Judge Thomas Wilson Hid 18 Years of Delayed Decisions
On October 9, 2026, the Michigan Supreme Court adopted the Judicial Tenure Commission’s stipulated findings against Judge Thomas D. Wilson of the 4th Circuit Court in Jackson County and ordered the sanction he had consented to: retirement from the bench effective February 28, 2026, a permanent bar on seeking election or appointment to judicial office, and no visiting-judge appointments until after September 1, 2026. The Court reviewed the record de novo and adopted both the findings and the legal conclusions as its own. The findings run across seven categories and fifteen violations. The one that organizes the rest is concealment: from about the time he took the bench in January 2007 until April 2025, Wilson instructed his staff not to code any case as under advisement in the court’s computer system, and the Commission found his purpose was to hide his delayed matters, including from the State Court Administrative Office. The Court called it an ongoing act of deception.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Thomas D. Wilson |
| Court | 4th Circuit Court, Jackson County, Michigan |
| On the Bench | Took office January 2007; chief judge of the 4th Circuit Court during his 2013 to 2015 divorce proceedings and in 2017 |
| Case | Michigan Supreme Court No. 169031; Judicial Tenure Commission Formal Complaint No. 110 |
| Order | October 9, 2026, adopting the Commission’s decision and recommendation on consent |
| Sanction | Retirement effective February 28, 2026; permanent bar on seeking election or appointment to judicial office; no visiting-judge appointment until after September 1, 2026 |
| Findings | Seven categories of misconduct, fifteen separate violations, all stipulated and adopted de novo |
| Separate Writing | Chief Justice Cavanagh concurring |
| Status | Final. He consented to the findings and the sanction and has left the bench |
Eighteen Years of Not Coding Cases
Michigan circuit courts code a case as under advisement when a judge takes a matter for decision, so the court’s computer system can track how long it sits. Court Rule 8.107(B) then requires trial judges to give the State Court Administrative Office quarterly statements identifying civil matters that were pending more than 56 days from submission. The coding feeds the reporting. Remove the coding and the reporting has nothing to report.
Wilson instructed his staff not to code any cases as under advisement, starting around the time he took the bench in January 2007 and continuing until April 2025. The Commission found, and the Court adopted, that his purpose was to conceal his delayed matters, including from the administrative office. Four specific cases went unreported as a result: two decisions that sat about a year each, and two 2024 matters in which rulings stayed pending for roughly six months apiece.
Every court has delay. What the Court found here was an eighteen-year instruction to staff that defeated the mechanism designed to surface it, which the Court characterized as dishonest and as an ongoing act of deception under Court Rule 9.104(3).
More Than Fifty Protective Orders
Michigan Court Rule 3.705(A)(1) gives a judge one business day to act on an ex parte petition for a personal protection order, and Rule 3.705(B)(1) requires petitions that do not seek ex parte relief to be heard as soon as possible unless the court finds the petition so lacking in merit that it should be dismissed without a hearing. The deadline is short because the request is an emergency by definition.
Wilson does not dispute that on three separate occasions, in 2018, in 2021 and in 2023, he failed to timely decide protective-order petitions assigned to him. Those occasions concerned more than fifty protective-order proceedings. The Court concluded that the failure violated the requirement that judicial duties take precedence over all other activities, the duty to dispose of court business promptly, and the duty to be faithful to the law, because he knew what the rules required.
| WHAT THE DELAY COST IN THREE CASES
A divorce matter involving elderly litigants, where there was concern that one or both could fall ill before resolution. He held a one-day bench trial in 2019, took it under submission on August 26, 2019, and did not rule until August 31, 2020. Counsel asked his staff about it repeatedly. He has no explanation for the delay. A civil case against a community college, where he took a summary disposition motion under advisement after a May 2021 hearing and left it pending until March 29, 2022, including four months while he was on medical leave. Again no explanation. A criminal case in which he imposed a delayed sentence under a statute he knew could not be invoked, over the prosecutor’s objection, and then dismissed the case. The Court of Appeals vacated the dismissal and remanded in April 2020 because there was no basis in law for it. He then took no action on the remand for 23 months. |
Using the Office for Family and Friends
A second group of findings concerns Wilson stepping into cases he had no business touching. In a domestic violence case pending before him, he learned that the defendant was about to be arrested for violating a no-contact order entered by another judge. He called police dispatch, without the knowledge of counsel, identified himself as Judge Wilson, said he had told the defendant to go to the protected person’s house to pick up medicine, said there was no need for an arrest, and said he had the situation all taken care of. His instruction to the defendant violated another judge’s no-contact order and exceeded his authority.
