Firm Accolades
D Magazine
What Is a Grand Jury and Why Is It Important? 
A grand jury is a legal body that plays an essential role in felony criminal cases in Texas, including murder cases. In most criminal proceedings, a judge oversees the process and makes determinations about the charges. However, in cases involving serious crimes, such as murder, a grand jury decides whether there is enough evidence to bring a formal indictment.
In Texas, a grand jury consists of 12 citizens who are selected at random from the pool of eligible voters. These citizens are tasked with reviewing the evidence presented by the prosecutor and determining if there is enough probable cause to charge the defendant. This decision does not imply guilt or innocence—it simply determines whether the prosecution has enough evidence to proceed to trial.
For defendants facing murder charges, the grand jury’s decision can be the critical factor in whether they face a trial for a crime that could carry severe penalties.
Managing Partner
Partner & Criminal Division Chief
Criminal Trial Division
Criminal Trial Division
Of Counsel
The Grand Jury Process in Texas: Step-by-Step
1. Selection of the Grand Jury
The grand jury is made up of 12 individuals who are randomly selected from the community. The selection process can vary, but it generally involves a group of eligible voters from the area where the alleged crime occurred. The role of the grand jury is not to determine the defendant’s guilt or innocence but to review the prosecution’s evidence and decide if there is sufficient cause for a formal charge.2. Presentation of Evidence
Once the grand jury is selected, the prosecution will present the evidence gathered in the case. This may include testimonies from witnesses, physical evidence, and expert opinions. However, the defense has limited participation at this stage. The defendant does not have the right to testify or cross-examine witnesses. Only the prosecution presents its case to the grand jury. The prosecution may also present a grand jury packet, which includes detailed documentation, witness statements, and other evidence that supports their case. However, this is a crucial point where your defense strategy comes into play.3. The Role of the Defense Attorney
While the defendant does not have the opportunity to speak before the grand jury, the defense attorney can play a pivotal role by submitting a defense packet. A defense packet is a collection of documents and evidence that challenges the prosecution’s narrative, aims to cast doubt on the charges, or presents mitigating factors that could lead to the dismissal of the case. By submitting a defense packet, the attorney attempts to provide a comprehensive counter-argument to the prosecution’s claims, which may lead the grand jury to decide there is insufficient evidence to indict the defendant. A carefully crafted defense packet can influence the grand jury’s decision-making process, increasing the chances of receiving a “no bill” decision, which means no charges are filed.
"Deandra Grant Law – Criminal & DWI Defense handled my case with diligence and professionalism. Deandra Grant's reputation is stellar and now I know why. She has a team of individuals who provide quality service."
- N. Coulter
"Deandra Grant Law – Criminal & DWI Defense fights hard for their clients and is always willing to go above and beyond. They are the best firm for DWI cases in DFW and beyond. Definitely hire them to represent you in any pending cases."
- P. Williams
"Deandra Grant made a tough situation so much better. She listened to my concerns and helped me so much with my case. I would recommend her to anyone needing legal services."
- M. Haley
4. The Grand Jury’s Decision
After reviewing the evidence presented by the prosecution (and any defense materials submitted), the grand jury will deliberate and vote on whether there is probable cause to indict the defendant. A “yes” vote from at least 9 out of the 12 jurors is required for an indictment. If the grand jury returns an indictment, the case proceeds to trial. If the decision is a “no bill,” the case is dismissed, and no formal charges are filed against the defendant.When Can a Defense Packet Help?
A defense packet can be one of the most important tools in preventing an indictment or reducing charges before a formal trial begins. A well-prepared defense packet is submitted by your attorney before the grand jury makes its decision, and it serves several key purposes.1. Challenging the Evidence Against You
The primary goal of a defense packet is to provide evidence that counters the prosecution’s claims. This might include:- Alibi evidence that shows you were not present at the scene of the crime.
- Physical evidence that contradicts the prosecution’s narrative.
- Witness statements that undermine the credibility of the prosecution’s witnesses or their testimony.
Related Videos
Judge or Jury Trial?
Choosing a Criminal Defense Attorney
2. Presenting Mitigating Factors
In some cases, your attorney may include information that helps explain the circumstances surrounding the incident in question. This could include:- Mental health considerations that suggest you were not in control of your actions.
- Self-defense claims showing that your actions were in response to a threat.
- Provocation evidence that could reduce the severity of the charges, such as manslaughter instead of murder.
3. Preventing Unwarranted Charges
In some instances, the grand jury may be presented with charges that are too severe based on the available evidence. A defense packet can help ensure that the charges are tailored to fit the facts of the case and may even prevent an indictment altogether. For example, if the evidence supports a charge of manslaughter rather than first-degree murder, the defense packet can help persuade the grand jury to pursue a lesser charge.Case Results
The Importance of Timing: Preparing Early
It is essential to understand that the grand jury process moves quickly, and having a defense packet ready early can make all the difference. In Texas, grand jury hearings are often scheduled soon after an arrest, and the window for presenting a defense packet is typically brief. Working with an experienced criminal defense attorney to prepare your case ahead of time is crucial for the best possible outcome.Why You Need an Experienced Defense Attorney
Facing an indictment for murder in Texas is a serious matter, and navigating the grand jury process can be complex. While the grand jury’s role is to protect defendants from unwarranted charges, the process can be influenced by the skill of your defense attorney. A well-prepared defense packet can make a difference between dismissal and a lengthy trial. Hiring an experienced defense attorney who understands the intricacies of the Texas grand jury process can be the key to securing a favorable outcome. A skilled attorney can:- Prepare a compelling defense packet that challenges the prosecution’s evidence.
- Ensure that all mitigating factors are presented clearly and effectively.
- Advocate on your behalf before the grand jury to ensure the best possible result.