Years Lost

Cornelius Dupree Jr.: 30 Years on One Witness’s Word

Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist
Updated
Read time 13 min
The Short Answer

In November 1979, a young couple was abducted at gunpoint outside a Dallas liquor store. The man was forced out of the car, and the woman was raped by two men. A week later police stopped Cornelius Dupree Jr., 20, and Anthony Massingill, 18, because they resembled two men wanted in a different sexual assault. The woman picked both from a photo lineup; her companion and two store employees did not. Dupree was convicted of aggravated robbery in 1980 and sentenced to 75 years. He was denied parole for years because he would not enter a sex offender program that required admitting guilt. In 2010, DNA testing of pubic hair evidence that had happened to survive found two male profiles, neither his nor Massingill’s. He had been paroled eight days earlier, after about 30 years. A Dallas County judge declared him free in January 2011, and the Court of Criminal Appeals granted relief that March.Below: how one shaken witness’s identification carried a 75-year sentence, how the evidence that cleared him survived, and what Texas has changed about lineups since.

Cornelius Dupree Jr.: 30 Years on One Witness’s Word

Her companion could not pick him out. Two store clerks could not either. One witness did, and it held for three decades, until a few hairs that should not have survived proved her wrong.

Case No. 14 • Dallas County, Texas30years in Texas custody for a robbery and rape DNA later showed were committed by two other men
Case at a Glance
Name Cornelius Dupree Jr.
Where Dallas, Dallas County, Texas
Convicted of Aggravated robbery, 1980; sentenced to 75 years. He was never tried on the rape
Years lost About 30 years, from his arrest on December 1, 1979, to his release on parole on July 22, 2010
What went wrong A single eyewitness identification by a victim who had not been wearing her glasses; three other people shown his photo who did not identify him; a parole system that required him to admit the crime
How it came apart The Innocence Project found surviving evidence in 2007; DNA testing completed in 2010 excluded both him and his co-defendant
Status today Exonerated. Declared free by a Dallas County judge January 4, 2011; the Court of Criminal Appeals granted relief on actual innocence March 2, 2011
Texas law in play Eyewitness identification procedures (Art. 38.20); preservation of biological evidence (Art. 38.43); post-conviction DNA testing (Ch. 64); actual innocence on habeas (Art. 11.07, Ex parte Elizondo)

The Road to Exoneration

  1. Done: ConvictedJury verdict, 1980
  2. Done: Conviction set asideMarch 2, 2011
  3. Done: ReleasedJuly 22, 2010, on parole
  4. Done: Charges dismissed or acquittedNot retried after the 2011 ruling
  5. Where it stands: ExoneratedActual innocence, March 2, 2011
  6. Done: CompensatedYes

He walked out on parole before the DNA results came back. He refused, for 30 years, to say he did something he had not done.

What Happened

On November 23, 1979, a young couple stopped at a liquor store on Dolphin Road in Dallas to buy cigarettes and use a pay phone. Two men, one with a pistol, forced them back into their car, made the man drive away, and robbed them. At a nearby park the man was forced out. Both attackers raped the woman, who was 26. They took her driver’s license and her rabbit-fur coat, and she was later found unconscious on the side of a highway.

A week later, on December 1, police stopped Cornelius Dupree Jr., 20, and Anthony Massingill, 18, about two miles from where the couple had been abducted. Officers had stopped them because they resembled two men wanted in a different sexual assault. Massingill was carrying a pistol. Both were arrested.

How the Case Was Built

The next day the couple looked at a photo lineup. The woman picked out both Dupree and Massingill. Her companion could not identify either man. Later, police showed the photos to two women who worked at a grocery store about two miles away, where two men had tried to sell the stolen coat. Neither identified Dupree or Massingill.

The identification had problems the jury could have weighed. According to the Innocence Project, the woman had not been wearing her prescription glasses during the attack, and at an identification hearing, with both defendants in the courtroom, she mistook Massingill’s photo for Dupree’s. Her companion explained his failure to identify anyone by saying his vision had been slightly impaired when he viewed the lineup. It was also a cross-racial identification: according to the Registry, the couple were white and the two men were African American. At trial, both of them identified Dupree and Massingill.

Dupree was convicted of aggravated robbery and sentenced to 75 years. He was never tried for the rape; according to the National Registry of Exonerations, prosecutors did not believe a rape conviction would add prison time. Massingill was convicted and was also sentenced to life for a separate 1979 rape-robbery. The Fifth Court of Appeals in Dallas affirmed Dupree’s conviction in 1982.

Thirty Years

According to the Innocence Project, Dupree filed three habeas petitions over the years, and each time he was denied a new trial. Parole was the other way out, and it came with a condition he would not meet. According to the Registry, earlier chances at parole were denied because he refused to take part in a sex offender rehabilitation program. According to the Innocence Project, that program required him to admit guilt. As Innocence Project attorney Nina Morrison later put it to the Dallas Morning News, he could have been paroled earlier had he admitted the crime, and he refused.

