Signature

Betty Lou Beets: The Signature Case

Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist
Updated
Read time 20 min
The Short Answer

Betty Lou Beets was convicted in Henderson County in October 1985 of the capital murder of her fifth husband, Dallas Fire Department captain Jimmy Don Beets, and sentenced to death. The State’s theory was that she killed him for his insurance and pension benefits (Beets v. State).To prove she was the one who shot him, prosecutors told the jury about the death of her fourth husband, Doyle Wayne Barker, whose body was found in the same yard. The Court of Criminal Appeals upheld that evidence, calling the “signature” between the two killings “close to perfect” (Beets v. State). Twenty years later, the same court cited the case as a model of signature evidence. Beets was never tried for Barker’s death. She was executed on Feb. 24, 2000 (TDCJ).

Below: the two men, the investigation, the trial, a defense lawyer with a book deal, the clemency fight, and the Texas law on signature evidence, murder for remuneration and lawyer conflicts today.

Betty Lou Beets: The Signature Case

Case No. 08

Two husbands buried in the same yard. Texas’s highest criminal court called the match “close to perfect.” The harder question was who pulled the trigger.

Case at a glance
Case Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d 711 (Tex. Crim. App. 1987) (op. on reh’g 1988); 173rd District Court, Henderson County
Where Henderson County, Texas (Gun Barrel City area, Cedar Creek Lake)
Victims Jimmy Don Beets (conviction); Doyle Wayne Barker (never tried)
Convicted of Capital murder (murder for remuneration), Oct. 11, 1985
Sentence Death, assessed Oct. 14, 1985
Status today Executed Feb. 24, 2000, at 62
How identity was proved Her children’s testimony and the “signature” of a second killing
The legal question When does a second killing prove who committed the first?
Primary source Beets v. State (Court of Criminal Appeals)

The Victims

Jimmy Don Beets joined the Dallas Fire Department in 1957 and worked his way up from driver to captain. In 1983 he was 45, commanding the No. 9 station in southeast Dallas and spending his days off at Cedar Creek Lake. He had a son, Jamie (Dallas Observer; Beets v. State). He and Betty Lou married on Aug. 19, 1982, and he died less than a year later (Dallas Observer; Beets v. State).

Doyle Wayne Barker, a construction worker, was her fourth husband. He disappeared in October 1981 (Dallas Observer; Beets v. State). His remains were found in 1985, and his son, Rodney Barker, witnessed her execution (CBS News). She was charged in his death but never tried, so this post describes what witnesses testified about it, not what a jury found (AP; CBS News).

The Case

Before Texas

Betty Lou Dunevant was born on March 12, 1937, in North Carolina, the daughter of sharecroppers. The family moved to Newport News, Virginia, when she was five, and that year an illness left her with profound hearing loss. The Dallas Observer reported that it was measles; Amnesty International later said meningitis (TDCJ; Dallas Observer; Amnesty International). She said her father drank and hit her, and court records showed that her mother was hospitalized for years with mental illness (Dallas Observer).

In 1952, at 15, she left the ninth grade to marry Robert Branson. They had six children and moved to Mesquite. She filed for divorce in December 1969, accusing him of cruel treatment (Dallas Observer).

Five Husbands

In 1970 she married Bill Lane, a house painter. On Jan. 17, 1972, she shot him at her apartment in Hutchins. She said he had broken down the door; Lane told deputies she had called him there. She was charged with assault with intent to murder, but the charge was reduced to a misdemeanor after Lane signed an affidavit saying he was at fault, and Lane paid her $100 fine (Dallas Observer). At her capital trial she admitted the misdemeanor conviction (Beets v. State). The two remarried and divorced again in 1973 (Dallas Observer).

