Judge Mark Luitjen Admonished Twice on the Same Day
On December 4, 2020, the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly admonished Bexar County senior district judge Mark Luitjen twice. The first admonition was for arranging an ex parte conversation with the prosecution during a recess, while defense counsel was out of the courtroom. The second was for saying ethnic slurs aloud in his courtroom four days after the El Paso Walmart shooting, with staff, attorneys and defendants present. The second came with an order of additional education in racial sensitivity. He remains on the Fourth Administrative Judicial Region’s list of senior and former judges eligible for assignment.

How a Bexar County senior district judge drew two public sanctions from the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct in a single order cycle, one for an ex parte call and one for slurs spoken aloud in his courtroom
| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Hon. Mark R. Luitjen, senior district judge sitting by assignment |
| Court | Bexar County district courts, by assignment; elected to the 144th Criminal District Court 1999 to 2006 |
| CJC Numbers | 19-0833 (ex parte) and 20-0468 (courtroom remarks) |
| Reviewed | Commission meeting of August 5 and 6, 2020 |
| Date Issued | December 4, 2020 |
| Sanctions | Two public admonitions; the second with an order of additional education |
| Provisions | Canon 3B(8) of the Texas Code of Judicial Conduct; Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 1-a(6)A |
| Education | Two hours with a mentor in racial sensitivity training, on top of required judicial education |
| Signed By | David Hall, Chairman, State Commission on Judicial Conduct |
| Current Status | Listed as eligible for assignment in the Fourth Administrative Judicial Region as of August 11, 2026 |
Two sanctions, two episodes about a year apart, one order cycle. One was a quiet procedural shortcut. The other was said out loud, in a courtroom, in front of everyone in it.
Neither is dramatic in the made for television sense. Read together they sketch a judge who twice misjudged where the lines of his office were drawn, and a discipline system that measures conduct by its effect on fairness and public confidence rather than by whether the judge meant any harm.
The First Admonition: An Ex Parte Call During a Recess
At an August 31, 2018 hearing in a Bexar County criminal case, Cause Nos. 2017-CR-7980 and 2017-CR-12813, the defendant had moved to withdraw his plea and for a new trial. Judge Luitjen, sitting by assignment in the 399th District Court, questioned whether he still had jurisdiction to rule given how much time had passed. He recessed for about 45 minutes to research it.
Defense counsel was not in the courtroom during the recess. The Commission found that the judge asked a prosecutor to summon someone from the District Attorney’s appellate section to come to court and discuss the jurisdiction question, and that he then allowed a second prosecutor to relay word that the office’s appellate chief agreed the court lacked jurisdiction. When the hearing reconvened, the judge announced that he had consulted the District Attorney’s Office and that the State believed he was right. Defense counsel objected. The judge answered that he believed he could consult anyone he wanted while researching a case.
Ex parte means from one side only. Canon 3B(8) bars a judge from initiating, permitting, or considering ex parte communications about the merits of a pending matter. The Commission found Judge Luitjen did both of the first two. He initiated the contact by arranging for the prosecution to weigh in during the recess, and he permitted it by letting the State’s position reach him while the defense was absent.
His defenses did not cure it. He said he had only invited the appellate section to participate in the hearing. He said he had already decided the jurisdiction question before the message reached him. He said he disclosed the contact as soon as the hearing resumed, and he disputed a line in the transcript attributing the call to a different person. The Commission’s answer is the part worth keeping: the rule forbids arranging or allowing the contact, so you do not have to be persuaded by it to violate the canon. The order also notes that when he disclosed the contact, he neither admonished the State for it nor said he would disregard what he had been told.
| WHY EX PARTE CONTACT IS BARRED
A one sided conversation about a pending case, even one about something that sounds procedural like jurisdiction, takes away the other side’s chance to hear it and respond. Canon 3B(8) bars a judge from initiating, permitting, or considering it. Arranging or allowing the contact is enough. Being persuaded by it is not required. |
The Second Admonition: Slurs in the Courtroom
August 7, 2019 was four days after the mass shooting at an El Paso Walmart that targeted Latino shoppers. Judge Luitjen had finished magistrating several undocumented immigrants. During a recess he fell into a conversation with the court reporter about the shooting and about the language news coverage was using to describe Mexican citizens.
What he said, according to the Commission’s findings, was that things had been easier in the past when people used two particular slurs for undocumented immigrants from Mexico, in English and in Spanish, and he used the actual words. He said it aloud, in the courtroom, while court staff, attorneys and defendants were still present. We do not reproduce the slurs here.
In his response he said he and the court reporter had been discussing political correctness and changing sensitivities, that what was appropriate yesterday can be scandalous today, and that he was describing how people used to speak rather than labeling anyone. He said he had never used those words about any person, that they were not considered slurs when he was in high school, and that he had already apologized in a news article to anyone who was offended. He also disputed the account given by the staff member who reported it.
The Commission was not persuaded by the framing. Under Article V, Section 1-a(6)A of the Texas Constitution, which bars willful conduct that casts public discredit upon the judiciary, saying the words aloud in open court was enough. The Commission publicly admonished him and ordered two hours of additional education with a mentor in racial sensitivity training, on top of his required judicial education for the year. The mentor is assigned through the Texas Center for the Judiciary, the sessions have to be scheduled within 60 days of written notice, and he had to certify completion back to the Commission.
What Ties the Two Together
The episodes look nothing alike. One is a phone call, the other a sentence. They share a root. In both, the judge did not think he had crossed a line. In the first he believed he could consult whomever he liked about a pending case. In the second he believed that describing historical slurs was not the same as using them.