In his own post-judgment divorce proceedings he approached the judge who had disqualified herself, ex parte, to sign an order on which a $2,030 child-support balance had been crossed out by hand and a zero balance written in. When she said she could not sign because she had disqualified herself, he told her he had stopped the disqualification from going through. She signed only after his former wife gave her consent by phone. He had been chief judge of the circuit while the divorce was pending.
Two of his relatives had cases, and he worked both. In a retail-fraud matter he told a Washtenaw County referee that he was chief judge in Jackson County, after which the hearing recessed and never went back on the record, and he separately lobbied the referee and the assigned judge to move the case to his own county, which happened based in part on his requests. In a minor-in-possession matter he met separately with two prosecutors, referred to here by role, and asked them to dismiss. Both told him the case had been conflicted out to another county precisely because he was chief judge where it was filed. After each refused, he said things like what goes around comes around, and that he would remember this. The Commission found those remarks threatened retaliation for a refusal to comply with an improper request. He also approached the visiting prosecutor assigned to the case and mentioned people he knew in her county, which she took as an attempt to influence her.
The Rest of the Record
Three other categories are in the findings and are stated here as the Court stated them, without elaboration. Wilson abused alcohol from sometime between 2013 and 2015 until 2020 or 2021 and at times appeared in public, including at the courthouse, after drinking; between 2016 and 2019 seven people observed him smelling of alcohol, disheveled, or slurring. The Commission asked him in May 2019 to obtain a substance abuse assessment and he did not; asked again in 2024, he did, and that assessment found no present cause for concern and reported that the earlier problem appeared resolved. Between 2016 and 2018 he made remarks to several women he worked with that they received as offensive, and the Court concluded those remarks reflected discourteous treatment of women based on their gender.
He also failed for fifteen years to disclose financial and personal relationships with attorneys who appeared before him: three who were tenants in a building he owned, one who was an investment partner, and five who represented him or his family. The Court noted there is no evidence any of those relationships affected his decisions in any case. The violation was the silence, not the outcome.
| HOW MICHIGAN MEASURES SERIOUSNESS
The Court applied the seven factors from In re Brown, 461 Mich 1291 (2000), which are worth knowing because they are a clean statement of what aggravates judicial misconduct anywhere. Everything else being equal: a pattern is worse than an isolated instance; conduct on the bench is worse than the same conduct off it; prejudice to the actual administration of justice is worse than prejudice only to the appearance of propriety; conduct touching neither is less serious; spontaneous conduct is less serious than premeditated or deliberate conduct; conduct that undermines the system’s ability to find the truth is worse than conduct that merely delays it; and unequal application of justice on the basis of race, color, ethnic background, gender or religion is worse than breaches that do not disparage the system on the basis of a class of citizenship. It was a pattern rather than an instance, on the bench rather than off it, deliberate rather than spontaneous, and aimed squarely at the system’s ability to know what was happening in its own courtrooms. |
The Rules He Broke
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Canon 2(A) and 2(B) | A judge must avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety and must act in a manner that promotes public confidence in the judiciary. Applied to the alcohol conduct, the remarks to women, the ex parte contacts, the minor-in-possession case and the concealment of delay. |
| Canon 2(C) | A judge must not use the prestige of office to advance personal interests or the interests of others. Applied to the dispatch call, his own divorce proceedings and both relatives’ cases. |
| Canon 3(A)(1) | A judge must be faithful to the law. Applied to the delayed sentence imposed under a statute he knew could not be invoked, the 23-month inaction after remand, and the protective-order deadlines. |
| Canon 3(A)(4) | A judge must not initiate or consider ex parte communications. Applied to the dispatch call and to the approach to the disqualified judge. |
| Canon 3(A)(6) | A judge must dispose of the business of the court promptly. Applied to the delayed decisions, the inaction after remand and the protective-order petitions. |
| Canon 3(B)(1) and 3(B)(2) | A judge must diligently discharge administrative responsibilities and direct staff to observe high standards of diligence. Applied to the obstruction of delay reporting, the instruction to staff, and his interference with the disqualification in his divorce and the transfer of his relative’s case. |
| Canon 3(C) | A judge must disclose information that may be grounds for disqualification. Applied to each undisclosed attorney relationship between 2007 and 2022. |
| MCR 9.104(3), 9.202(B) and 9.221(E) | Dishonest conduct, habitual intemperance, and failing to comply with a reasonable request of the Commission. Applied to the concealment, the alcohol conduct and the 2019 assessment respectively. |
The Sanction and What It Actually Changed
The Order issued on October 9, 2026. It directs retirement effective February 28, 2026, which had already happened, and it bars visiting-judge appointments until after September 1, 2026, a date that had also already passed. The only part of the sanction with forward-looking force is the permanent bar on seeking election or appointment to judicial office. The Court ratified an exit that had already occurred.