She married Ronnie Threlkeld in February 1978. She later accused him of beating her; he said he slapped her once during an argument (Dallas Observer). That October she married Doyle Wayne Barker and moved to Cedar Creek Lake. They divorced in July 1980 and remarried in July 1981. In October 1981 Barker was gone. Betty Lou said that after yet another beating he had walked out to buy cigarettes and never came back (Dallas Observer). Her daughter Shirley later testified to a different account (Beets v. State).

Jimmy Don

She met Jimmy Don Beets in the summer of 1982 at a club in Seven Points, and they married that August (Dallas Observer). Around 10 p.m. on Aug. 6, 1983, customers at the Redwood Beach Marina on Cedar Creek Lake, where she worked, saw an empty boat drifting. Inside was a fishing license in Jimmy Don’s name. She identified the boat and told a deputy the next morning that he had gone fishing and had been having trouble with the boat (Beets v. State). Firefighters searched the lake for weeks, and his body was never found (Beets v. State; Dallas Observer). His son told searchers he did not believe his father had ever been in the boat (Dallas Observer).

In the months that followed, according to the trial record, a fire department chaplain learned that Jimmy Don’s life was insured for about $110,000 and that his widow could receive about $1,200 a month in pension benefits. Betty Lou was the named beneficiary of an $86,000 policy through the city. In March 1985 a court issued letters naming her to handle his estate, and a pension settlement worth $15,852.59 plus $790.42 a month was set to be finalized in June 1985. It was canceled after her arrest. Other than salary checks and the money from selling his boat, the court noted, she received nothing from his death (Beets v. State).

The Investigation

In the spring of 1985, Henderson County sheriff’s investigator Rick Rose got a tip from an informant (Beets v. State). Investigators talked to one of her daughters, who had heard from her brother Robbie that their mother killed Jimmy Don (Dallas Observer). On June 8, 1985, Mansfield police arrested Betty Lou at Rose’s request. Rose then got a search warrant for her property near Gun Barrel City (Beets v. State; CBS News).

Jimmy Don’s remains were found in the front yard, beneath a wishing-well planter. Barker’s were found in the backyard, under a storage shed. A firearms examiner testified that bullets recovered with both men had been fired from a .38 caliber weapon, the caliber of a collector’s pistol in evidence, but he could not say they came from that pistol (Beets v. State). She was charged with two murders and held on $1 million bond (Dallas Observer). On July 11, 1985, she was indicted for capital murder, accused of killing Jimmy Don for remuneration (Texas Attorney General).

Her Children

Two of her children became the State’s key witnesses. Her son Robbie Branson testified that she told him she planned to kill Jimmy Don and wanted him gone when she did it, and that he helped her bury Jimmy Don and set the boat adrift so the death would look like an accident (Dallas Observer; Beets v. Scott). The trial judge told the jury Robbie was an accomplice as a matter of law, so his testimony needed corroboration (Beets v. State).

Her daughter Shirley Stegner testified that her mother told her of the plan beforehand and said afterward that she and Robbie had buried Jimmy Don. Shirley had herself been charged in Barker’s death, and her bond had been cut from $1 million to $5,000, but she said she had been promised nothing for her testimony (Beets v. State). A federal court later found that no promises of leniency were made to either child, noting that years later no charges had been pursued against them (Beets v. Collins).

The Trial

Trial began in early October 1985 in the 173rd District Court in Athens. District Attorney Billy M. Bandy prosecuted. Beets was represented by E. Ray Andrews, a lawyer who had represented her since the early 1980s, and Gilbert M. Hargrave (Beets v. State; Beets v. Scott). The defense had two answers: Robbie was the real shooter, and even if she was involved, the killing was not “for remuneration” (Beets v. Scott). Beets testified that Robbie shot Jimmy Don and that she only helped hide the body. “I loved Jimmy Don,” she told the jury. “Nobody’s ever been as good to me as he was” (Beets v. State).

