bias toward the defense, including appointing a defense lawyer who was not next in the public defender rotation and who had donated to the judge’s 2013 campaign, with that lawyer paid $72,765 and second counsel $34,485, which the notice called more than reasonable; an improper in-chambers hearing; and failure to cooperate with the Commission’s own investigation.
He denied each allegation and demanded strict proof. He admitted making the appointments and denied overpaying anyone or favoring the defense.
In March 2022 a visiting judge granted the State’s motion to recuse him from the retrial. Galvan was tried before a different judge in 2023, convicted, and sentenced to fifty-five years. He remains in prison.
Three years after that recusal the Commission’s public order arrived, and it addressed none of it. No bias finding. No finding about the appointment or the fees. No finding on cooperation. Twenty-two case numbers were consolidated into a single conclusion about the four conferences, and the sanction was a public admonition.
The order does not say why, and this file will not guess. What the public record shows is a proceeding that began as something that could have ended a career and closed at the bottom of the public ladder, with the charges that drew the headlines resolved by not appearing. That gap between what a formal proceeding alleges and what an order finds is itself worth understanding, because the allegations are the part the public remembers and the findings are the part that is actually true.
The Rule He Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Canon 3B(8) | A judge shall not initiate, permit, or consider ex parte communications, or other communications made to the judge outside the presence of the parties, between the judge and a party, an attorney, or any other court appointee, concerning the merits of a pending or impending judicial proceeding. |
Three of these four conferences were requested by the defense, for reasons that sound practical in the moment: not wanting to show the State a line of questioning, not wanting an argument in front of opposing counsel. The judge himself said on the record that avoiding a fight is not a reason to ex parte. A lawyer who accepts the invitation gets an advantage that evaporates on appeal and a judge who may later be recused from the case.
How It Played in the Press
El Paso’s television and digital outlets followed this for years rather than only at the end. KVIA, KFOX14 and KTSM covered the mistrial, the twenty-one complaints, the 2022 reporting that he could face removal, and his recusal from the retrial. The underlying murder case was later the subject of a true crime podcast episode.
When the admonition issued in 2025, CBS4 and the judicial accountability site AbusiveDiscretion.com covered it, and it followed him into his next campaign. El Paso Matters raised the admonition twice while covering his run for a county court at law bench in the 2026 Democratic primary.
Where Things Stand
Judge Lizarraga won the 168th District Court seat in 2010 and was re-elected in 2014, 2018 and 2022. He did not seek re-election in 2026. He ran instead in the March 3, 2026 Democratic primary for El Paso County Court at Law No. 4, a misdemeanor court, and lost outright to a municipal and jail magistrate judge who took 52.5 percent to his 34.1 percent in a three way race, avoiding a runoff. His term on the 168th ends December 31, 2026.
The seat he is leaving is one of two contested district judge races on the November 3, 2026 ballot in El Paso. The Democratic nomination for it went to a candidate who won a runoff in May.
The admonition itself is final and permanent. He did not take it to a special court of review, which is the only way a Texas judge can have a public sanction rescinded, and it sits in the Commission’s public record under his name. The Gavel of Shame series will follow if anything changes.
| Facing the System in Texas?
A private conversation with the judge about your case, without the other side in the room, is not a shortcut. It is a problem for whoever benefits from it, and the place to raise it is on the record while it is happening. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
Primary source
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Admonition of the Honorable Marcos Lizarraga, CJC Nos. 19-1353 et al., issued April 11, 2025. scjc.texas.gov
News coverage
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct in litigation with judge over handling of the Galvan case, KFOX14 Investigates (February 2022). kfoxtv.com
- El Paso judge removed from murder retrial, KTSM. ktsm.com
- Appeals court denies motion to dismiss murder indictment of El Paso man, KVIA (November 3, 2022). kvia.com
- El Paso judge publicly admonished over improper meetings in criminal case, CBS4 and KFOX14. cbs4local.com
- Conduct concerns surface among El Paso County Courts at Law judicial candidates, El Paso Matters (February 11, 2026). elpasomatters.org
- Primary election results, El Paso judicial races, El Paso Matters (March 3, 2026). elpasomatters.org
- El Paso voters to choose between Democratic and Republican candidates in two contested district judge races, El Paso Matters (October 13, 2026). elpasomatters.org
- Texas Commission on Judicial Conduct admonishes Judge Marcos Lizarraga for improper ex parte communications, AbusiveDiscretion.com. abusivediscretion.com
Reference
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, public sanctions, fiscal year 2025. scjc.texas.gov
- Marcos Lizarraga, electoral history and 2026 primary results. ballotpedia.org
This post summarizes a public sanction issued by the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, together with the Commission’s notice of formal proceedings as reported in 2022 and contemporaneous news coverage. The findings in the order are limited to the ex parte conferences; the other allegations described here were charged and never adjudicated, and Judge Lizarraga denied them. The defendant in the underlying murder case is named because his prosecution and conviction are a matter of public record. The complainants, the witnesses, the defense lawyers and the prosecutors are identified in the order but are referred to here only by role, and none of them is accused of any wrongdoing. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.