Chief Justice Cavanagh concurred to make a related point about the limits of a consent agreement. The power to appoint a retired judge as a visiting judge belongs solely to the Supreme Court. Neither the Commission nor the respondent can compel or direct how that power is exercised, so the agreement’s finite bar does not bind the Court later. She added in a footnote that she expressed no opinion on a future appointment, while noting that the level of misconduct here would be relevant and likely dispositive.
In Case File No. 56 a Florida judge admitted the words, disputed the canons, retired, and the review closed with no findings and no sanction at all. In Case File No. 49 a New Hampshire chief justice resigned under a stipulation in which he admitted three violations. Here there are full findings, adopted de novo by the state’s highest court, plus a permanent bar on returning. Same exit, three very different records left behind.
How It Works in Texas
Texas Canon 3B(9) says a judge should dispose of all judicial matters promptly, efficiently and fairly, Canon 3B(8) governs ex parte communications with its own short list of exceptions, and Canon 2B forbids lending the prestige of judicial office to advance anyone’s private interests, which is the provision the dispatch call would be measured against here. For how the Texas disciplinary process runs from complaint to sanction, see our explainer, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained.
What Texas does not have is Michigan’s Rule 8.107(B). No Texas rule makes a trial judge personally certify, every quarter, which matters have sat undecided past a set number of days. The Texas time standards in Rule 6.1 of the Rules of Judicial Administration are expressly aspirational, saying judges should meet them so far as reasonably possible, and they are measured from the appearance date rather than from submission: eighteen months for a civil jury case, twelve for a civil nonjury case, six months for a contested family law case. The report a Texas district judge personally attests to twice a year, under Rule 6.3, is about hours spent presiding and on other judicial duties, not about which of his rulings are outstanding. Case-level data reaches the Office of Court Administration through the clerks.
There is no Texas mechanism for a judge to defeat the way Wilson defeated Michigan’s, because the mechanism does not exist. There is also nothing that would automatically surface a Texas judge sitting on a ruling for a year. A litigant’s remedies are the ones a litigant has to bring: a motion asking the court to rule, then mandamus in the court of appeals, since ruling on a properly filed and pending motion is a ministerial act, Safety-Kleen Corp. v. Garcia, 945 S.W.2d 268, 269 (Tex. App.-San Antonio 1997, orig. proceeding), and a complaint to the State Commission on Judicial Conduct under Canon 3B(9). None of those happen on their own.
On the protective-order side the Texas analogue is tighter. Family Code section 84.001(a) says that when an application for a protective order is filed the court must set a hearing and may not set a date later than the 14th day after the date the application is filed, with an exception in section 84.002 for district courts in certain counties, and section 84.001(b) forbids delaying a hearing in order to consolidate it with a later-filed application. Emergency relief runs on a separate track: section 83.001 lets a court issue a temporary ex parte protective order, without notice and without a hearing, on an application showing a clear and present danger of family violence. A Texas judge who let more than fifty of those sit would be answering under the Family Code and Canon 3B(9) both.