The judge first kept the Barker evidence out as too prejudicial. After Shirley testified outside the jury’s presence that her mother had told her in October 1981 she was going to kill Barker, and that Shirley helped dispose of his body, the judge let the jury hear it. Investigator Rose was also allowed to testify that both children had told him their mother killed Barker. The jury was instructed to consider the Barker evidence only on who killed Jimmy Don (Beets v. State).

On Oct. 11, 1985, the jury convicted her of capital murder (Beets v. Scott). Neither side presented evidence at the punishment phase. The jury answered yes to the two special issues submitted to it, and on Oct. 14 she was sentenced to death (Beets v. State; Texas Attorney General).

The Lawyer’s Contract

On Oct. 8, 1985, just after trial began, Beets signed a contract giving all literary and media rights to her story to Andrews’ son (Beets v. Scott; Beets v. Collins). Andrews had also helped her with the insurance and estate matters at the center of the State’s remuneration theory, which made him a potential witness on whether she even knew about the benefits. And he had represented Robbie, the son he was now accusing of murder, in an earlier burglary case (Beets v. State).

“Particularly in a capital murder case,” a Fifth Circuit panel wrote, “it is odious to think that counsel hopes to gain his fee by marketing the tragedy and misery of his client, her family and, worst, the victim and his loved ones.” The panel called the contract “almost surely unethical” (Beets v. Collins). The State Bar never disciplined Andrews for it (Beets v. Scott).

Appeals

In November 1987 the Court of Criminal Appeals reversed. Killing a spouse to collect insurance, the court held, was not murder for remuneration; the statute was aimed at murder for hire. It ordered an acquittal of capital murder (Beets v. State). The State asked for rehearing, and on Sept. 21, 1988, the court changed its mind. A person commits murder for remuneration, the new majority held, when he “kills a victim in order to receive a benefit or financial settlement paid upon the death of the victim, such as proceeds of insurance and retirement benefits” (Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d at 737). Four judges dissented. “The difference between then and now,” Judge Teague wrote, “is absolutely nothing more than the protean opinion of a few judges regarding the meaning of an English word” (Beets v. State).

In 1991 a federal district judge granted habeas relief, finding that Andrews should have withdrawn to testify for her rather than represent her (Beets v. Scott). A Fifth Circuit panel reversed in 1993 (Beets v. Collins). In 1995 the full Fifth Circuit, voting 8-5, held that a lawyer’s conflict between his own interests and his client’s is judged under the ordinary ineffective-assistance standard, not the stricter rule for lawyers representing clients with conflicting interests, and found no deficient performance and no prejudice (Beets v. Scott). In 1999 the Fifth Circuit rejected her argument that she had no fair warning the remuneration statute covered her conduct: the reading was “the everyday meaning of the words used by the legislature” (Beets v. Johnson).

Clemency and Execution

By 2000 her lawyers, led by Joseph Margulies, argued that she had been abused by her father and her husbands and that no jury had heard that evidence (AP; Christian Science Monitor). Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and domestic violence advocates asked Gov. George W. Bush to stop the execution (Amnesty International; Human Rights Watch; CBS News). Her daughters showed the parole board photographs they said showed her battered and bruised (CBS News). Jamie Beets answered for his father, saying he wanted people to know “that he was a good person and that he didn’t beat nobody” (CBS News). A Fifth Circuit panel noted that there was “no record evidence that she was abused by this victim” (Beets v. Texas Bd. of Pardons & Paroles). Asked about the killing, Beets said she could not remember it (Christian Science Monitor).

The Board of Pardons and Paroles denied clemency on Feb. 22, 2000. Under Texas law the governor could not commute her sentence without the board’s recommendation; he could only grant one 30-day reprieve (Christian Science Monitor). Bush declined: “After careful review of the evidence in the case, I concur with the jury that Betty Lou Beets is guilty of this murder” (CBS News).

She was executed in Huntsville at 6:18 p.m. on Feb. 24, 2000. She was 62, the fourth woman executed in the United States since 1976 and the second in Texas since the Civil War (AP; TDCJ). She declined to make a final statement (TDCJ). At her request, none of her children attended (CNN).

