Jay Dee “B.J.” Penn III, born December 13, 1978, in Kailua, Hawaii, is a former professional mixed martial artist and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ) black belt. Known as “The Prodigy,” Penn became the first non-Brazilian to win the World Jiu-Jitsu Championship in 2000. He competed in the UFC, securing titles in both lightweight and welterweight divisions, making him one of only nine fighters to win UFC titles in multiple weight classes. A 2015 UFC Hall of Fame inductee, Penn headlined 11 major events, cementing his status as a pioneer for lighter weight divisions. However, his career has been overshadowed by a series of legal troubles spanning decades.
Details of the Arrest
Penn’s legal issues began notably in January 2015, when he was arrested in Kihei, Hawaii, for assault after a brawl outside a bar. He allegedly punched a friend, Kuuipo Mokiao, fracturing his eye socket, following a dispute at a Maui hotel. Penn was charged with assault but faced no formal conviction, and the case was resolved quietly, likely due to a lack of prosecution or settlement. In 2019, his estranged partner, Shealen Uaiwa, filed a restraining order, alleging years of physical and sexual abuse, including an incident where Penn threatened her and her family. A judge granted a temporary restraining order in October 2018, extended to 2021, allowing supervised visits with their two daughters. No criminal charges were filed in this case. That same year, Penn was involved in a bar fight in Honolulu and another on Hawaii’s Big Island, leading to his UFC release in September 2019.
Case Proceeding
In 2021, Penn was arrested for suspected DUI in Honokaa, Hawaii, after police observed signs of impairment during a reckless driving incident. He was released pending investigation, and no formal charges were confirmed. Earlier, in February 2020, a single-car accident in Hilo prompted another DUI investigation, but Penn’s team denied the vehicle flipped, and no charges were filed. In 2016, Penn faced allegations of second-degree sexual assault from a former employee’s girlfriend, but the Hilo Police Department’s investigation did not result in charges, and the UFC allowed him to continue fighting after an independent review.
Case Resolution
The most recent and troubling incidents occurred in May 2025. Penn was arrested three times in six days in Hilo, Hawaii, for abuse of a family or household member, specifically his mother, Lorraine Shin. On May 26, he was charged with “offensive physical contact” after allegedly stealing Shin’s mail, shining a flashlight in her eyes, and shoving her against a vehicle. Released on $2,000 bail, he was arrested again the next day for violating a 48-hour stay-away order by returning to Shin’s home. On May 30, a bench warrant was issued after Penn missed a court date, leading to his third arrest. He was released on $2,000 bail, with a hearing scheduled for June 10, 2025. Shin obtained a 180-day restraining order, citing “extreme psychological abuse” and alleging Penn suffers from Capgras delusional syndrome, believing she and family members are imposters. Penn’s social media posts reinforced these claims, accusing imposters of stealing family assets.
Related Videos
Biggest Mistakes of a DWI Charge
Choosing a Personal Injury Attorney
Where Are They Now?
As of June 2025, Penn, now 46, remains a fugitive per some reports, though he was released on bail after his third arrest. His next court appearance is pending, and Shin’s restraining order, effective until March 2030, includes protections for Penn’s ex-partner and children. Penn’s erratic behavior, potentially linked to mental health issues or chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), has raised concerns among fans and fighters, as seen in posts on X. He last fought in 2019, losing seven consecutive UFC bouts, and attempted a 2022 gubernatorial run in Hawaii, eliminated in the Republican primary. Penn resides in Hawaii, but his current activities are unclear amid ongoing legal and mental health challenges.
Penn’s case highlights the intersection of fame, mental health, and legal accountability. His repeated arrests and disturbing allegations suggest a need for intervention beyond legal consequences. For athletes, his story underscores the importance of addressing mental health and avoiding volatile situations that can spiral into legal battles, tarnishing even the most illustrious careers.