| IF YOUR CASE HAS BEEN SITTING
Put the request to rule in writing and set it. A letter to the coordinator is not a record. File a motion asking the court to rule, request a submission or hearing date, and make sure the request is file-stamped, because mandamus relief depends on showing the matter was actually presented and the court refused or failed to act. Track the clock from the right date. Texas time standards run from the appearance date, not from the day the judge took your motion under advisement. Know both numbers before you argue delay. Mandamus is the remedy, and reasonableness is the test. There is no magic number of days. Under In re Chavez, 62 S.W.3d 225, 228-29 (Tex. App.-Amarillo 2001, orig. proceeding), courts weigh the trial court’s actual knowledge of the motion, any overt refusal to act, the state of its docket and the other matters it must address first, and the relator has to bring evidence of them, which is one more reason the written request matters. The conduct complaint is a separate track. A complaint to the State Commission on Judicial Conduct does not get your ruling and does not pause anything in your case. File it if the conduct warrants it, but do not treat it as a substitute for asking the court to rule. |
Where Things Stand Now
This one is finished. Wilson consented to the findings and the sanction, waived his rights, left the bench in February 2026, and is permanently barred from seeking or accepting judicial office in Michigan. There is no appeal from a sanction a judge agreed to, and the Court adopted the Commission’s findings as its own after de novo review rather than merely accepting them. The one open question the order leaves is the one the Chief Justice flagged: whether he is ever appointed as a visiting judge is for the Court, not the agreement, and she signaled how that would likely go.
| Facing the System in Texas?
A ruling that never comes is its own kind of injustice, and there are ways to force one. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
PRIMARY SOURCES
- Michigan Supreme Court, Order, In re Thomas D. Wilson, Judge, 4th Circuit Court, No. 169031, JTC Formal Complaint No. 110 (Oct. 9, 2026), adopting the Judicial Tenure Commission’s stipulated findings of fact and conclusions of law, with Cavanagh, C.J., concurring. All findings, rule citations and quoted conclusions in this post are taken from that order. courts.michigan.gov (pdf)
- Michigan Supreme Court, Order appointing a master, No. 169031 (Oct. 2, 2025). courts.michigan.gov (pdf)
- Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission, Commission files FC 110 as to Hon. Thomas Wilson, 4th Circuit Court (Sept. 11, 2025). jtc.courts.mi.gov
- In re Brown, 461 Mich 1291 (2000), the seven seriousness factors. courtlistener.com
NEWS COVERAGE
- WILX, Michigan Supreme Court orders Judge Thomas Wilson to retire after misconduct findings (Oct. 9, 2026). wilx.com
- ABA Journal, Judge agrees to retire after allegations of drinking on the job, case delays and retaliation threats (Oct. 12, 2026). abajournal.com
- WKHM, Formal Complaint Against Jackson County Judge Alleges Heavy Misconduct, Sexual Harassment, and Alcohol Abuse (Sept. 2025), covering the complaint when it was filed. wkhm.com
REFERENCE
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canons 2B, 3B(8) and 3B(9). txcourts.gov (pdf)
- Texas Rules of Judicial Administration, effective July 1, 2026, Rule 6.1 time standards and Rule 6.3 district court time reporting. txcourts.gov (pdf)
- Safety-Kleen Corp. v. Garcia, 945 S.W.2d 268 (Tex. App.-San Antonio 1997, orig. proceeding). courtlistener.com
- In re Chavez, 62 S.W.3d 225 (Tex. App.-Amarillo 2001, orig. proceeding). courtlistener.com
- Texas Family Code section 84.001, setting the hearing on an application for a protective order. texas.public.law
- Texas Family Code section 83.001, temporary ex parte protective orders. texas.public.law
- Deandra Grant Law, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained. texasdwisite.com
- This post summarizes a public judicial-discipline order for general informational purposes as of publication. It is not legal advice. Judge Wilson stipulated to the findings and consented to the sanction, and the Michigan Supreme Court adopted the findings and conclusions as its own; nothing here is an allegation beyond what that order states. The Court found no evidence that his undisclosed relationships with attorneys affected his decisions in any case, and the 2024 assessment it cites found no present cause for concern regarding alcohol. Litigants, defendants, court staff, the prosecutors and the judge’s relatives are referred to by role and are not named, and no minor is identified.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.