Judge Michael Fanning Resigns Under a Letter of Counsel
On October 15, 2026, the Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania announced that Judge Michael Fanning of the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas had accepted a public Letter of Counsel resolving two complaints, File Nos. 2025-622 and 2026-178. A Letter of Counsel is a dismissal, not a sanction. The Board issues one when it has enough evidence to file formal charges but concludes that charges are not the right disposition, and it can only be issued if the judge accepts it and its terms. The terms here were steep: Fanning consented to the Board releasing the letter publicly and pledged to resign from the bench by September 4, 2026, and never to seek judicial office again. He accepted the letter on October 14, 2026. The two files were then dismissed and closed. The felony charges that drove the second complaint had already been withdrawn by the District Attorney’s office in July, with no finding of criminal intent and nothing litigated in the Court of Judicial Discipline.

| CASE FILE AT A GLANCE | |
| Judge | Michael Fanning |
| Court | Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania (Family Court). Appointed 2014, elected 2015, retained November 2025 |
| Matter | Judicial Conduct Board File Nos. 2025-622 and 2026-178 |
| Disposition | Public Letter of Counsel, which is a dismissal with conditions, not a sanction |
| Letter Dated | September 15, 2026, signed by Chief Counsel Melissa L. Norton |
| Accepted | October 14, 2026; announced by press release October 15, 2026 |
| Conditions | Consent to public release, resignation from the bench on or before September 4, 2026, and a pledge never to seek judicial office in the future |
| Rules Cited | Code of Judicial Conduct Rules 1.1, 1.2 and 2.16(A) |
| Interim Suspension | Without pay on the Board’s March 2026 petition (3 JD 2026); lifted July 23, 2026 after the charges were withdrawn |
| Criminal Case | Charges withdrawn July 16, 2026. No conviction, no finding, no adjudication of the underlying allegations |
| Counsel | Elizabeth A. Hoffheins, Deputy Counsel, for the Board; John S. Summers for Judge Fanning |
| WHAT A LETTER OF COUNSEL ACTUALLY IS
Pennsylvania splits judicial discipline across three bodies: the Judicial Conduct Board investigates and charges, the Court of Judicial Discipline tries the charges and imposes sanctions, and the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania reviews. A Letter of Counsel is the Board’s own off-ramp, used before the second step ever happens. The Board offers one when it decides that even if the conduct breached the rules, the violation does not necessarily merit formal charges or there are other mitigating circumstances. It can be private or public. It takes effect only if the judge accepts it and its terms, and the judge must stipulate that the letter and the facts behind it may be used in any future proceeding on a new complaint, before the Board, the Court of Judicial Discipline, or the Supreme Court. That last piece is why a dismissal is not nothing. It is a dismissal that leaves a loaded record behind it. |
Two Files
The first complaint, File No. 2025-622, began with Fanning’s own self-report of an arrest in Cape May, New Jersey on August 11, 2025. Police were called to a restaurant and marina by its manager. The Board’s letter recites allegations that he was combative with staff, was trespassing in a private area of the marina, and was intoxicated, and that when officers confronted him and told him he was the subject of an official investigation he refused to provide information, became loud and belligerent, and tried to leave against police orders. He was cited for obstructing the administration of law, graded as a disorderly persons offense. During that investigation the Board learned police had been summoned to his Cape May home on several occasions dating back to 2021 in connection with family disputes. The Board’s press release describes at least two instances of antisocial behavior in Cape May that resulted in his arrest.
The second, File No. 2026-178, followed his arrest in Philadelphia on March 10, 2026 after an alleged domestic incident involving two family members, referred to here by role only. He was charged with felony aggravated assault, felony strangulation, and two counts each of misdemeanor simple assault and misdemeanor reckless endangerment. A temporary protective order issued. On the Board’s petition, the Court of Judicial Discipline took what the Board called the extraordinary step of suspending him without pay while the charges were pending.
The Board also faulted him for something smaller and entirely separate: he did not tell the Chief Justice he was under investigation as of March 10, 2026. The letter calls that undoubtedly less serious than the rest, while saying it is incumbent on a judge to keep the Court informed of such events.
The Charges Were Withdrawn
On July 16, 2026, the District Attorney’s office withdrew all of the charges, citing extensive mitigation and a lack of cooperation from the complaining witnesses. They were dismissed without any finding of criminal intent. A week later, on July 23, the Court of Judicial Discipline lifted his suspension because the charges had been its only basis; the court system put him on administrative duty, not hearing cases, pending a decision on his assignment. No complaint was ever litigated in the Court of Judicial Discipline.