He wrote to the Innocence Project in New York. In 2006 and 2007, with the cooperation of the Dallas County District Attorney’s office, the project searched for evidence. Most of it was gone. The vaginal swabs and other samples had been lost or destroyed. What remained were pubic hair combings and cuttings from the victim’s rape examination. “It’s really a miracle it was saved,” Morrison said.

How It Came Apart

In July 2008 the Innocence Project asked District Attorney Craig Watkins’s office to test what remained, and in 2009 the office agreed. The evidence went to Forensic Science Associates, a private laboratory in California, which found DNA from two men on the surviving hair evidence. In a report dated July 30, 2010, the laboratory excluded both Dupree and Massingill. Confirmation testing was completed in December.

Eight days before that first report, on July 22, 2010, Dupree had been released on parole, after about 30 years. On January 4, 2011, in Criminal District Court No. 2 in Dallas County, Judge Don Adams accepted the papers both sides had filed, declared him innocent and told him, “You are free to go.” Dupree, 51, said it was “a joy to be free again,” and that “the system needs to be fixed” so it would not happen to anyone else.

On March 2, 2011, the Court of Criminal Appeals granted relief. The trial court had found that “no rational jury would have convicted Applicant in light of the new evidence,” and the court noted that the evidence from post-conviction DNA testing and investigation “indicates that it was another individual, and not Applicant, who committed this offense” (Ex parte Dupree, No. AP-76,504 (Tex. Crim. App. Mar. 2, 2011) (per curiam) (not designated for publication)). The court set the conviction aside on actual innocence grounds. Judge Meyers dissented, and Judge Keasler did not participate. He was never retried.

Where Things Stand Now

When he was cleared, the Dallas Morning News reported that he had served the longest prison term of any Texas inmate cleared through DNA evidence. The Innocence Project’s Barry Scheck put it more broadly, calling it the “largest number of years anyone has ever served in the state of” Texas for a crime he did not commit.

Anthony Massingill’s case took longer. With the support of the Dallas County District Attorney’s Conviction Integrity Unit, he filed for habeas relief in 2014. In September 2014 the Court of Criminal Appeals set aside two of his convictions and ordered a new punishment hearing in his separate rape case, because testimony at his original punishment hearing about his guilt in the cleared cases had been shown false. On Oct. 17, 2014, prosecutors dismissed the November 1979 robbery charge. He remained in prison on the other conviction.

By the Dallas Morning News’s count, Dupree’s was the 21st exoneration in Dallas County. Two of the others are in this series: Richard Miles (Case No. 12) and Martin Santillan (Case No. 35), whose case also turned on a single eyewitness.

How Texas Law Answers It

This one happened in Texas. The question is what has changed since 1980, and what has not.

Lineups now have rules

The day Dupree was declared free, according to KERA, District Attorney Watkins said his priority for the coming legislative session was eyewitness identification standards for every police department in the state, and that he wanted them “required.” That session, the Legislature passed House Bill 215, which created Article 38.20. Every Texas law enforcement agency whose officers conduct photo or live lineups must now have a written policy based on credible research on eyewitness memory and on practices designed to reduce erroneous identifications. From the start, that policy had to address how fillers are chosen, what the witness is told, how the result is documented and preserved whatever it is, how a lineup is conducted for a witness who cannot read or has limited English, and who runs the lineup. For a live lineup that meant, if practicable, an administrator who does not know which person is the suspect, or other procedures designed to keep anyone from influencing the witness. For a photo array it meant an administrator who can run it blind or in another way consistent with proven or supported best practices. House Bill 34 made it more specific in 2017. An agency’s policy must now include procedures for choosing fillers who are consistent in appearance with the description of the perpetrator and do not make the suspect noticeably stand out, and witness instructions that include a statement that the person who committed the offense may or may not be present. The bill also added a direct command: a witness who makes an identification must be asked, immediately after the procedure, to state in her own words how confident she is, and the agency must document what she says.

The statute has limits. Under Section 5, failing to follow the policy does not bar an identification from evidence, except as Section 5(c) provides. But under Section 5(c), added in 2017, when a witness who made an earlier lineup identification identifies the defendant in court, that identification is admissible only if it comes with the details of each prior identification, “including the manner in which the identification procedure was conducted.” Under today’s law, in a case like Dupree’s, the woman’s courtroom identification would be admissible against him only if it came with the details of each earlier identification she made, including how each procedure was conducted.

Evidence has to be kept

What freed Dupree survived by luck. Texas first required the State to preserve biological evidence after a conviction in 2001, in a provision renumbered as Article 38.43 in 2005 and expanded in 2011 to reach every agency that handles biological evidence in a felony case, including police, prosecutors, courts, public hospitals and crime labs. After a conviction with a prison sentence, the evidence must generally be kept until the defendant dies, completes the sentence or is released on parole or mandatory supervision. Before the prosecutor, clerk or other officer holding it can destroy it, notice must go by mail to the defendant, his last lawyer of record and the convicting court, and a timely written objection from any of them stops destruction by that route. Since 2019, the contents of a sexual assault kit collected in a felony investigation must be kept for at least 40 years, or longer if the statute of limitations runs longer, whether or not anyone has been charged. None of that existed in 1979, and by the time anyone looked in Dupree’s case, the swabs were gone.