The Commission disagreed both times, because judicial conduct rules are not graded on intent alone. They are graded on what the conduct does to the fairness of a proceeding and to public confidence in the courts. A one sided call during a recess corrodes the first. Slurs spoken in a courtroom four days after a massacre aimed at the community sitting in it corrode the second.
You are entitled to a judge who keeps both sides in the room when your case is discussed, and who extends the dignity of the office to everyone in the courtroom. When either breaks down it is not a question of manners. It goes to whether the proceeding was fair and whether the institution deserves trust.
The Rules He Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Canon 3B(8) | A judge shall not initiate, permit, or consider ex parte communications concerning the merits of a pending or impending judicial proceeding. |
| Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 1-a(6)A | A judge shall not engage in willful or persistent conduct that is clearly inconsistent with the proper performance of judicial duties or that casts public discredit upon the judiciary. |
About the Sanctions
A public admonition is the least severe public sanction the State Commission on Judicial Conduct issues. It can admonish, warn, or reprimand, privately or publicly, order additional education, and in the gravest cases recommend censure or removal to a review tribunal. Drawing two public sanctions in one order cycle is itself unusual, and the second came with a remedy the Commission does not often use.
The two matters rest on different footing, which is why they produced two orders rather than one. The ex parte admonition rests on a canon of the Texas Code of Judicial Conduct. The courtroom remarks admonition rests on the constitutional standard directly, because no canon squarely covers what he said. Both were issued under the Commission’s authority in Article V, Section 1-a(8).
Most judicial conduct problems are not cartoon villainy. They are misjudgments by people who believe they are in the right. A shortcut here, a careless remark there. The rules, and the public record the Commission creates, exist because good intentions are not the test.
The Visiting Judge Problem
Both episodes happened while Judge Luitjen was sitting by assignment, which is worth mentioning because a visiting judge is harder to get away from than an elected one.
A party in a civil case gets one objection to an assigned judge as a matter of right under Government Code section 74.053(b). File it within seven days of notice, or before the first hearing, whichever comes first, and that judge does not hear the case. No reason is required. Section 74.053(d) goes further for a judge who lost the last election for the seat: either party can object, and there is no one objection limit.
None of that reaches a criminal case. Section 74.053(b) says a party to a civil case, and the courts have read it that way. A criminal defendant who draws a visiting judge has the ordinary recusal and disqualification motions under Rule 18b and nothing else. The defendant in the 2018 hearing in this file was in a criminal case.
That is the practical lesson under both admonitions. The ex parte contact and the courtroom remarks both happened in front of criminal defendants, and criminal defendants are the people with the fewest tools for choosing who hears them.
How It Played in the Press
The slurs were public more than a year before the Commission ruled. In August 2019, San Antonio media reported the remarks, including KSAT’s longtime courthouse reporter and the San Antonio Current. The coverage carried something the Commission’s order does not mention: the remarks had already cost him his place on the local roster of available visiting judges, after the regional presiding judge removed him.
In those interviews he acknowledged the remarks, said words matter, and apologized to anyone offended, while maintaining he had been describing how people used to talk rather than insulting anyone. That is the news article the Commission’s order refers to. The reporting also flagged the open question of whether the matter would be referred to the State Commission on Judicial Conduct. It was, and in December 2020 the Commission added two public admonitions to the record.
Where Things Stand
Mark Luitjen was elected to the 144th Criminal District Court in Bexar County in 1998 and served from 1999 to 2006. He ran once more, in 2012, for the 379th District Court, and lost to the incumbent. Since leaving the elected bench he has worked as a senior judge sitting by assignment.
The removal from the local visiting judge roster in August 2019 did not end that. The Fourth Administrative Judicial Region’s list of senior and former judges eligible for assignment, revised August 11, 2026, names him at number 15, senior district judge of the 144th, criminal specialty. Eligibility on the regional list is not the same as receiving assignments, and the list does not show how often a judge is actually used. What it does show is that the two public admonitions did not remove him from the pool.
That is how the Texas system is built. A public admonition is a permanent, public mark on the record. It is not a bar to sitting. Anyone who wants to know whether the judge in front of them carries one can look it up on the Commission’s website, which is the entire point of making the sanction public. The Gavel of Shame series will follow if anything changes.
| Worried Your Case Was Not Decided Fairly?
Ex parte contact, judicial bias, and procedural shortcuts can be grounds to challenge a ruling, and the objection and recusal deadlines are short. Knowing which ones apply to your case, and when they run, is part of the job. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
Primary sources
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Admonition of the Honorable Mark Luitjen, CJC No. 19-0833 (ex parte communications), December 4, 2020. scjc.texas.gov
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, Public Admonition and Order of Additional Education of the Honorable Mark Luitjen, CJC No. 20-0468 (courtroom remarks), December 4, 2020. scjc.texas.gov
- Fourth Administrative Judicial Region, senior and former judges eligible for assignment, revised August 11, 2026. txcourts.gov
News coverage
- Paul Venema, Local judge barred, apologizes after making racial slurs, KSAT (August 14, 2019). ksat.com
- Visiting judge offers apology after using racial slurs against undocumented immigrants in San Antonio, San Antonio Current (August 2019). sacurrent.com
Reference
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 3B(8); Tex. Const. art. V, sec. 1-a. scjc.texas.gov
- Tex. Gov’t Code sec. 74.053 (objection to an assigned judge in a civil case). texas.public.law
This post summarizes the findings of two public sanctions issued by the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct. All findings are drawn from those public orders. In his responses Judge Luitjen disputed that his conduct was improper. The prosecutors, court staff and criminal defendant involved are identified in the orders but are referred to here only by role; none of them is accused of any wrongdoing. The slurs found by the Commission are described rather than reproduced. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.