How the Case Was Built

  • Her son’s testimony. Robbie described the plan, the burial and the staged boating accident. As an accomplice, he needed corroboration (Beets v. State).
  • Her daughter’s testimony. Shirley described her mother’s statements before and after the killing. The court held she was not an accomplice to Jimmy Don’s death as a matter of law (Beets v. State).
  • The graves. Acting on an informant’s tip, investigators found both bodies on her property (Beets v. State).
  • The money. Insurance and pension records, and her efforts to collect, supported the remuneration theory (Beets v. State).
  • The bullets. A .38 caliber weapon, but no match to a specific gun (Beets v. State).
  • The Barker killing. Admitted to prove she, not Robbie, was the shooter (Beets v. State).
Signature evidence in Texas

Texas Rule of Evidence 404(b) bars proof of other crimes to show that a person acted in keeping with bad character. The same evidence may come in for another purpose, such as motive, plan, identity, or absence of mistake or accident (Tex. R. Evid. 404(b)).

To prove identity, the other crime and the charged crime must share details so distinctive that they mark both as the work of one person. Similarities that are typical of that kind of crime are not enough. Sometimes a single unusual detail is. The evidence must still survive Rule 403 balancing. Segundo v. State, 270 S.W.3d 79, 88-90 (Tex. Crim. App. 2008).

The Signature Question

On rehearing, the Court of Criminal Appeals held that identity was in dispute because the defense had tried “to place Branson’s finger upon the trigger of the murder weapon.” The State had charged Beets with killing for remuneration, not with hiring someone, so it had to prove she was the one who fired (Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d at 739).

The court then set the standard: the accused’s “‘signature’ must be apparent from a comparison of circumstances in both cases.” And it found one. “In the case at bar, the ‘signature’ is close to perfect.” The court pointed to a similar and unusual .38 caliber weapon, men shot late at night while they slept, the same apparent financial motive, and the same cover-up: both bodies wrapped in sleeping bags and buried in her yard, under “[i]nnocuous-looking structures,” in holes dug in advance for a barbecue pit and a wishing-well planter (Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d at 740). Twenty years later, Segundo cited this passage as its example of a true signature: “the same unique weapon, the same financial motive, the same late time of day, and the same yard to dispose of bodies in two different murders” (Segundo, 270 S.W.3d at 88 n.21).

Judge Teague’s answer, in a dissent when the court refused to reconsider, is the reason this case still matters to defense lawyers. He agreed that identity was in dispute. His point was that the Barker evidence did not resolve the dispute: nothing in the record made it more likely that she, rather than Robbie, had killed Barker. “[H]ad the State elected to prosecute Branson for the murder,” he wrote, “it surely would have been permitted by this Court to offer the extraneous offense against him for exactly the same purpose as it was offered against appellant.” Under the court’s own precedent, he said, the State had to prove by clear and convincing evidence that she committed the Barker killing, and that proof generally had to be better than the proof on the charged killing. “Otherwise, evidence of the extraneous offense is merely redundant on the question of identity” (Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d at 758-59 (Teague, J., dissenting from denial of reh’g)).

A signature shows that the same person committed both crimes. It does not, by itself, show who that person is. The match between the two graves was strong. What tied the Barker killing to Betty Lou and not to Robbie was, again, the word of her children.

The 1985 trial predated Texas’s criminal rules of evidence, and the 1988 opinion applied the older case-law test for extraneous offenses without citing Rule 404(b) (Beets v. State). Today a Texas judge must also find, before the jury hears about another offense, that a jury could reasonably find beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed it. Harrell v. State, 884 S.W.2d 154, 160-61 (Tex. Crim. App. 1994). That is the threshold where Teague’s question would now be fought.

