Why Maryland Removed Chief Judge Vickie Gipson
On May 13, 2026, the Maryland Commission on Judicial Disabilities unanimously recommended the removal of Vickie Gipson, chief judge of the Anne Arundel County Orphans’ Court, calling her misconduct calculated, continuous and egregious. The Commission found sanctionable conduct across five categories, from undermining a colleague’s judicial independence to breaching the confidentiality of her own disciplinary proceeding to citing three cases in a court filing that do not exist. On October 5, 2026, the Supreme Court of Maryland heard argument and ordered her removed from office the same day, effective immediately, in a per curiam order in JD No. 2, September Term 2025. The Court found she had committed one or more of the charged violations and that removal was appropriate given the egregious nature of the misconduct. The full opinion had still not issued as of late October 2026. Below: what the Commission found, how her case compares to Knapp’s, what happened to this court at the ballot box, and how the same powers work in Texas.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Vickie Gipson, Chief Judge, Orphans’ Court for Anne Arundel County, Maryland |
| First elected | November 2018. Re-elected November 2022 and designated chief judge by the Governor the following summer |
| CJD numbers | 2024-051, -053, -054, -069 and -109 |
| Commission recommendation | Removal, signed May 13, 2026, unanimous among the eight members who participated, by Chair Anne K. Albright |
| Hearing | August 21 and 22, 2025 and December 5, 2025. She did not appear the first day; she appeared and testified December 5 |
| Removal ordered | October 5, 2026, argued and decided the same day. Per curiam order, JD No. 2, September Term 2025, clerk time stamp 4:09 p.m. |
| Panel | Watts, Booth, Biran, Gould and Eaves, with Senior Justices Glenn T. Harrell and Robert N. McDonald specially assigned. Chief Justice Fader and Justice Killough did not participate |
| Authority | Md. Rules 18-435(c), 18-437 and 18-437(f)(1); Md. Const. art. IV, sec. 4B(b)(1) |
| Status | Removed from office, effective immediately. Full opinion to follow and not yet filed |
| THE DISCIPLINE LADDER (MARYLAND)
Maryland’s Commission on Judicial Disabilities can privately reprimand a judge on its own, but every public sanction, from a public reprimand up through suspension and removal, requires the Commission to refer the matter to the Supreme Court of Maryland, which decides. A removal recommendation is the Commission’s strongest possible referral, and the Court may still impose something less severe. Twice on this feud it did not. |
The Order, and How Fast It Came
The Court heard argument on Monday, October 5, 2026, and removed her that afternoon. The clerk time stamped the order at 4:09 p.m. the same day. It removes her from office effective immediately and expressly reserves the Court’s reasons to be stated in an opinion later to be filed. That is the identical sequence the Court used with Knapp, whose order came the day of his argument and whose full opinion followed about six weeks later, on July 17, 2026.
She had filed formal exceptions to the Commission’s findings and asked for something short of removal, the Commission had responded to those exceptions, and the Court considered both along with the record before ruling.
Two justices sat it out. The order notes that neither Chief Justice Matthew Fader nor Justice Killough participated, with two senior justices specially assigned in their places. The order does not say why but the Commission made a finding that Gipson contacted Chief Justice Fader directly about her conflict with Knapp while it was unfolding.
One thing the order does not do is say which violations the Court sustained. It recites the nine Maryland Rules the Commission determined she violated, then concludes only that she committed one or more of them. As of late October 2026 the only document the Court has filed in the case is that four page order.
What Court This Is
Maryland’s Orphans’ Court is a probate court despite the name, handling wills, estates and guardianships of minors’ property. Most of its judges are elected in county elections and are not required to be lawyers, and they must have lived in the jurisdiction for at least twelve months before election. Three counties, Harford, Howard and Montgomery, dispense with separate Orphans’ Court judges altogether and have circuit judges sit instead.
Anne Arundel County has three Orphans’ Court judges who sit as a panel, and Maryland law requires the court to sit at least two full business days a week, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Those two facts, a three judge panel and a statutory sitting requirement, are what the first two categories of findings are about.
What the Commission Found
Gipson was first elected in November 2018, re-elected in November 2022 alongside two new colleagues, Marc Knapp and David Duba, and designated chief judge by the Governor the following summer. The Commission’s findings, reached by clear and convincing evidence after a hearing that ran from August to December 2025, are organized into five categories. Its summary of them is blunt: her misconduct was “calculated, continuous, and egregious.”