Testing and the innocence writ

Dupree’s testing came through the District Attorney’s cooperation, not a court order. Without that cooperation, the route is Chapter 64, which lets a convicted person ask the convicting court to order DNA testing. The court must find that the evidence still exists in testable condition with a sufficient chain of custody, that it likely contains biological material suitable for testing, and that identity was or is an issue. The convicted person must also show by a preponderance of the evidence that he would not have been convicted if exculpatory results had been obtained, and that the request is not made to unreasonably delay his sentence or the administration of justice. If testing clears him, the claim goes forward on habeas under Article 11.07. When the Court of Criminal Appeals granted Dupree relief, it cited the case that sets the standard: an applicant must show “by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable juror would have convicted him in light of the new evidence” (Ex parte Elizondo, 947 S.W.2d 202, 209 (Tex. Crim. App. 1996)).

When the case is one witness

Find out everyone who saw the lineup and everyone who did not pick your client. A companion who could not identify anyone, store employees who saw the men selling the stolen coat and did not choose your client, a witness who was not wearing her glasses: each is evidence, and each belongs in front of the jury.

What This Means If You Are Charged in Texas

  • Get the whole identification record. Ask for the lineup itself, the instructions, who ran it, what the witness said about her confidence, and every other witness who viewed it.
  • Count the people who did not identify your client. A failed identification is not an absence of evidence. It is evidence.
  • Ask about the conditions. Lighting, distance, stress, a weapon, glasses, how long the witness saw the person. These are the facts that make an honest witness wrong.
  • Make sure the evidence is preserved. Request preservation of biological evidence early, and answer any notice of destruction under Article 38.43 in writing.
  • Know that parole may ask you to admit guilt. A sex offender treatment requirement can collide with a claim of innocence. Talk to a lawyer before deciding how to respond.

The Bottom Line

Cornelius Dupree was convicted on the identification of one frightened woman who had been attacked at gunpoint, was not wearing her glasses, and later confused his photograph with his co-defendant’s. Three other people shown his photograph did not pick him. He spent 30 years in prison and turned down the easier way out because it required saying he did it. What freed him was a handful of hair cuttings that happened to survive after the rest of the evidence was lost. Texas now regulates lineups and requires that biological evidence be kept. Neither change helps unless someone asks how an identification was made, and makes sure the evidence is still there to test.

Sources

Case record and reporting

  • Ex parte Dupree, No. AP-76,504 (Tex. Crim. App. Mar. 2, 2011) (per curiam) (not designated for publication). courtlistener.com
  • Ex parte Massingill, Nos. WR-13,685-05 & -06 (Tex. Crim. App. Sept. 17, 2014) (per curiam) (not designated for publication). courtlistener.com
  • Ex parte Massingill, No. WR-13,685-07 (Tex. Crim. App. Sept. 17, 2014) (per curiam) (not designated for publication). courtlistener.com
  • Cornelius Dupree Jr., National Registry of Exonerations, Case No. 10426. exonerationregistry.org
  • Anthony Massingill, National Registry of Exonerations, Case No. 11669. exonerationregistry.org
  • Cornelius Dupree, Innocence Project. innocenceproject.org
  • “DNA clears 2 men in 1979 Dallas robbery, rape,” Dallas Morning News (Jan. 4, 2011). dallasnews.com
  • “Innocent man exonerated after 30 years in prison,” KERA News (Jan. 4, 2011). keranews.org

Texas law

This post is an informational synthesis for educational purposes and is not legal advice. It is based on the Court of Criminal Appeals’ 2011 opinion, the records compiled by the National Registry of Exonerations and the Innocence Project, and contemporaneous reporting, and on the Texas statutes and cases cited, as available in November 2026. The victims are described by role. Case citations should be independently verified against the official record before use in any filing.

Where We Defend
Criminal Defense

Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.

Subscribe via RSSGet new DWI guides in your reader
Deandra M. Grant
Written & Reviewed By

Deandra M. Grant, JD, GC, MS, ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist

She holds a Master of Science in Pharmaceutical Science and a Graduate Certificate in Forensic Toxicology, both from the University of Florida. She is the author of The Texas DWI Manual and has defended Texas DWI cases since 1994.

Full profile and credentials →

Your Defense Starts Now

Facing a Serious Charge in Texas?

When the State's case is one eyewitness, how that witness came to pick your client is the case. The sooner a defense team is looking at the lineup, the conditions and the people who did not identify anyone, the more can be done. Intake answers 24/7.

3300 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75219
(214) 225-7117
4500 Airport Freeway, Suite 101
Fort Worth, TX 76117
(817) 631-6522
605 Austin Avenue, Suite 5
Waco, TX 76701
(254) 735-3588
1333 W. McDermott Drive, Suite 180
Allen, TX 75013
(972) 848-8828
1101 Ridge Road, Suite 201
Rockwall, TX 75087
(469) 253-6999
1317 E. McKinney Street, Suite 101A
Denton, TX 76209
(940) 600-5536
No Cost · No Obligation

Request a Free Case Evaluation

Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.