Discipline Without a Finding
The Board wrote down its reasoning instead of hiding it. The letter says the mere existence of such serious allegations of misconduct has left an irreparable stain on your judicial service, and that if he remained on the bench that stain would continue to devalue the integrity of the judiciary in the eyes of the public. It noted that although the allegations remain unproven, the effect on the judiciary has the potential to be far-reaching and injurious to its reputation.
The Board concluded that the damage to public confidence did not depend on whether the allegations were true. It rested the result on the Cape May conduct, the pattern it raised, and the reputational effect, not on a finding that he did what the withdrawn charges alleged.
The Board says it weighed the potential effect on the complaining witnesses if the matter were to proceed further. A contested disciplinary trial would have required those two family members to testify about events a prosecutor had already decided not to pursue, partly because they were not cooperating. Taking the resignation instead spared them that.
The Same Court, the Other Direction
Case File No. 54 is a judge of the same Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, investigated by the same Board, and the comparison shows the full range of what this one institution does. There the Board filed a formal complaint in the Court of Judicial Discipline over a single conversation in a robing room about another judge’s sentencing, the court took two days of testimony, and removal is on the table. Here, on conduct involving arrests in another state and a withdrawn felony case, it filed no charges and dismissed.
The difference is not severity. It is proof and posture. The robing-room conduct was provable and contested, so it went to trial. These allegations were not going to be proved by anyone, and the judge was willing to leave. A board that wants a judge off the bench will take the certain exit over the uncertain trial, which is the same calculation behind Case File No. 41 in Florida, Case File No. 49 in New Hampshire, and Case File No. 52 in Louisiana.
The Rules Cited
| Rule | What It Requires |
| Rule 1.1 | A judge shall comply with the law, including the Code of Judicial Conduct. |
| Rule 1.2 | A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety. |
| Rule 2.16(A) | A judge shall cooperate and be candid and honest with judicial and lawyer disciplinary agencies. |
How It Works in Texas
Texas reaches the same destination by a different road, and the Texas version is harder. The State Commission on Judicial Conduct can accept a voluntary agreement to resign in lieu of disciplinary action. Like a Letter of Counsel it ends the matter with no findings, and like a Letter of Counsel it requires the judge’s consent. Unlike a Letter of Counsel, the Texas agreement makes the judge forever disqualified from judicial service in the state, and the Commission publishes the list of judges who have taken one. Pennsylvania got a pledge; Texas takes an enforceable disqualification, and violating the agreement is itself a ground for discipline under Government Code section 33.001(b). Case File No. 45 covers the recent Texas example. For how the Texas process runs generally, see our explainer, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained.
The suspension piece has a close Texas parallel too. Article V, section 1-a(6)A of the Texas Constitution lets the Commission suspend a judge, with or without pay, as soon as the judge is indicted for a felony or charged with a misdemeanor involving official misconduct, and its suspension orders run until the charges are dismissed, the judge is acquitted, or the Commission orders otherwise. That is the same device Pennsylvania’s Court of Judicial Discipline used here, and Case Files No. 51 and No. 53 show it running in Texas in 2026. Note what follows when charges are withdrawn: the suspension ends, as Fanning’s did on July 23, and the judge returns to the bench unless something else happens. A conduct commission is not obliged to accept that the dismissal settles the conduct question, and the Board here did not.
One difference is worth naming precisely. Pennsylvania’s Rule 2.16(A) puts the duty to cooperate and be candid with disciplinary agencies in the code of conduct itself, and the Board cited it. The Texas Code of Judicial Conduct has no equivalent canon; Canon 3D runs the other way, obliging a judge to report another judge or a lawyer. Texas puts the duty in statute instead: Government Code section 33.001(b)(5) lists failure to cooperate with the Commission as conduct that supports discipline. A Texas judge in Fanning’s position would also be measured against Canon 2A, which says a judge shall comply with the law and should act in a manner that promotes public confidence, and Canon 4A, which requires extra-judicial conduct that does not cast reasonable doubt on the judge’s capacity to act impartially or interfere with judicial duties.