What the Defense Could Have Tested

  • Who fired, in both killings. The signature linked the two deaths; it did not choose between the two people who knew where the bodies were. Make the State prove the extraneous killing to the Harrell standard before the jury hears it.
  • The investigator’s account of what the children said. When a witness repeats what others told him about an uncharged killing, object on hearsay grounds, and on confrontation grounds if the person quoted does not testify. In Beets, the investigator told the jury both children said their mother killed Barker (Beets v. State).
  • The children’s exposure. Shirley was charged in Barker’s death and her bond dropped from $1 million to $5,000. Courts found no promises, but a witness’s pending charge is always fair ground for cross-examination (Beets v. State; Beets v. Collins).
  • What she knew about the money. Remuneration requires proof that the defendant killed to get a benefit. Andrews told a federal habeas court she had seemed unaware of the benefits when she came to him, but the Fifth Circuit held he could not speak to what she knew when Jimmy Don died, and that the chaplain’s testimony showed she already knew (Beets v. Collins; Beets v. Scott). Knowledge of the benefit is the element to attack first.
  • Her own lawyer. A lawyer whose son holds the book rights, who may be a witness, and who once represented the State’s key witness has three reasons to be somewhere else. See the Texas rule below.
  • Mitigation. No punishment evidence was offered at all. The Fifth Circuit said she never gave Andrews any hint of abuse (Beets v. Collins); her later lawyers said her family had asked him to raise it (CNN). Today’s mitigation investigation does not wait to be told; see The Mitigation Investigation.

How It Works in Texas

Murder for remuneration. Penal Code § 19.03(a)(3) still makes it capital murder to commit murder “for remuneration or the promise of remuneration.” Under Beets, that includes killing to collect insurance or retirement benefits (Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d at 737). Later cases require the State to offer “some evidence of the defendant’s intent or state of mind as related to an expectation of remuneration.” Rice v. State, 805 S.W.2d 432, 434 (Tex. Crim. App. 1991); see Urbano v. State, 837 S.W.2d 114, 116 (Tex. Crim. App. 1992). For how capital cases are tried, see Capital Murder in Texas.

Accomplice testimony. “A conviction cannot be had upon the testimony of an accomplice unless corroborated by other evidence tending to connect the defendant with the offense committed; and the corroboration is not sufficient if it merely shows the commission of the offense.” Code Crim. Proc. art. 38.14. For what can go wrong when a case rests on a cooperating witness, see Justin Wolfe in our Years Lost series.

Lawyers and book deals. Before the case is over, a Texas lawyer “shall not make or negotiate an agreement with a client, prospective client, or former client giving the lawyer literary or media rights to a portrayal or account based in substantial part on information relating to the representation.” Tex. Disciplinary R. Prof’l Conduct 1.08(c). In the Fifth Circuit, a conflict between a lawyer’s own interests and his client’s is judged under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984), which requires the defendant to prove deficient performance and prejudice, rather than the presumed-prejudice rule of Cuyler v. Sullivan, 446 U.S. 335 (1980). Beets v. Scott, 65 F.3d 1258, 1265-66, 1272 (5th Cir. 1995) (en banc). The Supreme Court, quoting that decision, has said the Sullivan rule does not clearly support extending it beyond conflicts between clients, and has left the question open. Mickens v. Taylor, 535 U.S. 162, 174-76 (2002).

The death penalty statute. Beets’s jury answered two questions: deliberateness and future dangerousness (Beets v. State). For offenses committed on or after Sept. 1, 1991, the deliberateness question is gone. Jurors who find future dangerousness must then decide whether mitigating circumstances warrant a life sentence, now life without parole, instead of death (Code Crim. Proc. art. 37.071).

Clemency. The governor may grant a reprieve, commutation or pardon only on the written recommendation of a majority of the Board of Pardons and Paroles, and may grant one reprieve of up to 30 days on his own in a capital case (Tex. Const. art. IV, § 11; Code Crim. Proc. art. 48.01). See A Last-Minute Confession Before a Texas Execution.