A colleague who rarely showed up, and was excused
Judge Duba was a full-time high school teacher when he took office. Rather than require him to comply with the sitting requirement, Gipson approved a schedule that let him work court hours in the afternoon around his teaching job, then let him arrive around 11 a.m. once school was in session. Between December 2022 and June 2023 the court sat fifty-two times and he was absent for thirty-six of them. Court staff testified the accommodation backed the docket up by three to four months. The Commission found she never reported his failure to perform his duties, and instead moved contested hearings to the afternoon so she would not have to sit with only Knapp in the morning.
Silencing a colleague’s dissent
After Knapp told her he intended to write a dissent, she delayed circulating the majority opinion for weeks and then tried to have it signed and filed before he could finish; he intercepted the signed copy in the clerk’s office in time to attach his dissent. She then directed that the court would issue only orders rather than opinions going forward, telling him he could not dissent from an order the way he could from an opinion, and later issued a written directive requiring her approval before any judge’s decision could be printed or filed. He kept drafting memoranda of dissent but was not certain they ever reached the parties or the record. She also changed rulings issued by Knapp and Duba in cases where she had not presided, which the Commission found exceeded her administrative authority as chief judge.
From an email warning to a peace order
On April 18, 2024 she emailed a court-wide guideline threatening further action without additional warning if judges argued in open court, then filed her first complaint against Knapp with the Commission less than an hour later. After an email exchange in which he answered a request for decorum with a vulgarity, she filed a second complaint and arranged for a security guard to sit in chambers, telling the Commission that a guard and another person thought Knapp might be intoxicated, a claim the guard’s own incident report did not support.
Over the following two weeks she sent a stream of emails to the Commission, the Judiciary’s Threat Management Center and the county sheriff, at one point describing Knapp as someone who may have a mental disability, and asking that his access to the courthouse’s rear entrance be restricted so that only he would have to pass through a metal detector. Judiciary officials repeatedly told her they had no authority to suspend a sitting judge and directed her to the sheriff or the Commission. On May 16, 2024, when Knapp chose to work in the courtroom between hearings rather than in chambers, she called the police. Responding officers found no assault and no criminal conduct, and she confirmed to the responding officer that he had only pointed and yelled. The county’s own Homeland Security and Intelligence Unit later concluded the matter was an employee conflict, not a threat.
On May 19, 2024 she filed for a peace order against Knapp and separately filed a criminal Application for Statement of Charges alleging stalking, signing each page with her chief judge title. A temporary peace order was granted, but the case was dismissed in July 2024 after it expired procedurally. She immediately filed a second peace order petition on the same conduct, and that one was denied outright in August 2024 after a full hearing, the court finding she could not meet her burden of proof. The criminal matter did proceed far enough to be set for trial, and prosecutors dropped the charges in May 2025 before it was tried.
Talking to the press about a pending case
Throughout the peace order proceedings she spoke repeatedly with reporters about her conflict with Knapp and about complaints she had filed with the Commission, including telling one reporter she was going to cry after her first peace order case was dismissed, and stating publicly that she did not feel Orphans’ Court judges’ safety was anyone’s responsibility. She also contacted Chief Justice Fader directly about the conflict. The Commission found these contacts, made while she repeatedly identified herself by her judicial title, both breached the confidentiality Maryland law requires for matters before the Commission and improperly leveraged the prestige of her office to advance her side of a personal dispute.
Fighting the process itself
The fifth category is about the disciplinary process. Despite repeated written instructions to direct all communication to Investigative Counsel, she kept copying the Commission’s Chair and Executive Counsel on substantive matters for months. She missed discovery deadlines, did not fully comply with an order compelling production, did not appear for the first day of her own hearing in August 2025 having scheduled a conflicting event, and sought to postpone until after Knapp’s case was resolved, which the Commission denied.
One filing drew particular scrutiny. In a reply brief filed the day before her hearing resumed, three cases were cited as legal support. The Commission found that none of the three citations corresponds to an actual reported Maryland decision, that the volume and page numbers in fact belong to entirely different and unrelated cases, and that the errors were consistent with citations pulled from an unreliable or automatically generated source rather than an official reporter.
Fabricated citations have now produced sanctions in courts across the country, and here they appear in a disciplinary filing by a sitting chief judge, in the category the Commission treated as her failure to cooperate candidly with the process.
Not Her First Time Before the Commission
She had a prior disciplinary history. In September 2021 she entered a Conditional Diversion Agreement with the Commission after it found she may have failed to perform judicial duties, failed to timely file tax returns and pay outstanding tax obligations, endorsed a political candidate and a business on her personal social media page, used court resources to apply for a political position, attempted to sell jewelry and insurance to court personnel, failed to timely file required financial disclosure statements for 2018 and 2019, and showed a lack of candor in her responses to Investigative Counsel. She completed the terms of that agreement in September 2022, two months before winning re-election.