| WHEN CHARGES GET DROPPED, THE FILE DOES NOT CLOSE
A withdrawal is not an acquittal, and it is not a finding of innocence. Prosecutors withdraw for many reasons, including the two cited here, mitigation and witnesses who will not participate. None of those reasons is a determination that nothing happened, and none of them binds a licensing board, an employer or a conduct commission. Collateral bodies apply a lower standard and a different question. A criminal court asks whether the State proved an offense beyond a reasonable doubt. A conduct body asks whether the conduct, or sometimes just the existence of the allegation, damaged public confidence. The second question can be answered yes on a record that would never support the first. Expunction is the Texas tool, and it does not happen on its own. A Texas dismissal can make a person eligible to clear the arrest record under Chapter 55A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, but that is a separate proceeding with its own eligibility rules and waiting periods, and nothing is cleared until someone files it. There is a real difference between saying the charges were dismissed and saying a court found the allegations untrue. The first is accurate and defensible. The second, if it is not true, creates a new problem in whatever proceeding comes next. |
How It Played in the Press
The Philadelphia Inquirer followed the case at each step: the March arrest and the Board’s petition, the July 16 withdrawal, the July 23 order lifting the suspension, and the September 4 resignation, which it reported from a person with direct knowledge and which opened the seat to an appointment by the governor until the 2027 election. The Board’s October letter came after all of that, and the legal trade press that covered it led with the Board’s phrase irreparable stain.
By the time the public learned the terms, the resignation had happened. What the letter added was the Board’s written reasoning and the permanent pledge.
Where Things Stand Now
Fanning left the Philadelphia bench, the two complaints are dismissed and closed, and he has pledged never to seek judicial office again. The criminal case ended in July with the charges withdrawn and no finding of any kind. The one live thread is the stipulation he signed: if he violates the terms of the letter, the Board may relitigate the matter in the Court of Judicial Discipline, and the facts behind the letter come with it.
One oddity in the dates is worth noting without reading anything into it. The letter is dated September 15, 2026 and conditions the dismissal on a pledge to resign on or before September 4, 2026, a date that had already passed when the letter issued, and he did not accept it until October 14. The Inquirer reported the resignation on September 4. The resignation came first and the paperwork followed.
| Facing the System in Texas?
Charges that get dropped still leave a record, and clearing it is a separate fight. Deandra Grant Law handles state and federal criminal defense across Texas. If you are facing a DWI or criminal charge in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin, Denton, Rockwall, or McLennan County, put our experience to work for you. Call (214) 225-7117 • texasdwisite.com |
Sources
PRIMARY SOURCES
- Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania, Press Release, Judge Michael Fanning, Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas, Public Letter of Counsel (Oct. 15, 2026), together with the Letter of Counsel dated September 15, 2026 in File Nos. 2025-622 and 2026-178 and the judge’s Statement of Consent. Every quotation and every allegation described in this post comes from that letter. judicialconductboardofpa.org (pdf)
- Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania, Press Release, In re Judge Michael Fanning, 3 JD 2026 (Mar. 12, 2026), on the petition for interim suspension without pay. judicialconductboardofpa.org (pdf)
NEWS COVERAGE
- The Philadelphia Inquirer, on the withdrawal of the charges (July 16, 2026). inquirer.com
- The Philadelphia Inquirer, A Philly judge accused of domestic violence is no longer suspended after all charges were dropped (July 24, 2026). inquirer.com
- The Philadelphia Inquirer, on the resignation (Sept. 4, 2026). inquirer.com
REFERENCE
- Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, including Canon 2A, Canon 3D on reporting other judges and lawyers, and Canon 4A on extra-judicial activities. txcourts.gov (pdf)
- Tex. Gov’t Code Section 33.001(b), including (b)(5), failure to cooperate with the Commission, and (b)(6), violating a voluntary agreement to resign. Government Code ch. 33
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, resignations in lieu of disciplinary action. scjc.texas.gov
- Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, suspension orders under Article V, section 1-a(6)A of the Texas Constitution. scjc.texas.gov
- Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, Chapter 55A, expunction of criminal records. statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Deandra Grant Law, Who Polices Texas Judges? The SCJC Explained. texasdwisite.com
- This post summarizes a public judicial-discipline document for general informational purposes as of publication. It is not legal advice. A Letter of Counsel is a dismissal, not a finding of misconduct and not a sanction. The criminal charges described here were withdrawn by the District Attorney’s office on July 16, 2026 with no finding of criminal intent, no conviction, and no adjudication of the underlying allegations by any court, and nothing in this post should be read as a statement that Judge Fanning committed any offense. The allegations recited in the Board’s letter are allegations only, and the allegations underlying the withdrawn charges are deliberately not recounted here. The family members, complaining witnesses, restaurant staff and police officers referred to in the Board’s letter are described by role and are not named.
Which county your case is filed in changes how it is charged, who prosecutes it, and which court hears it.
Charged With a Crime?
Whatever you're facing, a DWI or any criminal charge, the sooner you have a forensic-trained team on it the more we can do. Tell us what happened and we'll review your options, at no cost and no obligation. Intake answers 24/7, and if your case is one we can take on, we schedule a free consultation with an attorney.
Request a Free Case Evaluation
Tell us what happened. We'll respond as soon as possible.