Where Things Stand Now

Beets was never tried for Doyle Wayne Barker’s death; after her death sentence, that case did not go forward (CBS News; AP). As of 1993, no charges had been pursued against her children (Beets v. Collins). Andrews, the Christian Science Monitor reported, “was later convicted and disbarred for soliciting a bribe” in another matter (Christian Science Monitor).

Her daughter, now Shirley Furgala, told her story on Investigation Discovery’s Evil Lives Here in 2020 (TVmaze). The case is the subject of Irene Pence’s 2001 book Buried Memories (Open Library), Glenna Whitley’s 1995 Dallas Observer story “Death Row Granny” (Dallas Observer), and Margulies’s own account, “Memories of an Execution” (NACDL). For another case where other killings were used to prove identity, see Coral Eugene Watts in this series, and for the stakes when a capital conviction is wrong, see Wrongful Convictions and the Irreversible Death Penalty.

Sources

Primary source

  • Beets v. State, 767 S.W.2d 711 (Tex. Crim. App. 1987) (op. on reh’g 1988). courtlistener.com

Court records, statutes and rules

News coverage and other accounts

  • Glenna Whitley, “Death Row Granny,” Dallas Observer, Jan. 26, 1995. dallasobserver.com
  • Texas Attorney General media advisory (Feb. 11, 2000) and AP execution coverage (Feb. 24, 2000), as reproduced by the Clark County Prosecuting Attorney. clarkprosecutor.org
  • Human Rights Watch, “Governor Bush Urged to Stay Execution,” Feb. 22, 2000. hrw.org
  • CBS News, “Texas Executes Betty Lou Beets,” Feb. 24, 2000. cbsnews.com
  • Scott Baldauf, “Texas execution shows Bush’s limited role,” Christian Science Monitor, Feb. 24, 2000. csmonitor.com
  • CNN transcripts, Feb. 24, 2000. cnn.com; cnn.com
  • Amnesty International, AMR 51/19/00, Jan. 31, 2000. amnesty.org
  • Amnesty International, AMR 51/35/00, Feb. 25, 2000. amnesty.org
  • Joseph Margulies, “Memories of an Execution,” The Champion, Dec. 2000. nacdl.org
  • Open Library, listing for Irene Pence, Buried Memories (2001). openlibrary.org
  • TVmaze, Evil Lives Here, season 8, episode 4 (2020). tvmaze.com

This post describes Betty Lou Beets’s conviction using court records and published reporting. She was charged with but never tried for the death of Doyle Wayne Barker; that killing is described through trial testimony and the appellate court’s ruling on its admission, not as a separate conviction. Claims of abuse are attributed to the people who made them. This post is offered for general information about Texas law, is not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Where We Defend
Criminal Defense

Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.

Subscribe via RSSGet new DWI guides in your reader
Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By

Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist

She holds a Master of Science in Pharmaceutical Science and a Graduate Certificate in Forensic Toxicology, both from the University of Florida. She is the author of The Texas DWI Manual and has defended Texas DWI cases since 1994.

Full profile and credentials →

Your Defense Starts Now

Facing a Serious Charge in Texas?

When the State builds its case on a pattern, a lab result or a confession, every link has to be tested. Deandra Grant Law defends clients from offices in Dallas, Fort Worth, Allen, Denton, Waco and Rockwall.

3300 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75219
(214) 225-7117
4500 Airport Freeway, Suite 101
Fort Worth, TX 76117
(817) 631-6522
605 Austin Avenue, Suite 5
Waco, TX 76701
(254) 735-3588
1333 W. McDermott Drive, Suite 180
Allen, TX 75013
(972) 848-8828
1101 Ridge Road, Suite 201
Rockwall, TX 75087
(469) 253-6999
1317 E. McKinney Street, Suite 101A
Denton, TX 76209
(940) 600-5536
No Cost · No Obligation

Request a Free Case Evaluation

Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.