Her Defense: A Claim of Disparate Treatment
She has consistently argued she was treated unfairly. In a motion to dismiss filed in July 2025 and denied before her hearing began, she wrote that what was at stake was not just missed deadlines or misunderstood rules but the Commission’s decision to prosecute the victim of violence while delaying charges against the aggressor, Judge Marc Knapp, who is white and male, and that the result was that she, the Black woman who reported the threats, faced a public hearing first. She argued the sequence sent a dangerous institutional message: the victim goes on trial before the aggressor. A related framing, that she was being retaliated against for raising workplace violence concerns, has been picked up by some local commentary.
It is her contention, made in her own filing and repeated by some sympathetic commentary, not a finding by the Commission or any court. And the Commission did address the underlying asymmetry, in mitigation rather than in her favor. It expressly considered that Knapp was the primary aggressor in their interpersonal conflicts, and then held that despite the workplace conflict, judges are always obligated to engage in conduct that does not defy the Code. The removal recommendation came after weighing that, not in ignorance of it.
The Rules She Broke
These are the rules the Commission determined she violated, as recited in the Court’s order. The Court concluded she committed one or more of them without specifying which, so treat the list as the Commission’s findings rather than as a list the Court individually adopted.
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Md. Rule 18-101.1 | A judge shall comply with the law, including the Maryland Code of Judicial Conduct. |
| Md. Rule 18-101.2 | A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the independence, integrity and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and its appearance. |
| Md. Rule 18-101.3 | A judge shall not abuse the prestige of judicial office to advance the personal or economic interests of the judge or others, or allow others to do so. |
| Md. Rule 18-102.5(a) and (b) | A judge shall perform judicial and administrative duties competently and diligently, and shall cooperate with other judges and court officials in the administration of court business. |
| Md. Rule 18-102.8(a) and (b) | A judge shall require order and decorum in proceedings, and shall be patient, dignified and courteous to those with whom the judge deals in an official capacity. |
| Md. Rule 18-102.12 | A judge shall require court staff, court officials and others subject to the judge’s direction and control to act consistently with the judge’s own obligations under the Code. |
| Md. Rule 18-102.15(a) and (b) | A judge who receives information indicating a substantial likelihood that another judge has committed a violation shall take appropriate action, and shall inform the appropriate authority of a substantial violation. |
| Md. Rule 18-102.16(a) | A judge shall cooperate and be candid and honest with judicial and lawyer disciplinary agencies. |
How It Would Work in Texas
Two of the findings against her have close Texas analogues, and one of them is a duty most judges never think about until it is too late.
The chief judge’s powers are the ones she did not have
Texas has no chief judge of a multi-judge trial court in the Maryland sense. The closest thing is the local administrative judge, whose authority comes from Chapter 74 of the Government Code and is a list of administrative functions: assigning cases, supervising the docket, managing personnel, requesting assistance from the presiding judge of the region. Case File No. 34 covers a Texas judge who learned the hard way that in a county operating a court administrator system, the staffing power belongs to the judges of the courts served collectively rather than to any one of them.
What no Texas administrative authority includes is the power to change another judge’s ruling in a case you did not hear. A judgment signed by the judge who presided is that judge’s judgment. It is corrected on motion, by that court, or on appeal. The Commission found Gipson altered rulings issued by both of her colleagues in cases where she had not presided, and found that exceeded her administrative authority. A Texas judge doing the same thing would be looking at Canon 2A, Canon 3B(2) and a mandamus, and the orders would likely be void rather than merely improper.
The duty to report another judge
Maryland Rule 18-102.15 requires a judge who learns of a substantial likelihood that another judge violated the Code to take appropriate action and to inform the appropriate authority. That is the rule Gipson broke by accommodating a colleague’s absences for months instead of reporting them.
Texas has the same duty in Canon 3D(1) of the Code of Judicial Conduct: a judge who receives information clearly establishing that another judge has committed a violation should take appropriate action. The Texas version is phrased as a should rather than a shall, and it is almost never the basis for a sanction on its own. This file is a useful reminder that in a state where it is a shall, the failure to report was one of the nine rules that cost a chief judge her seat.
Who decides
In Maryland the Commission recommends and the Supreme Court decides, which is why there is an argument, an order and an opinion to read. In Texas, the State Commission on Judicial Conduct imposes the four graded sanctions itself, and removal runs on a separate track: the Commission may recommend removal to a Review Tribunal of seven appellate justices selected by the Supreme Court of Texas, whose judgment is the final one. The practical difference is the paper trail. Maryland produces a signed opinion explaining a removal. Texas produces a tribunal judgment that rarely gets reported at all.
How This Compares to Knapp’s Case
Both judges were investigated over the same conflict and the Commission recommended removing both. Knapp’s case moved first: the Court removed him on June 4, 2026, the same day it heard argument, calling his conduct egregious. Case File No. 23 covers that case in full. Hers took longer, because her hearing was delayed twice at her own request and the Commission did not issue its recommendation until nearly a year after his.
The Commission found Knapp was the primary aggressor and said so, in mitigation of her charges. Both were still removed. Provocation was treated as context rather than excuse. Her removal did not rest on who started the feud. It rested on what she did with the powers of a chief judge once she had them, and on how she handled the disciplinary process that followed.
Three judges were elected to the Anne Arundel County Orphans’ Court in November 2022. Duba resigned in November 2024, Knapp was removed in June 2026, and Gipson was removed in October 2026. None of the three remains.
Where Things Stand Now
She is off the bench as of October 5, 2026. She did not run for re-election, and she appears nowhere in this year’s election returns. Only a few months of her term remained, which makes the removal less consequential for her tenure than for the record it leaves: a removal order rather than a quiet exit.
Knapp made the opposite choice. Three weeks after the Court removed him, he stood in the June 23, 2026 Democratic primary for the same court. In a field of four for three nominations he finished last, with 17,188 votes and 15.41 percent, behind all three candidates who advanced. He thanked his supporters afterward.
So on November 3, 2026, Anne Arundel County voters fill all three seats on this court, and not one of the judges they elected in 2022 is on the ballot. Three Democrats and three Republicans are competing for the three places, and local coverage framed the race exactly as the record warrants, as voters picking probate officials after scandals.
The Court’s full opinion still has not issued. The Gavel of Shame will update this file when it is filed.
| Facing the System in Texas?
Who signed the order in your case, and whether that judge had the authority to sign it, is not a technicality. A ruling altered by a judge who never heard the matter is a ruling worth challenging, in Maryland and in Texas alike. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
Primary sources
- Supreme Court of Maryland, Per Curiam Order, In the Matter of the Honorable Vickie Gipson, Judge of the Orphans’ Court for Anne Arundel County, JD No. 2, September Term 2025, argued and filed October 5, 2026. mdcourts.gov
- Maryland Commission on Judicial Disabilities, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Order and Recommendation, CJD 2024-051 et al., dated May 13, 2026. courts.state.md.us
- Supreme Court of Maryland, October 2026 argument schedule, listing JD No. 2 for Monday, October 5, 2026. courts.state.md.us
- Maryland State Board of Elections, Anne Arundel County primary results, June 23, 2026, Judge of the Orphans’ Court. results.elections.maryland.gov
News coverage
- Maryland Supreme Court removes Anne Arundel Orphans’ Court judge from bench, Maryland Matters (October 5, 2026). marylandmatters.org
- MD Supreme Court removes Anne Arundel Orphans’ Court judge, The Daily Record (October 5, 2026). thedailyrecord.com
- Commission recommends Anne Arundel Orphans’ Court Judge Vickie Gipson’s removal, The Daily Record (May 14, 2026). thedailyrecord.com
- Suspension, not removal, recommended for Maryland judge, The Daily Record (December 5, 2025). thedailyrecord.com
- Removed Anne Arundel orphans’ court judge thanks supporters after apparent primary loss, The Daily Record (June 24, 2026). thedailyrecord.com
- Voters to pick Anne Arundel probate officials after scandals, The Daily Record (June 17, 2026). thedailyrecord.com
- Maryland judge Vickie Gipson skips disciplinary hearing over misconduct allegations, Abusive Discretion (August 2025). abusivediscretion.com
- Questions of disparate treatment emerge following recommendation to remove Chief Judge Vickie Gipson, Report Annapolis (May 16, 2026). reportannapolis.com
Reference
- Maryland Commission on Judicial Disabilities, public actions of the Commission. courts.state.md.us
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 3D(1). txcourts.gov
- What the State Commission on Judicial Conduct can and cannot do. texasdwisite.com
This post summarizes public judicial discipline records and news reporting as of late October 2026. The Supreme Court of Maryland has ordered Gipson’s removal; its full opinion explaining that decision had not issued as of this update, and the four page order does not identify which of the charged violations the Court sustained. Court staff, security personnel, complainants and the reporters described in the findings are referred to here only by role. Judge Gipson’s claim of disparate treatment is her own contention from her own filing, not a finding by the Commission or any court. Judges Knapp and Duba are named as public officials; Judge Duba is not the subject of any sanction described here, and the findings about his attendance are findings about Gipson’s supervision of the court. This is general commentary on a public record, not legal advice.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.